Great bagels and super nice people! I’m a native New Yorker who lives in Chicago and was in the area for work. Went to Bagelman for lunch and had a delicious bagel with cream cheese and lox. I left as they were closing for the day so they offered me a free bagel or two for the road since they make new ones fresh each morning. When I told them I was flying home to Chicago and that my family loves New York bagels, they loaded me up with a free big bag of them to take home with me. My family has been enjoying them all week! Customer service at its finest, and a great quality bagel!
Fresh bagels, breakfast sandwiches, & coffee. I definitely recommend not toasting the bagels & getting a veggie, scallion, or specialty cream cheese.
So I was looking for bagels, and I ended up here! Did not disappoint!! I got an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and bacon. So so good, fresh and crispy! To drink I got a Bagelman Mixer which is their creation of pink lemonade and sweet iced tea! Very very good!
Nice sandwich, stuff full of fillings. The roast beef was soft and tasty. I wasn't keen on the macaroni side pot though. Well priced and in a nice location
Amazing experience ordering mini bagels for a party the day before. They were ready earlier than the original pickup time we were told. So professional and super nice.
AMAZING BAGELS AND KIND STAFF! This was my very first experience trying New York Bagels and BOY IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT! I was very confused at first with the amount of options offered but the cashier was very kind and helpful and explained how i could order my bagel! Everything was so yummy! I will be returning when i am back in garden city!
My favorite breakfast spot. Sometimes the line gets backed up, but it’s worth the wait.
Great neighborhood bagel/sandwich spot. Delicious food and more importantly great service and management. Will be coming back here often!
Me and my family had a vacation trip in New York City and we were staying not too far from BagelMan . We stopped in and got some rainbow bagels and the lady and the gentleman was very friendly and they said will make some more fresh bagels just give us 10 minutes and will have some fresh new ones coming out the oven the bagels were great service was fantastic overall I give them 10 stars if I could give them at this location I even brought some back for some of my friends back home in Chicago thank you
Good bagel place, with a fair amount of other sandwiches in a convenient spot. I usually go here for bagels, and they're solid quality. The flavored spreads are awesome though; I love the olive cream cheese while my girlfriend loves the strawberry (made with real fruit). Very little wait time with the option to call ahead and pick up.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes