This restaurant was extremely busy on Saturday night Huge party in the back room numerous parties that were 10 to 12 customers at a table and yet the wait staff was prompt courteous and excellent Some of the best Italian food in our area highly recommend this restaurant
Our family ate dinner at Michael's to celebrate my mother's birthday. We all ordered baked mostaccioli. It was delicious, and the bread melted in your mouth. The waitress was great. It's our family's favorite restaurant.
Our friends told us about this place! We rode our motorcycle and did not realize they opened at five. So we sat out there thinking we were going to wait a half hour when the owner came out and told us to come on in! Awesome service and great food! Thanks again!
This is a great restaurant!! It was my first time there and I absolutely love the food!! Plus, the waitstaff was amazing and so polite. I highly recommend Michael's Italian Restaurant.
Moved out of area 6 years ago. First time back for dinner with friends. Nothing’s changed - still wonderful food and service
This has been my favorite restaurant for YEARS. I've yet to find Italian food in Florida to compare and when we are in Elkhart, I eat at Michaels as often as I can!
Susan Cooper Campanello
+5
If you haven't tried the hot bacon salad dressing you should, it is to die for, love this place
We had to wait longer than we would've liked, but the food was DELICIOUS! I highly recommend the eggplant parmasean... Great atmosphere, great service
An Elkhart classic! The food is everything you want from an Italian grandma with the atmosphere to seal the deal. Pricing is in line with the quality and experience and the service is always no nonsense! Love love love it!
Feels like home when Rico's staff takes good care of you. Had a great Xmas eve experience. Rico even danced and sang for us.
What is there not to love about this place? The owners, the staff and the food. Yummm... I bring clients here all the time and they now crave the food...
Been a life time Elkhart resident and first time ever ate at Michael's last night. We will be back soon!!! Excellent food and service friendly staff!!!
Dinner was outstanding as always, and the service was great. Meatball, onion, mushroom, black olives pizza was incredible.Stuff shells and a couple extra meatballs for desert.
Love this place!! Fantastic food (my favorite is the Eggplant Parmesan, my husband's is the Plummers pizza, my kids love the spaghetti & meatballs), if you aren't in the mood for Italian, try their burgers or chicken strips! Start with the beer cheese & crackers--you won't regret it. Wonderful, laid-back atmosphere & friendly staff!
First time, overall quite good.... Good food & service, nice place, at reasonable price. Was bit disappointed in the prime rib - have had better, have had not as good... was expecting better here. It had pleasing taste, but missing some seasoning and also not as juicy / tender as would have liked. The pasta combo was quite tasty, and filling... leftovers are great! Also ordered a pizza to go; bacon on entire pie, with pepperoni on one half and then Italian sausage on the other... very good, probably best part of the meal (especially like the cornmeal dusting on the bottom of the thin crust) ;). The homemade cheese was first-rate, with pleasing smooth texture, and is very rich... little bit goes a long way. The salad (made with spinach) and the special bacon-infused dressing was excellent... as was the baked potato. As mentioned, the service is friendly and prompt, with water refilled and items brought and dirty done dishes removed. Nice place... will be back.
Favorite restaurant in town. Been going to Michael's for over a decade. Best food and drinks around.
KathyJo Mayer-Strukel
+4.5
Best Pizza!. We have been going to Michael's for YEARS! It is in the old "Italian" neighborhood in Elkhart and the pizza is among the best I've ever had!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes