Honestly this wasn't anything to write home about. We went here just to grab a quick appetizer before a movie.
The calamari was OK, though it felt more like eating chicken tenders instead of calamari. The spanakopita were so strange. They tasted almost sour? Like they were filled with relish instea
Horrible unseasoned food with no taste no flavor. The chicken gyros tasted like chicken salad. Baklava was served cold when ordering to go. It was gooey, soggy and separating. Not worth the $60 for a family of 4
Solid gyros ‘n’ dolmas, pleasant atmosphere, great staff. A good place to go when you want a casual evening out with something other than burgers, fried chicken, or Mexican in FoCo. I also pick up a bottle of their Greek seasoning every few months or so, just to have with salads ‘n’ grilled chicken
It took me a while to find a place where falafels are good in Fort Collins, cause all the ones I have tried are gross, but I LOVE the falafels from Cafe Athens and the sauce. The only good ones in FOCO!
Gyro meat and suvlaki lamb was decent but both were dry and over cooked. Taziki was bland with no cucumber. The pita was good though. All of this would have gotten it 3 stars at least but the sides were awful! We got the mixed vegetables and orzo. The veggies were obviously from a cheap king supers
Since being back from Germany, which had some of the best Greek/Mediterranean food I've had, but I haven't been to Greece yet, cafe Athens had hands down the best Gyro meat. Pita and hummus was on point. Dolma was alright. Falfel was good. And the Turkish coffee was on point!
10/10 will go again, a
Ordered gyro falafel and fries the gyro and falafel were so dried out that they were inedibl.
the gyro meat was crunchy because it had been fried- $30 for 1 meal- while waiting 20 min for pick up the staff was goofing around like all 4 of them were on break- while diners were waiting for food-
When
Best Greek food I've had since I lived in NY, amd better than most I had there. Any folks saying it's "got no flavor" probably caught the BIG 'vid because this is flavortown.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes