I decided to check this place out because I love pizza. The deep dish is very good. I had to try the thin crust. It was good too. I prefer the deep dish. Yummy.
We were greeted upon entry by the hostesses. We advised we were going to sit at the bar. The bartenders were nice & attentive. The lady with the longer brown hair made excellent drinks. Plus she shut the garage window when a child was screaming her so loud. She's like if her parents aren't going to discipline her, well just close this door so y'all don't have to listen to it. By far my fav bartender ever for doing that! We ordered the jalapeno pretzel bites, do not recommend. They're not that good & there's not too many of them. The Chicken Tai hand tossed pizza was excellent.
The pizza is decent. Overall the food is good. Value is good as well.
The pepperoni wrap appetizer was good.
The steak wrap was good.
I have ordered pizza from this pizza place in other states always good pizza. I like the classic on tavern thin crust personally. Good go to spot for good pie
I recently sat in the bar area and was very impressed. Even though the bar too was almost full I was greeted within moments of sitting down. The bar tender (Meghan) was very up beat and personable. I especially liked that when I sat down and told her the styles of beers I liked she immediately made suggestions and let me taste what was on tap. On top of that, later I was having trouble deciding what type of pizza I wanted and she suggested something that wasn’t even on the current menu! I think it was the “Italian grinder”, it was AMAZING! I will definitely be going back and highly recommend!
Great pizza, just wish they had anchovies…. We had a veggie pizza and a meat pie and finished off with the cookie…. Brae was our server and he did a great job, very personable guy. We look forward to going again.
Felt like an old school tavern, wings was good. Pizza could have be cooked a little longer. Overall good choice
The pizza was good, the Chicago-style 🍕was a thicker crust but I’m used to deep pie like style which it wasn’t. It was still good. The other Detroit style was okay. Only critique - burnt pepperonis don’t taste good. Service was good.
First time visit. Been wanting to try this place for a while now. Glad we did! I was impressed by the beer selection. Our server Catherine was very friendly and attentive. I ordered a Chicago 7, with Chicago thick crust. While it's not real Chicago deep dish, it was still very good. My wife ordered the Chicago 7 Calzone. Most Calzones are too crunchy, but this one was light and airy. Stuffed full of cheese and toppings. One could easily make 2 meals out of it! For dessert, we had a fresh baked cookie with bananas, strawberries, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce. Such a great dessert! We'll definitely be back!
We went on a Monday night. Not busy and our waiter was attentive. We got a pizza (forgot the name, farmer’s daughter or something like that) not bad but not the best. We got wings and those were very good. We also got a phil’s cheese sandwich and that was really really good. The prices are reasonable as well. I would go again and would order the same thing, except that pizza. I would try a different one. But overall it was worth trying out.
Love this place and their selection of beer. Another great addition to the area and they are actually open late. Many things close in the Alliance area early, so it's always great to get something later. They have great food and also a rewards program you can sign up for. They have a way better selection of beer then your normal restaurant which is amazing for the Craft Beer fans out there. The staff is great and very friendly at this location as well. I definitely recommend this place if you are a late night, craft beer fan.
Menu is outstanding. The pizza is perfectly cooked with some great flavor choices. Service is efficient and friendly. Love coming here.
Update: Come here about once every 1 - 2 weeks. Continues to blow our minds. The artichoke dip is one of the best appetizers in my book. Also, we did have an issue with a miscommunicated order and the manager insisted we take a free med pizza home even when we said it was fine. Great customer service.
Amazing Pizza! My wife and I are from Buffalo NY and there pizza is the closest thing I’ve found to NY and Chicago. My wife says the Gluten Free pizza is better than NY’s. We had pizza and boneless wings. Both tasted amazing. Visit was on Feb. 2nd 2019
Service: Great service. Our server was Grace and she did a great job. We eat here before the dinner rush which I’m sure helped.
Facility: clean with clean bathrooms.
Old Chicago Pizza is a sport bar, there's nothing wrong with that, but don't visit the place thinking you are in cozy old style pizza restaurant. Go for their amazing and creative bar mixology and huge TV all around. They have thin and thick Chicago style, your preference, then the regular pizza fare also a house signature list. We chose the Tuscan chicken not reading carefully or thinking that pizza has cheese we got this very fresh pie top w spinach but no cheese or tomato sauce. I would return to tried different ones and amazing drinks.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes