Pudgies Pizza Pasta & Subs. Pudgies Pizza, is a childhood favorite that compares only to the highest quality pies ive ever tasted if you want something different but at the same time good i would give them a go. this location is one of the best.
LOVE IT!. I love Pudgies Pizza especially your stromboli's. We would stop by and pick up a few slices or even a whole stromboli when we went to our doctor's appointments every month. We needed our pudgie's pizza fix. We love you Pudgies and get your butts down to Weeki Wachi Florida. You would do great business here.
Great Food. Just went to the South Main store while visiting Elmira on July 6th. I love that pizza. Grew up on it and now live in Brooklyn where they think they have the best but they are wrong. NYC pizza is just greasy cheese on a cardboard crust. I hope Pudgie's is around forever.
Elmira Restaurant Reviews
+4.5
Deep dish (Chicago) style pizza. Also try their "Italian Sausage Special," and their meatball sub, calzones and strombolis. Some menu items are better than others - cheese steaks not too authentic. But still, an Elmira institution. $.
Couldn't help but feel a wave of excitement last Sunday, my family and I treated ourselves to a little special dinner and goodness me, did it surpass our expectations! Delight soared up to the elm trees when we bit in the flavor-packed pizza, our taste buds persisted dancing for sure. All heavens broke loose when the veggie pizza entered the territory of our eager mouths.Tasting celebration there every single moment!
I want to share my exceptional experience with everyone about my visit to Elmira. This restaurant is much loved for their huge, subtly flavored personal pizzas - tasted almost like Italy. Salads with fresh non-wilty greens, perfect companions! Wings - ah, spot on seasoning and oh so fine.But in comes my favorite, Jim, with an irresistibly warm smile being the cheerful provider of delightful, piping hot subs to your doorstep.I commend the fine people running the nap place - lovely times spent outdoors on fine days. If you haven't visited yet, what are you waiting for - go submerge yourself in an ocean of Italian roots!
Visiting here made my day, cause this spot I found gives the hugest pizzas which were real tasty! Some fellow, the kind delivery guy Jim, tossed in a salad too, and man, that decision was spot on - lettuce brought the crunch, dressing was fantastic! More'n'satisfied with the meal and their top notch service. Bravo! I sure hope they find a spot in sunny Cal soon. Can't help not craving more.
I ordered a personal pizza and it was HUGE (and very tasty). I love Pudgies Southside Elmira. Their sauce is fantastic, and salads are always fresh with fresh and un-wilted, brown, or slimy lettuce. The wings are almost always perfection and the right amount of seasoning.
Oh wow! When it comes to pizza places in Elmira, our hands down favorite is always a toss between dominos and papa johns but, ever since we stumbled upon this amazing little place our decision is forever Pudgies. Even after a tiring day of home renovations nothing can take away the sheer delight of their delicious pizza, loaded with a generous amount of mouth watering sauce! Big shoutout to our beloved driver Jim, who went out of his way and gifted my little girl 5 bucks it ended up giving her the perfect birthday surprise.
We also love their buffalo wings. Perfect amount of sauce and just the right degree of crispness, please put this place in your Elmira bucket list despite some minor delays with delivery once or twice, ample amounts of flavorful, non sloppy salads balancing out some of the sinful indulgence ;))But, here's the thing--their sandwich filled with Italian sausage transports me straight back to my childhood!
My favorite pizza! Awesome place to sit and hang out with friends! Always know what you are getting because it’s always fresh and consistent. Excellent every time!!
Just gotta share this... I said 'arrivederci' to my kitchen yesterday, with a mountain of home improvements going on. Enter 'yo favorite go-to' in Elmira - a certain pizza, pasta, and subs joint. Oh my, such good eats - the pizzas tasty, subs loaded and their deep-dish was insane guys! Super impressed by their delivery guy, a cool dude named Jim. Seriously, what a gem. Bagged myself a mega salad, house renovations, go green right? Go if ya haven't folks!
This Pudgies is different from the other Pudgies for some reason. The pizza and the food is mostly the same, but there were a few things on this Pudgies menu that I don't recall being on my local Pudgies'.
The wings were made exactly like Pugies wings be; whether that's a good or not good thing is a matter of preference.
Just wanted to give a shout out to Janet and her team at the Southside pudgies! We had a big order with very little notice... They got it here on time.. and it was perfect! Thanks for helping us out today!
Just picture me, there I was at the end of a labour-heavy renovation day, determined energy oozing out from every pore, yearning for a we-a bit of girl-end and a large bite of pizza. Last stop to grab? Name surprised you? But surely delighted - Pudgie's. Now, y'all gotta appreciation here for the timely and smoothly serviced as ebooks. A round of applause for Jim, folks! He is no less than an ol football idol.
The pizza was excellent and the staff was great. I would highly recommend this place to anyone. They have a variety of items on the menu.
Ran into an issue with my order but they made it right without hesitation. Food is excellent and the staff is super friendly.
As delighted customers, we would like to express our utmost satisfaction with the delivery service provided by this Italian restaurant in elmira.
The convenience of having our favorite Italian dishes delivered to our doorstep has truly elevated our dining experience.
highly recommend this restaurant for their exceptional service and mouthwatering Italian fare.
We had an awesome pizza a few weeks ago! It's been a long time since I've had a pizza from Pudgies and I was very happy with it.
The food was delicious, not the Pudgie's I remember as a kid (probably due to inflation). However, I would continue to return here and highly recommend.
In town for the Thanksgiving weekend and stopped for dinner one night, everything exactly as I remember, excellent food and friendly service.
The dough is different being puffier and more dough like. Although it is different, it is a unique staple for many locals that grew up on it.
OMG am I excited to write this review. When I was younger, my mom worked at the old Pudgies store in Mansfield. Needless to say, we ate a lot of pizza growing up. Well, fast forward to today and it’s been more than twenty years since I’ve lived remotely close to a Pudgies.
With that said, whenever we visit our family back home in Pennsylvania, we make it a point to order from here. On this trip, we stopped at the Elmira store. The pizza was hot and fresh and above that, it tasted amazing. Add on that this was also the first time my daughter was able to try Pudgies and have a similar experience that I did growing up, I couldn’t be any happier with our visit there. Thank you to the Elmira crew for making a delicious pizza as well as your stellar professionalism. Now just open a store in Utah so we don’t have to travel as far.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes