Ivan Garcia
Really neat neighborhood pizzeria !!! The staff is always friendly and very attentive!!!
The pizzas are seriously good !!! One of my favorites in the area!!!! I know it’s not traditional though the Hawaiian is my go to and superme !!!
Oscar Melendez
*Updated* 🍕❤️
Nothing fancy, and that’s why it’s a 4 star! They’re not doing anything crazy here, just serving up NY style slices and bring super friendly to their customers. It’s at a very busy street so I’m sure they get all kinds of customers in the door, but they kept a smile the entire time.
I didn’t wanna hit up the joints downtown because those are usually just bars with mediocre pizza. This was a neat little place just doing their thing and making people happy!
Great selection of cold drinks as well!!
Robert Prasch
My family and I moved to Florida from New Jersey. One thing I miss about the Northeast is the amazing food. I think McGregor P&D could compete their pizza is delicious. Our favorite is the red, white & green.😊
Frankie D
Pizza was amazing the garlic knots not so much. I think if they were taken out of the oven 2/3 mins earlier they would have been perfect if you order take out be sure to check ur knots .....
Jon Tyler
I drove by only occasionally until I started a new job that brought me by daily. Working 3-11 made it a great stop for lunch. They have a lunch special 2 slices and a drink for $6.99. I couldn't resist. I have tried many different kinds as they have different pizzas prepared for lunch each day. Unfortunately the only pizza picture I took was the meat lovers however all were delicious. I grew up in the Boston area and that is the crust I'm partial to. Their's didn't disappoint. It crunches on the bottom and the sides are light and fluffy. When somebody does the dough right you just know. As a kid I remember eating the pizza and then saving the crust as sort of a dessert. You can do that here. I've also had the Chicken Parm sub sorry no pic but it was delicious. Many places attempt meatballs and few succeed but McGregor Pizza Company was a home run. I was fantasizing about sitting and watching TV with a bowl of meatballs kinda like popcorn. While their sauce is great you could easily eat these plain. They were moist and flavorful and when I got the meat lovers slice special I was right while I love sauce the meatballs held their own as a topping on the meat lovers slice's. I also got a meatball sub that was great... plenty of cheese not to much sauce with the flavor of the meatballs shining through. I'm gonna enjoy trying everything I think meatball sliders might be next. The staff is super friendly they also have beer and wine as well as outdoor and indoor seating and a restroom.
Al Amir
First time here and have to say their pizza was definitely up there at the top among the best pizzas we’ve had all over. I would definitely rate this the best pizza place in Lee county. Their 2 slice deal is also a great price. Will definitely be back to try out some other menu items too!
Tyana Ralston
We absolutely love this pizza and the restaurant!!! The delivery is amazing!!! And it’s by far the best pizza in the area!!!
Tasha K
McGregor pizza is fantastic! The owner Katie unis the sweetest business owner in SWFL and her and her husband have always been accommodating, kind and helpful! We order them for business catering, personal event catering and just for everyday lunch or dinner! The prices are reasonable and in my opinion the #1 place to get pizza in our area! Oh and Peyton is awesome too! Thank you all for everything you do!!!
Najir Scott
Great pit stop for food! The pizza is worth every penny in m book. Neil is also a pretty cool guy too with exceptional customer service
Joe Peters
There Subs, Stromboli's and calzone are delicious. Cant forget the jacked up garlic knots (Pepperoni popper) and so good. Pizza on the underhand is average for Florida. Hand tossed was underdone and the thin crust burnt. They staff are a great bunch and are always inviting.
Jonny Lynn Marie Nobile
Wonderful restaurant. The pizza was great and the staff was amazing. Very nice atmosphere, my new favorite pizza place. They even have gluten free options.
Roxanne Dufresne McCain
This is my go to spot for a calzone, I've never had any issues and the food and service is always good! I definitely recommend this place...
Jennifer Rivers
I have gotten pizza here 5 times in the last few months. The first time the pizza was absolutely amazing! Service not quite so hot. The last several times that I did order the pizza and I tried it three more times after the first. It was severely overcooked. Crust was very crunchy and burnt both on the bottom and the cross ring. It was still somewhat okay. And will only get again if I am in a serious pinch and crunch for time and I'm hungry! Otherwise I will try somewhere else.
Pizza was not burnt today 4/11/18 but not the same great taste as I first had. Service again was only o.k. even with my telling them I had received burnt pizza a total of 6 pies the last three times that I was there.
All in all the pizza last night was good taste in good quality. But I just did not have that same amazing flare it did in the beginning. At least for me anyway.
Joan Roush
Love the 2 slices and soda deal! Awesome pizza and great staff. Sandy is amazing and so are the owners! Cute little place too.
Richie Cruz
We are addicted! Fresh ingredients,tasty pizza,and good service. We have been ordering from Mcgregor Pizza a lot lately and they have not disappointed. Way better than ordering a greasy heavy pizza from one of those big chain pizza shops! It's our go to spot for great food on the quick and it's nice that it's nearby.
Brandy Dodge
Fresh, simple and delicious. I've been eating at this establishment for 10 years, and have always enjoyed the food. Even though there's been management changes a few times, things are still great! Love the pepperoni poppers and the Chicago Beef, oh and the white pizza of course. The sandwich bread is delicious with a nice chew and pepperoni poppers, well they speak for themselves. I definitely say give this place a try!
David Reed
First time trying the Pizza, while the toppings were plentiful, the sauce was pleasant and adequate amount of cheese. I didn't care so much for the dough or crust. It was slightly overcooked and a teeny bit chewy. I was a teeny bit disappointed, especially since it was a little bit more in cost.
Jessica Weathers Nolan
Awesome, great atmosphere, excellent customer service and most importantly the food was amazing! Definitely recommend.
Weinberger Liat
Came back from beach and ran into this place !! Were so glad we did. Great food in a nice Casual Sheek. Love the Red White and Green pizza and chicken salad sandwich!!!
Miles Nordskog
This eatery is apparently under new ownership. The pizza is smaller but costs the same price. The quality is not as good. And if you want a single slice your options are cheese or pepperoni and that’s it. They won’t even throw a couple mushrooms on a slice for you anymore. They took one of my favorite places and ruined it, I will never eat there again.
Jeff Smith
Best pizza in Ft Myers! Our new favorite place. Give them a try as you will not be disappointed.
Jenny Madden
Stoped in for Carry Out a few days ago. And ordered the Pesto Pizza with a side salad.
The pizza was amazing. (Add tomatoes) I highly recommend
Alex Botello
You guys have amazing pizza but your customer service is horrible. I was a new customer. I've stopped in twice for lunch. I thought I found my to go spot when I'm working in the area. Stopped in today and the doors were locked. The guy behind the counter gave me an attitude asking if I could not read pointing at the open sign. I said yes it says you open at 10am, it was 10:08 when I arrived. Definitely would not recommend it to anyone unless you have time to waste.
Joel Moroney
Pizza is On Point (even if I do say so myself). P.S. I own the joint! Thank you for a great two years. If it's been awhile since you've tried us, stop in and try us again. We are ready and the pizza has never been better! Hit me up on here if you ever have any issues and we will make it right!
Ravit Gutman Hadad
If you are looking for one of those authentic NY style pizza - this is the spot. Best local pizza around!
Mary Carmen Catoya
Excellent and amazing pizza. We are visiting from Miami and stayed in FM for the Holidays. We ordered out on Wednesday. A cheese/ white pizza and Mediterranean and it was very good
Robin Gipson Houlihan
Great pizza! We’re getting our pizza from here from now on!!!����
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes