Andrew Olson
SO thrilled that we found Vintage Cantina! Such delicious tacos with a fun and unique variety of flavors — great atmosphere and service as well! A few of our favorites were the Juicy Lucita, C.B.R., Thai Brussels, and Avocado — but you truly can't go wrong no matter which you choose! Definitely a new favorite spot that we’ll be returning to often.
Jennifer J
Tacos were good as usual. But some things have changed over the last few years.... 3% fee regardless of cash or card? Just add that to the menu pricing then. Service was OK at best. The bartender was amazing, but she wasn't our server, nor did we order alcohol, but she brought us refills without asking
Connor B
Came for variety tacos & a great cocktail. Slam dunk! Definitely will be back. Not only were the food & beverages great, but the service was excellent & the atmosphere was relaxing. I enjoyed everything about Vintage Cantina!
Anne Edison-Albright
Stopped here for dinner on our way to Door County; so glad we did! We were the only ones there with kids but everyone welcomed us and the whole family had a delicious meal. The menu is flexible for a wide range of allergies, dietary needs and tastes. I was able to have lots of dairy and nut free choices, which isn't always easy to get when we eat out. Grateful for the excellent hospitality and meal!
Maria Fiscal
Great atmosphere! Great drinks -ordered the salty watermelon margarita and a limeade. And a great variety of tacos - ordered barbacoa, carnitas and carne asada
Eric Christenson
There is quite a bit to like here. The atmosphere is decent. It's not amazing; it is an update on the restaurant that used to be there, but not significantly remarkable. That being said, it's good for a date night or a bite to eat before a show at the theater next door.
It's definitely not a place for small kids. I think the only thing a 3-year-old was guacamole (hold the peppers) and orange juice.
The drink selection was fairly limited. The house margarita was excellent, as was the freshly squeezed orange juice. For an appetizer we got guacamole, which we agreed was too small for the price and the quantity of chips with which it was served. It was decent guacamole, though, especially if you like it on the spicy side.
We got their Thursday special, mushroom tempura tacos. We both liked these spicy, delicious tacos very much. I also tried the avocado tacos and Thai Brussels tacos, both made vegan, and both pretty good. Overall the tacos were a hit.
The server we had was very friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. She was able to make solid recommendations for which kind of tortillas to use with which tacos and which could be made vegan.
If I could change one thing, I'd say add a few more options, especially for little kids, but having a burrito or fajita plate would also go a long way. If you love tacos, or margaritas, though, this place has some amazing ones.
Update: after coming here again after such a long time, the experience was a bit lacking. Their options are more limited than they were previously, which lowered my enthusiasm a bit. Drinks and guacamole are still good, but not much else.
Michael Cheri
I loved the variety of tacos. I prefer the thinner type of nacho chips than the type they serve. The queso dip was incredible
Shawn Schumacher
If zero stars were a possibility I would. Customer service from the servers, bartenders, and owner were unprofessional. Especially the owner was rude not only to my wife and I but made comments to the rest of our guests to the point. We were there to celebrate a birthday party and they were not busy. They made it seem like they weren’t able to accommodate at party of 10 people and made us feel very uncomfortable. We decided to take our business elsewhere. I will NEVER go back because of this experience. I suggest others think twice if you decide to being a party of 4 or more.
Becca Lynn Tassone
Went tonight, and service was stellar-thanks, Amy! House margaritas are the best I’ve ever had. Chips are so good and so was the carrot spread (despite it looking like baby food). Fried avocado taco was amazing. Shrimp and grits taco was good-the grits were so yummy. The tempura fish taco was eh-tasted like the fish was not seasoned-no salt and pepper even. Overall a great experience. Kind of stood around for a bit before we were greeted-not knowing we seat ourselves. But for that and the fish taco, it would have been 5 stars!
Michelle Hedtke Virtues
Great little place for "high end" tacos. Very tasty with many options. Closest to real Mexico fish and shrimp tacos I've had in area. Atmosphere is neat and if first floor is full check upstairs too. Oh and the margaritas are great too!! Looking at other reviews, our service was great. Walked in and greeted by waitress. Told us we can sit anywhere. Chose window seat and she came and cleaned it immediately for us. Our waitress was friendly and helpful with ordering as it was our first (of many) visits.
Dana King
Incredible coconut margaritas! Fantastic unique taco. The best tortilla chips in Wisconsin. I would give it five stars but it is a little pricey. Always had top service.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes