Sluurpy
Reset

There are 24 restaurants

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Garden City

There are 24 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Grimaldi's Pizza
87/100 (1591 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Meatballs
Cannoli
Eggplant
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My favorite Grimaldi location. Super quiet neighborhood with a huge private parking lot. The service here is just perfect. I gotta be honest, this..."
Jesse Yuan
"Love it here! I can't speak for take out but one of my favorite places to go and sit for a casual but delicious meal! You can't beat a fresh..."
Jenna DiPaolo
"I passed this place on Franklin Ave and 10th Street on the way to an appointment and knew I had to stop there for lunch. I had the meatball parm hero..."
Matt Seinberg
"The pizza here is delicious. It’s a thin crust, brick oven baked pizza! You can order one of the specialties or build your own. Salads and a..."
Mei Tam
"First off, they're buffalo wings are amazing. Second, for toppings choose buffalo chicken and jerk chicken for your personal pizza. This was my first..."
Random Things
"I'm a little surprised how good the food was. Although numerous restaurants in this area are good.. Grimaldi was..."
Dominick Sarle
"Jose was amazing. He asked about our day, it was a bad due to the experience at the restaurant we attempted right before. He completely changed our..."
Dominique Rodrigues
"Beautiful place to be, great atmosphere and amazing sweet Manager, definitely coming..."
Hossam Eshmawy
"Great service, great food I love visiting..."
Rissa
"#summer2020 #covid19 #coronavírus #socialdistancing #flattenthecurve #stayathome #nystrong #august2020 #selfcare #longislandsummer #longisland..."
Andrea D. Hicks
"Delicious, authentic brick oven pizza (some of the best I’ve had since getting back from Italy.) I ate it before I could take a picture. Just..."
Steven Liss
Old Chicago
87/100 (1384 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
American
Bar
Pub
Pizza
American
Italian
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Nachos
Pesto
Fish
Burger
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Bar
American
Pub
Pizza
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Visa
Parking Available
Accepts American Express
Free off-street parking
Accepts Discover
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My son and I are not able to eat gluten. This place has the best gluten free pizza we have had! The place is clean and service is..."
Heather Olivier
"We have eaten there around 5 times and we have always had excellent food and always had a great waitress. We love to come and eat there. It's an hour..."
Sherri Wilder
"Great beers on tap, but, the best treat was a bottle of Longboard, made by Kona Brewing Co and Budweiser in Ft Collins Co. Yummy appetizers and..."
Mjb Buford
"Justin Walsh is amazing - great staff - wonderful food and the best beer in..."
Stephanie Dickson
"Great food and service, and great location. I recommend this place to all my..."
Scott Wittman
"Beer variety is outstanding! The pizza is amazing (even though I hate pizza). Old Chicago pizza is the only pizza I will eat &..."
Mekayla Guerrero
"The food was delicious, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was perfect. Definitely one of my top 3 places to eat and I will always go..."
Mike Bordewick
"Fun atmosphere, delightful waitress, great food and drink! I want to go back..."
Patti Francis
"The food was better than I expected . The waitress was very good very nice and the cutest little redhead I've ever seen in these parts. She looked..."
Rodney Wilder
"Awesome food best pizza in town good and fresh good..."
Eric Stephen
"Waitress was awesome, friendly and attentive. I got the Chicago cheese steak, but probably wouldn't order again. Sandwich was kind of dry, and..."
Robert “Nick” Richards
"Waited over an hour to get seated, ordered appetizers & pizza. ALL came at once. Looked like they were understaffed as tables went hours before..."
Jill Wolters
"Long wait times, short staffed. That being said, the waitresses are awesome and the food is worth it. Hubby and I had the lunch pizza and salad..."
Ezmra
"I've stopped by this Old C many times while passing through and it's always been a great place to stop for lunch. Good selection of beer and they..."
Michael Pare
"We stopped in after shopping on a Saturday to catch some football and lunch at the bar. Liz was the bartender and she gave us great customer service,..."
Candee Jean The Local Local
"We had and always have a great time, had a very delicious, a very satisfying meal!!! Our waitress was so kind, playful and so patient with our 3..."
xotwod
Caffe Luciano’s
83/100 (786 ratings)
Restaurants
Wine Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Cafe
Italian
Pizza
Beer restaurants
Italian
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Salad
Lasagne
Beer restaurants
Italian
Wine Bar
Café
Pizza
Takeout
Television
Street Parking
Seating
Waterfront
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free off-street parking
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Rebecca & Debbie rocked the patio with their talent! The food was perfect, the wait staff happy and professional! We waited 45 mins to get a table on..."
Darcee Houston-Tennyson
"Loved every bit of it—the view, the staff, our beautiful server, and thwe delicious food!!! A must!..."
Marla J Muncy Keller
"Along the Greenbelt in Garden City this gem is well worth looking for. Great selection of appetizers, panni's, pizza, and a great view of the river...."
Kevin Bartlett
"Perfect little stop on the Greenbelt, just across the Iron Bridge in Ester Simplot Park. The food is great , the bar is open and the staff is..."
Yvonne Kimball
"Are you kidding me? Excellent menu...our pork belly special blew us away! Quaint and fresh. Perfect service (thank you Robert & Andrea). Comfortable..."
Gretchen Pelsma Talbert
"This is a place I could hang out at for hours... on the river, shaded, drinking wine. Bruschetta was great, the grilled salmon was perfect. Nice..."
JoEll Crain
"This is a very nice restaurant/caffe. We're huge fans of the original Luciano's and the new Caffe is equally amazing. Out next adventure will include..."
Vincent Archibeque
"Caffe Luciano’s is fantastic. Bev did an outstanding job developing this restaurant. The location is wonderful. I can’t wait to sit on the..."
Barbara Brown
"Great food. Great beer. Great service. Too bad the place was built so small it will always be too full in the summer. Plan on make it a regular stop..."
Brad Keith
"A completely different menu then it's parents place, but with the same high quality of service and food. You can't go wrong here! A winner from the..."
Rob Nesbit
"Very limited menu compared to sister restaurant Lucianos. Wonderful salads! Ricotta pretty salty. Located on the river and walkways/trails. Clean and..."
Kasey Kraft
"Such a cute place. We had some coffee and tried the charcuterie board and the baked brie. Our waitress was super helpful and funny. I can't wait..."
Bobby Foster
"Caffè Luciano's is a charming little place overlooking the Boise River. Good menu selection, quick service, and friendly staff. When the outdoor..."
Mike Lydon
"Excellent food and friendly service right along the bicycle..."
William Sowle
"One of the best sandwiches I've ever had! The salmon sandwich was delicious! So much flavor. What a great little quaint spot on the..."
Kyle Dewey
"Got the zucchini sandwich and it was delicious. Staff was super chill and friendly. Had a couple of good ciders too. It's like a secret fresh..."
Derek Davidson
Pizza Supreme
83/100 (2470 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Joe and his team are so nice! I’ve never had a bad experience. Food is delicious and fresh. And, you MUST order a square pie - - my family’s all..."
Bo V
"Pizza Supreme used to be located in Roosevelt Field near the Time Out Arcade. The square pie was always amazing. There is nothing better than a..."
paulbiggs
"For years, Pizza Supreme has consistently delivered a delicious mouthful of Italy. Famous for their square pizzas, always add their garlic knots to..."
Jacqueline Vita
"We got a supreme pizza from Pizza Supreme and it wasn't your average supreme. It was WAYY above average, with slices soo big and toppings piled high...."
Dan Tyler
"Grew up coming here with my family and still make trips out from the city. Many of square pies have been consumed and they are delicious. Makes me..."
J J
"Great square slices. Always fresh. Garlic knots are some of the best I have ever had. Can eat just the knots with a side of sauce as a meal. Covered..."
Kevin Law
"I found out by chance today that the pizza I raved about from my childhood still existed, brought a square cheese pie home and it is just as good as..."
Dawn Hetzel
"Because my dad works there and I got it for free and the pizza is delicious and everything on the..."
Valentina Garcia
"This pizza is actually very good. Everyone on LI knows what good pizza tastes like. If you give this place a try you won't be let..."
Daniel Kennedy
"We ordered a cheese pie from this place fresh as you can get any also gave us 12 knots on the house very friendly..."
Jay Malone
Sbarro
83/100 (19509 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Roosevelt Island Fields is an absolute gem nestled just a stone's throw away from Manhattan, offering an oasis of tranquility and..."
NYC simpledriver. COM
"Many indoor malls are gone or in disrepair or closed. Most surviving malls have had their ups and downs through the years. Not Roosevelt Field...."
Philip Zalon
"Had A Wonderful Time With My 2 Childhood School Friends, The Mall Was Huge, It Was Cold, Just Right After Corona. But I Really Enjoyed..."
Gofran Ahmed
"Great place to hang out. Lots of stores including some high end. Very good food court. Lots of..."
Nelson Figueroa
"had a good experience here, has at least all of your favorite malls, the food court has lots of choices, there was a Starbucks in the Macy's which..."
mannat multani
"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Roosevelt Island Fields: A Verdant Haven Just Moments Away! Discover the hidden gem that is Roosevelt Island Fields – an..."
Professional Driver
"🛍️ Just had an incredible shopping experience at Roosevelt Field Mall! This place is a shopaholic's paradise with a vast array of stores to..."
William Jacobs
"I recommend Roosevelt. The AMC theater is right next door and many other restaurants. Also many clothes Stores , jewelry Stores, food Boots and so on..."
Widlande Pierre
"Great mall with excellent shops, clean and well lit, plenty of places to eat, with a pretty good food court, also there was no problem getting a..."
Tony Aguirre
"This mall is great. It's centrally located in Long Island, close to Queens and other parts of the island. They have pretty much all the stores you..."
Shah Quadery
Marco's Pizza
81/100 (479 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"Pizza was great and didn't have to wait long for it. This was our last stop leaving the beach this weekend and worth the stop. Thanks to the..."
Wendy Moore
"I should have asked him to make sure, but my ticket says my driver was...Brian!! Thank You so much for bringing us a hot pizza! He was very polite!!..."
Janet Davis
"Great service, friendly staff! Definitely a 5..."
Amanda Perry
"Marcoo's Pizza has some amazing food, but that's nothing compared to that one delivery driver they have in the white Chevy Tahoe. I tell ya, that guy..."
Andy Sorrell
"Consistent and..."
Carolyn Winnie Robertson
"Perfect pizza, best pizza in murrels inlet, The other pizza places parking lot,are empty.Marcos had a wait, well worth..."
Jimmy Shine
"Pizza chain established in 1978 making their pies the authentic Italian way with dough made from scratch, fresh in store, a special three cheese..."
Philip Ward
"This is the first time we have ever had Marco's Pizza. We ordered thin crust. We really like the sauce and the crust. It is a very tasty pizza. We..."
Lori Rosian
"Had an excellent pizza ordered online got there big cheese xl pizza with Italian sausage. Had it delivered it came almost 15 min before promised..."
mike blaso
"First time trying Marco’s and it did not disappoint!! We dined in, pizza was served hot and delicious!! I ordered a regular garden salad which I..."
Cindi Morgan
"Best pizza in town. The flavor is on point. Always delicious. All the employees are super nice and fast. I go with my dad everyday Wednesday Pizza..."
Shelley N
"Drove 20 minutes from Myrtle Beach.. bought the extra large Hawaiian chicken.. and took it back to my hotel. Outstanding Pizza. Took 10 minutes from..."
Peter Laflamme
"Grabbed a late night pizza last minute here. The pizza was amazing and the price was surprisingly low. Definatley a new favorite for..."
Pastor Tim
"Amazing pizza and subs, with very little wait time for food prep and..."
Lead Farmer 77
"Bananna peppers, feta cheese, & old style pepperoni! Very good! Best pizza, I had in a long..."
CHUCKII moore
"This pizza is slept on by a lot of people ..this being said,the pizza here was very very delicious!!! We got the deluxe with extra mushrooms and we..."
Mike Allen
"Great quality pizza...best..."
stephanie erickson (Liz)
Rustica Brick Oven Cafe
80/100 (2019 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Pesto
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"This restaurant is a gem in Garden City. Very close to Nassau Boulevard train station and very close to Adelphi University. Amazing Italian food and..."
Faryal Chaudhry
"Love love love this place. Visit it every time we are in the area. Extremely GF friendly! Not only do they have delicious GF pizza but they also have..."
Keri Maletto
"This place has the best gluten free pizza I've tasted so far. The atmosphere is cozy, if a little busy, but you don't feel forgotten. Portions were..."
Elaina Eiser
"Went to dinner with some friends. Food was good and service was just as good. Nice spot to go to for a casual night out for dates or a get together...."
Nelson Acevedo
"It was our first time there. Love the brick oven pizza . And the price reasonable . Definitely will return for more..."
Cynthia Matadin
"This is the kind of place Nassau Blvd is really desperate for. There aren’t a lot of options to sit down and have a nice meal that feels like a..."
Christina Rubino
"the pizza is one of the better ones in the Nassau area. the dinner dishes can be..."
Dee L
"The pizza is always good that's why I drive all the way from Queens to get it. Hot and deliciously..."
Jason Guthrie
"When I dine in, always friendly service. Best gluten free food I've..."
Stacey Pagan
"Ordered a large House Special pie, a crust that has and can support such a topping choice while providing a great crunch -..."
Robert Riccio
Garden City Pizza
80/100 (1018 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"Spartan takeout-focused pizza place with pizzas like nowhere else. Buy a slice or buy a pie. Shrimp, chicken parm, buffalo chicken, white - they were..."
Kundan Sen
"Very good quality and delicious pizzas at reasonable prices. Customer service was very good, with knowledgeable and helpful staff. Friendly and fast..."
G Bach
"Everything here is very good, however the Veal Cutlet Parm Hero was the best I've ever had. It was crispy, yet tender. The bread was crusty, yet..."
Jonathan Anderson
"It's always crowded and that's because the pizza is awesome. One of my favorite spots! Staff is very friendly, the owner is down to earth. Very nice..."
Veeda B
"My first time to Garden City Pizza and I was amazed at the prices and the pleasant atmosphere. The wait staff were very nice and the pizza was hot..."
1SweetLadyVee
"No frills spot with some of the best pizza I’ve had. The staff is friendly and welcoming. I definitely recommend the vodka..."
S H
"Hands down this place has great pizza , and service was nice . As well they have booths you can sit down and kid friendly /family friendly . Will..."
NinjaTurtle 21
"They were able to accommodate a large order, same day request with vegan and gluten free options. Delivery was provided and the items arrived warm...."
Traveler's Q
"This tiny space pumps out delicious food. Not just pizza; (paninis, salads, soups, entrees) they cater as..."
Robert
"This is my go-to pizza spot for delivery to my office. After you order a couple times GCP will have your information on file (address and credit..."
Peter A
"The food is always really good and the service is nice. My mom’s in love with the mesclun salad, but my favs are their speciality..."
Travis
"Had the spinach pinwheel. Freshest and softest pinwheel I’ve ever had! I always look for them at decent pizza spots, and thus place is by far the..."
Kris S
"Excellent pizza and perfectly cooked wings. Oftentimes the pizzerias we have tried in the past had decent pizza and terrible wings or excellent pizza..."
Mary R
"Delicious! Didn't have any pizza but the skirt steak is..."
Tyler Roy
"Great pizza. Great service. Different pizza crust styles and they are happy to customize. Fresh salad ingredients. We showed up with a large party..."
Hilal Kanaan
"Excellent service! I order ahead and they are always on time. Their penne a la vodka and mesclun salad is one of my faves. Super friendly staff and..."
Mariana Torres (Salvi Nomad)
"The staffs were so friendly and generous and the food was..."
Wilson Chou
Pizza Hut
70/100 (459 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"We ordered the Big Box deal during the Georgia - South Carolina game. Ordering online was easy, service/pick up was on time and the food was really..."
Scott George
"This Pizza Hut that I go to is TOTALLY AWESOME! I've never had an issue with this store. Great Customer Service! Always have my orders done right...."
David Shaw
"We loved the Big Dinner Box and everyone got what they wanted- we ate twice- $30 well..."
Arneja Riley
"This place was swamped with door dash orders and other orders like deliveries and walk ins when I got there 3 people walked out with dash orders for..."
Shadeenah
"The pizza I just ordered from this location is the most well-prepared pizza that I have ever eaten from Pizza Hut! Kudos to the staff, and thank you..."
Matthew Kostecky
"I have ordered pizza here a few times in the last month. The food has always been well-prepared and the customer service is great as well. Highly..."
CreativeWriteHer
"I am not happy that the only way you can get promotions is if you order online. If you call the store in Garden City, GA they will refuse to tell you..."
Ebbie
"Great quality and orders are always on time and right. Great quality and great..."
Randall Frantz
"At this store is all depends on who cooking the pizza… the pizza super fresh and made rite… it not burn and it made on time the dark skin guy ..."
ellis marshall
"Our family loves this Pizza Hut location! The pizza is always delicious and every time we visit the store, the staff is so friendly and remember us...."
Kristy Daly
"My order was ready as promised!!!!! My order was AWESOME!!!! Great taste right temporary. Keep up ya'll AWESOME..."
L
Domino's Pizza
70/100 (417 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Always quick and hot, whether I pick it up, or have it..."
Leila Rae Bush
"Domino's pizza in garden city and pooler are awesome partners in the community. They contribute and participate in S2S Facts Inc. Annual Trunk or..."
Donna Williams
"They were slammed pack busy, and i couldn’t get ahold of a person, until Nick answered the phone. He explained they were super busy and only had..."
Tobias Boyles
"sadly i had to wait almost 3 hours for my food but when i called someone named nick answered and was so sweet. i got my food a couple minutes later..."
Skiler
"I always order online and pick up in person. The store is always clean, employees are always respectful and greet you, as you come in through the..."
Danielle
"Thankyou Mr George/nick? for driving back to bring our sauces, ya didn't have too but it was much..."
Kitt soup
"Only complaint they didn't send marinara with the bread sticks. ....."
Candy Outen
"Best experience I’ve had at this location in years. Was pleasantly surprised. Everything Joshua made was delicious, perfect temperature and..."
Heather McAllister
"9/10 times they put toppings on the pizza like it's their own 🍕 You can tell when the good cooks are working too.. This specific location is my..."
mister 9001
"I love my local Domino's. The orders are correct and delivered with care. The few times they have been super busy, they call me and let me know...."
Pamela Marie
"I ordered on a Monday night, maybe 30-45 minutes before closing at midnight. I didn't have high expectations considering how late. My delivery..."
Dana R