If you like pie, you need to come here! The Pie Lady is passionate about what she does, and will make sure you leave with something you like, that you will have time to bake to perfection. She discouraged us from getting a whole pie, because we weren’t sure we would be home long enough that evening
Wow, great key lime pie! My wife said it was the best key lime pie she ever tasted and she doesn't normally like key lime. She loves cherry pies which i see from other reviews, are even better!
Super fluffy whipped cream, nice key lime filling and crumbly graham crust is absolutely delicious.
I am a bit of a pie snob and this was one of the best pieces of pie I have ever had! We tried the cherry crumble pie (with homemade vanilla gelato) and the cherry apple pie (with fresh whipped cream) and they were both so good. Fresh, flavorful, not overly sweet, and not even remotely artificial. Yo
The best cherry pie I ever ate :) Everything fresh and delicious. Very nice and friendly service. I recommend to visit this place.
Delicious cherry pie. Flaky crust and the filling was packed with tart, yet sweet, cherries. You could taste that it was real fruit. The lady was extremely kind, energetic, and helpful. I would say this is the best place to get cherry pie in door county.
What can I say about this place? Well, first off, it's the most adorable pie shop I've ever seen. Secondly, the woman who sold us pies personified "sweetie" in this place's name (although her name was Carol). And thirdly, but not one bit least... the pies were amazing!! Perfect sweetness and crust.
We tried apple, pumpkin, pecan, and chocolate chess pie - all of them were good but pumpkin was my favorite. I’d love to go back again and try more of the many pies they make! Get there early in the day to have the most options. If you want a whole pie, make sure you call a day or more in advance
An online article about the best cherry pie in Door County led us to Sweetie Pies, and we are so happy to have found this place! My husband said it was the best cherry pie he ever had. Except for my mom’s, I definitely agree!
Small selection since we got there later in the day. Bakery is pricey. Crumble on top of pies was good, but the crust was tough. Cute shop.
I heard this was the place to get the best Door County Cherry Pie, and guess what it was!! Tart and sweet at the same time. Crust cooked perfectly and not all runny inside, just filled to the top with cherries! All it needed was a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream! (Oops where is the pie?) Tiny bit
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes