Reviews Mellow Mushroom Fleming Island

We literally come every Tuesday night for Bingo. Unless I'm working. Generally we sit at the bar unless we have our daughter in tow, then we sit like normal folk at a table....which feels weird but whatever. I've been going to Mellow well over 10 years now, and Coleen (bartender) is absolutely amazing. Tonight we got the Drunken Funguys to start. Pizza dough formed into bite sized pieces and served with their pizza sauce, beer-cheese-cheese (is that even a thing?), and honey mustard. I've got a love for their pizza sauce so I ate mostly that while as my daughter opted for the honey mustard. Now, usually we start with the meatballs. Three big meatballs with mozzarella cheese in between (similar to a mini burger), on a bed of pizza sauce, with basil and shaved Parmesan topping. My favorite. I love them so much I contemplated betting a Meatball Hoagie, but to not get pizza seemed like a sin. However, my daughter did get the Meatball Kid's Meal. There's no pasta, but it was two of the large meatballs served just like the app. Do Note: Drinks don't seem to be included with kid's meals. She got milk, which was $1.75, and took maybe two sips. Never again kid; I can buy a gallon for like a dollar more. My husband and I each got a Large Pizza ($26/each) because we're gluttonous. And also because he works the next 4 days and I work the next 5. Meal Prepping at it's finest! As always, he got the Mighty Meaty. And it was overflowing with meat! So if you love meat on your pizza, that's the one for you. My go-to is the Buffalo Chicken. And I can almost promise you, it's made different every week. Two weeks ago I had barely any buffalo sauce, this week the buffalo sauce was present, but in a different pattern than normal....that should tell you how often I go, when I know the patterns of how the sauces are put on the pizza. Sometimes there's a healthy helping of bacon, other times you have to squint hard to find it. I think a few years ago the Jax Beach location put chopped up celery on it, which was nice, but I don't believe any location does that anymore. *BlackFinn does put chopped celery on their Buffalo Chicken Flatbread, YUM! The best thing at this place, is the Bleu Cheese, and I'm not even kidding. I could drink it. And I never liked Bleu Cheese until maybe two years ago, and it was Mellow that turned me on to it. Get it on the side, dip your pizza crust in it. Wanna know why I don't have more than 1 kid? Because I don't want to give up Mellow's Bleu Cheese for 9 months. Speaking of Bleu Cheese, try their Bayou Bleu pizza. A Bleu Cheese base with Shrimp and Andouille Sausage, who knew a pizza place could cook such amazing shrimp!? I could eat a whole plate of just the shrimp. Though my hubs and I do joke that we can instantaneously feel our arteries clogging when we eat it. Maybe one day soon I'll venture away from my beloved Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

It was the best service and the food was amazing!!!! Not my first time there at that location but the best time time. All the staff was top notch in my book,

Come here all the time. Often come after church on Sundays, love their brunch menu. Who would have thought eggs on a pizza would be so great!! Love the shrimp and grits also. Service is always great also.

My kind of pizza place!!! Hope to hit it a few times during the upcoming football season. With some friends and a Jaguar victory, it should be a blast!! LOL Probably have to miss work the next day.

It was great and I was able to get the best gluten free pizza.

Great white pizza, pretzel bites with spicy beer cheese and those Southside wings are amazing . The manager Jake and the server Alexandra are amazing people too.

Came on a Monday evening and the place was packed. Got a seat at the bar immediately and our tender was quick to welcome us and tell us about the beer and drinks. My wife ordered a Captain and Coke with Cherry and I got the Sweetwater Dank Tank Series 710bHazy Double IPA which was amazing. We ordered the mushroom soup, absolutely fantastic. We also ordered a plain pizza and a white pizza called The Great White. We were not fans of the sweetness of the red sauce on the plain, but the Great White was sublime. Wonderful service, good prices and a great atmosphere. Great date night or night out with the boys destination.

We have been going to this Mellow Mushroom since 2013. I must say that yesterday was the first visit where everything was absolutely perfect! We had taken a break from going there due to a previous experience with a terrible manager with no people skills. After yesterday’s experience, this is definitely back on the top of our list for places to go out and have a nice dinner at. Everything arrived in a timely, fashionable order. The food was cooked perfectly and had the best presentation that I can remember there. The general manager, Alex, visited our table and was so pleasant to speak with. He had a genuine interest in making sure everything was ok. What a change from our previous visits. Highly recommend this Mellow Mushroom if you are looking for a welcoming, at-home atmosphere with excellent food!!!