Lauren Ganther
Love Bake My Day!! We had them make cake for our wedding and it was so beautiful and delicious! They are so kind and easy to work with! Highly recommend them!!
Jess French
Bake My Day has certainly made our day! We ordered cupcakes for my fathers 77th birthday! They were all packaged and ready for pick up when we arrived. The red velvet was a personal favorite of mine, but given the variety we selected for this custom order... everyone was certainly happy with our dessert! Thank you for being a part of our family celebrations!
Jason Roemaat
Bake My Day made my wedding cake just how I envisioned! The mini tier cake with sheet cakes were definitely the best route for us and the flavors tasted amazing! We went with 3 flavors... but honestly they have so many it was hard to pair down. I'm not sure how the day of delivery went since I wasn't there, but it was set up by the time guests arrived. They even left a box for us to be able to take home the tip teir in. The cake tasted amazing!
Beth Relyea
Such an amazing crew to work with! They listened to my ideas for our wedding cake and it came out looking so much more elegant and pretty than I had imagined! And the flavors..... just so amazing!! Highly recommend the amaretto and cherry! Thank you so much for adding "sweet" memories to our wedding day!
Rhya Bleser
I had been recommended to go to Bake My Day through multiple friends, as their presentation and cake quality was respectable for the Green Bay Area. Initially, I contacted the owners and they were nothing but polite, and also went out of their way to allow us to taste the cake flavors, when they usually only do this for wedding cakes only. From there on out, the cake and the process was a disaster. We went in for our cake consultation and spent over an hour with the lady trying to capture every detail of the cake. They were extremely difficult and made it almost impossible to recreate the image, with every detail being an added on fee. We had requested a tiered cake, but would have been outrageously expensive to purchase as there were add on fees for almost everything, from the flavor of the cake, the extra words and details upon the cake, the display, fondant, and more to name. Yes, we have purchased cakes before and are aware that there are some additional fees, but this seemed excessive. We ended up switching our style of the cake, as it was an easier and cheaper, still fairly pricey, option. We had provided photos for the cakes. Upon pick up, the cakes represented nothing of the given pictures and was of poor quality. We had ordered two cakes, neither of which were of expected quality or presentation. The sheet cake that we had purchased was iced in a hideous blue, not resembling the theme or the other blues with the corresponding cake, and the words on the cake were not straight, rather in a zig-zig and crooked. It appeared that the cake was rushed to be finished this morning and there was no effort put into the presentation. For the second cake, it is similar to the provided photo, but does not have the qualities that we had requested. The frosting is speared, the details on top look ridiculous and could have been done better my a high school culinary student, and there are no fondant pieces, which were requested. Additionally, to add onto the day this was a cake for a high school graduation and when picked up the sadness and disapproval from my daughter was evident, with no concern or address to the problem. The customer service was impressive and appreciative at the beginning, but the product is not of good quality and does not meet the needs of the customer. This cake could have been made for a MUCH cheaper price at a chain grocery store with a much better presentation. I would not recommend coming her for anything but a basic cake with little to no detail.
ellie rasmussen
My favorite cake shop in town I always order from bake my day because I know I'm never disappointed ever always tastes good even 5-7days after! I always order you guys for my birthday every yr I always request BAKE MY DAY! No other cake stands up to you guys!
Tina D
I was recommended to Bake My Day by a friend since I needed a last minute birthday cake and I’m here to say that they didn’t disappoint! They came through in less than a day’s notice. The cake was baked fresh that morning and they had it decorated and ready by early afternoon. It was beautiful and so delicious! I’m a customer for life! Awesome whipped cream frosting as well! Thank you to the staff at Bake My Day! 😃
Lawrence Pieri
Visit their shop for the first time today, as they advertised Gluten free cupcakes. I was very disappointed with the quality of their cupcakes. As soon as you take a bite, they fall apart and crumbled they tasted like they were made from a box mix. I spent $14 for 4 cup cakes and feel very disappointed.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes