Sluurpy
Reset

There are 11 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Hicksville

There are 11 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Vinnie's Mulberry Street
93/100 (512 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Delivery
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Definitely one of the best pizzerias in the area. Staff is very friendly. I got the buffalo chicken pizza, and it was the best one I've had by far...."
Tiffany Chen
"Really good pizza and staff is unbelievably..."
Max Cohn
"Pizza was delicious! We loved the family feel of this place and the owner was a stud. Clean inside and service was very quick. The grandma was the..."
Nick Bierman
"Classic NY style pizza , fresh ingredients. Pizza taste at its best. I tried many local pizza place in LI, this is one of best tasting NY style..."
Guess MyName
"Best pizza in the hood tried the rest you will come back to the Best. Are they make you feel like family they remember my name every time I go there..."
Richard Bifulco
"Great friendly neighborhood pizza joint. Fresh and tasty all the time. Tried some of their desserts / gelato which was also pretty..."
Krishna Y.
"After seeing many delicious looking pics on Instagram I finally got a chance to try this place and wow was I impressed by them the Upside down was..."
Joseph Lanzarotta
"Consistently perfect Grandma pie - the best I've ever had - light, crispy crust with tasty sauce and the right amount of cheese. The team is..."
Kelly D
"One of the only pizzerias that has both amazing pizza and amazing pasta! I love going there, they're so nice and the food is always fresh and tasty!..."
Carla Dods
"My favorite place. They make the absolute BEST rigatoni and broccoli..."
Erin Pugliese
"One of the kindest and most generous owner. Was closing time and he decided to have me try everything on the display before closing. Amazing attitude..."
Sumraiz Mehmud
"Very well prepared delicious lunch entrees. Hot rolls and zeppoles included when ordering entrees and dining in. Perfect sized portions for lunch...."
Susan E
"They make the best Pizza Cones in the Industry! We had ours stuffed with chicken. Thanks, great Idea! It's a must have for..."
Richard Palmeri
"The pizza is amazing and it's one of the best pizza in Long Island. Their Upside down square pizza is better than the famous L&B Spumoni Gardens in..."
Tony L
"This is the place to go for pizza, Italian dishes, heroes and chicken rolls. Best chicken rolls on Long Island. Enjoy your visit and..."
Lou Cap
"The best. Love this place for years. Can't believe I haven't left a review before. Nat and Vito have been crushing it for years here. Quality..."
Daniel Lada
"GOOD PIZZA.. but wasn't crispy enough. Maybe next time..."
Armando Rodriguez (Mobile Express USA)
Raimo's Pizza
91/100 (786 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Been here since 1989, always had Mario’s before and was pretty good 8.5/10. Discovered this place by word of mouth. Even though it’s 10-15 mins..."
Ryan Suh
"I grew up in this neighborhood back in the 70’s and 80’s. Raimo’s pizza every Friday was a treat that I have fond memories. It was awesome then..."
Christine Werner
"This place was AMAZING!! From the food to the service everything was Grade A+! We will definitely be coming back here..."
danielle lobosco
"The food was AMAZING!!!! So flavorful and delicious!! The service was great and Bobby treated us like family! HIGHLY..."
Joe Marin
"Delicious! Worth trying people! The aroma of rhe fresh sause smell fills the air as you walk in The food cooked fresh Clean and well kept..."
Maryann B (Bluemidget)
"I’m 5 mins from Marios, Phils and every pizza shop you can name on jericho turnpike or the surrounding area. But my family and I make the drive..."
wou day
"Raimo's Hicksville Sicilian and grandma pizza beats everyone in Long Island. I don't care what others say, their fracchia bread is the best period...."
Tropical Smoothie Cafe Hicksville
"I have been going here since the place first opened back in 1976 or 77 I think. I was around 14 then. The owner, Sal, always was consistant with the..."
Me To
"Very pleasant staff. Delicious food. Been a staple in Hicksville for over 20 years. I believe these are new owners sometime over the last 5 to 10..."
Flak DiNenno
"I have been going there for many years, since high school. The ownership may have changed, but the food remains fresh and delicious. It is a happy..."
Arlene Giese
Trullo D'oro
87/100 (600 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Fish
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I must have driven past this gem a million times. A friend suggested we meet and eat here. It was a great choice. My Ravioli was superb, my..."
Michael Costa
"Highly recommend. Lovely service, nice atmosphere and we loved all our food choices. Gino (owner) came over to our table to welcome us once we were..."
S Perez
"Wonderful restaurant and freshly made for the party. Geno and Marie are two lovely and gracious host and hostess. Everyone will love the hospitality..."
Lorina Bautista
"Love this place. Went last night and had the Sea Bass Franchese. It was very light and delicious. My husband had the Chicken Parm and said that was..."
Debra Stern
"True authentic Italian food and owner straight from Italy! Classic dishes but also delicious different combinations..owner is willing to make you..."
Valerie Lauto
"First - this restaurant is AMAZING! The food is incredibly fresh and tasty with every bite! Prepared to perfection. The best part, the chief even..."
Michael Dziubas
"We had a special dinner at Trullo D’Oro with 3 generations at the table and everyone loved it. The owner (returned from La Caravella days) and..."
Kardhru D
"I ate dinner for the first time at Trullo D'Oro last night with my parents, and we can't wait to go back! The food was incredible from the baked..."
Lauren Foundos
"A local gem! We are so happy to have discovered this cute little Italian place with amazing food. It is one of our go-to places for a delicious meal..."
Linda Silver
"I went here with my family tonight and absolutely loved it. The food tasted amazing, the atmosphere was beautiful, traditional. The service was..."
Kyron
"Had dinner with 2 friends. Everything about the restaurant was terrific. The food was wonderful and felt like I was in Italy. I am not so easy to..."
Edith Rae Brown
"Down from Boston for the weekend to visit the old neighborhood and family. Tried this restaurant for the first time. Upon entering we were greeted..."
George Odonits
"We went to Trullo D'Oro on mother's day and had a truly delicious dinner. This restaurant used to be LA Caravella and to my delight had the same..."
Anita Rivman
"The first time I had eaten there, the veal I ordered was delicious , the service was very good, the atmosphere was pleasant. No complaints, I would..."
Laurie Bahna
"This Hicksville Italian restaurant is a must go to establishment. A fine menu with very good service. Go and have Gino and Maria create a dining..."
Lou Cap
"The entire experience was great. It is a family owned restaurant that puts their heart and sole into their food and care for their customers. The..."
Derek Teitel
"13 people Lunch. Parking on the side of the Restaurant. Great ambiance, excellent service, owner is personable and funny and Food was..."
Rajnish Kapur
Pasta-eria
85/100 (580 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Irish
Irish
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Irish
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The food is delicious and the servings are enough to take home for seconds. I had the chicken parm with spaghetti and the chicken was juicy and..."
yvette seibert
"So glad to be invited to dinner a Pasta-eria... nicely decorated, great servers (Marco and Noel) very attentive, polite, and efficient! ..."
David S
"First of all ask to be seated in Noel's section. He's great! Whatever he suggests, order it. He is batting 2 out of 2 in Great things to eat..."
Wendy Maini
"Sat in the dining room for a pizza and some coffee. The waiter was awesome, and the guys at the counter were nice guys. Pizza was..."
Kevin Bartolotto
"The food is amazing, excellent customer service. Outside just looks like a small pizzeria but they also have a restaurant inside and it’s very..."
Genesis Paulino
"The pizza is great. The meatball parm hero is great. The chicken parm hero is great. And so are the rice balls. Love the sauce they have here. And..."
Quinn Duffy
"Great food. Good service. Good presentation of food. Maybe 1 more noodle would have been..."
Jason Sims
"It's one of my all-time favorite places. The staff is always the best. Food is 100% and so much food I always bring home..."
Chris Pellicci
"The food is pretty good from here , but the fried chicken cutlet taste old and..."
emartinezc
"Best pizza on LI by far. Portnoy needs to visit if hasn’t..."
Rit
"I love this place! Great gnocchi and very great wait staff. Large portions that match the price. I am big on good service, so I hope the owners know..."
Sarah T
Marios
82/100 (837 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great selection of pizza toppings, plenty of seating. Pizza delicious and perfect crispy..."
Amy Cole
"THIS PIZZA IS SO GOOD. Myhusband loves for the white ricotta, I love rhe chicken bacon ranch. The garlic knots are the best. We drive all the way..."
Leah Munz
"Mario’s is one of the best in Nassau County hands down. The variety of pizza they have must be over 15 and the quality of the food and Taste is..."
Malatak
"My bf and I tried other pizza places, but its just not Marios at Westbury. Absolutely delicious pizza, huge slices, and have never regreted going. We..."
joselyn beltran
"Nice pizza spot. Not a typical NYC slice, but it's still very good. Nice cripsy crust. As far as Pizza shops go, this one is well lit and comfortable..."
Anthony Moy
"We ordered through Doordarsh after our car broke down just after we got here and it was very convenient. We had ordered Persian food for ourselves..."
Sarah McCollum
"One of the best pizza places I've ever been! It took me awhile to pick because I wanted everything and that doesn't happen very often for me. staff..."
ivelina Gadelov
"Food was good, I order a cheese slice with extra cheese 🧀 taste..."
Franklin cruz
"Very good sausage slices,crust is firm and Sausage, pepper & onion roll, very..."
Wanda Kittell
"The best pizza in the area by a long shot. I love the taste and how cheesy it is. I give them 5 starts because the food deserves it, as well the..."
Ron Herrera
"Been coming here a lot lately. The garlic knots are..."
Michael Rosenberg
"Pizza was very tasty and cheesy , I had the plain..."
Donald S
"It's definitely one of the pizzerias of all..."
Joe Mama
"Ive been going to this pizzeria for years and it's my favorite pizza spot. Their specialty slices are delicious, their staff is super nice and their..."
Eric Martin
"Love this place, order from them all the time. Yesterday was the first visit to the restaurant, which is immaculate. The strip mall in which it's..."
Hallie Hardenburgh
"They make great salads to order. Comes with piece of Italian..."
Ava Marie Gabriel
Bellerose Famous Pizza
80/100 (173 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Mid-range
"Awesome pizza but loved their falafel. Will visit soon with..."
Parag K Pandya
"Ordered a half buffalo chicken, half barbeque chicken pie with some friends. The person at the counter offered to make a fresh one even though there..."
Avril Skywalker
"Excellent service, excellent pizza, and excellent wraps. I have no idea where or what Justin Balducci was eating, clearly he has no taste, because..."
Sandeep Chatrath
"They make excellent Pizza. They do have other stuff but I've found their Pizza to be the best. They make personal pies for$6.75. Add a topping for..."
Parmjit Singh
"Love the pizza and wraps in this clean and friendly place! Can't wait to go back and try the falafel too. All five of us, two parents and three..."
Donna Dholakia
"Often imitated but never duplicated. Its the closest to Singas pizza with just a different name. Prices are great, food is great. Check it out next..."
Jason Ramos
"Best pizza, so many options to choose from, all fresh ingredients . Always delicious. The best falafel too.My favorite is jalapeño and onion. The..."
Anil Wadhwani
"This pizzera is what mom/pop gourmet flavor is all about. I have a 3 yr autistic child that is so picky with food that only a pizza from this place..."
Anil Masih
"Great tasting. Lots of customization options. Fairly standard wait time (usually only 20 minutes). And most of all, excellent customer..."
Nikhil Sanghvi
"Great place!! The pizza was fresh and spot on. The falafels are a must try!! The place was clean and the staff was friendly. Great new addition to..."
kal patel
"A lot better run than the previous pizza place at this location. The people working here are nicer and the food is..."
Marc Gonzalez
"Finally Bellrose pizza is close to home in Hicksville. Yummiest pizza ever. Love their crust and..."
simran kalra
"Wings are incredible I would highly recommend that you try. Love them and I will be there soon getting some more of those delicious..."
Garrett Nuttall
"The Chicken Tikka wrap is amazing. The service was great and the food is wonderful. We’ll definitely be..."
Jeffrey G
Cheers Restaurant Bar & Grill
78/100 (122 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Italian
Spanish
Latin
Indian
"We had our company holiday party at Cheers. They closed down the entire place for us which was very nice of them to fo for us. We had a DJ and..."
Ariel Weigel
"Just had lunch for the first time here. Our waiter was wonderful: friendly, attentive, polite and not overbearing. Food was really good! We each had..."
Kimberly Kuck
"Hicksville is a pretty quiet town, with not too much night life. With that being said, Cheers Sports Bar & Grill is a great hang out! The food..."
Christian Nunes
"Great atmosphere and drinks. Good for sports night. Some food items on the menu are great as well. Downstairs Party Hall is also good for..."
Karandeep Singh
"First night cheers is offering pasta night. The food that you get for the price is amazing. $10.95 multiple choices of pasta and sauces. Bread with..."
Raymond Dalton
"Awesome place. I really love the food and prices for the food and drinks are simply amazing. The servers and the bartenders are very friendly and..."
Harry Malhotra
"Cheers just started a Wednesday pasta night, $10.95. Great selection of pasta and sauces. We ordered the fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, The..."
Ray Greco
"Great drinks & atmosphere! The staff was very friendly from the second we walked in until we left. I highly recommend this place if your looking for..."
samantha koske
"This place has the best of both worlds. You can chill at the bar while watching some sports games with your buddies plus there is a pool table to..."
Sarbjit Singh
"Great Mixed Drinks! Good bar food. Good place to hit up during happy hour. Servers are friendly and very informative and helpful when trying to..."
Kristopher Lee
"Love the atmosphere such great food and amazing customer service with even better prices. The drinks are also pretty great. Harry was so..."
Ryee H.
Patrizia's
77/100 (1661 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Lamb chops
Octopus
Pesto
Fish
Lobster
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Clams
Calamari
Calamares
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My sister visited from CA I made reservations for her 50th Birthday and everything was great. The food, the service, the music, the atmosphere was..."
LaToya B
"Best Italian Restaurant on LI!! Food, Service and especially the Music. If you want to have excellent fresh food with great party atmosphere, this is..."
Edward Park
"I did my 40th bday dinner here in the semi private tent and I had a blast andddd the food was amazing!!!! 10 out of 10 recommend!!! I dealt with Sal..."
Georgenia Rapley
"Came here for Father's day with the family. We got the family style meal and everyone enjoyed every course. Especially the kids. Our server,..."
Brian Kupchik
"The food was great...my wife had the salmon with pistachio and I had the eggplant Parm..... Joe the manager was very attentive and we had a good time..."
jeyson cruz bajurto
"Wow, not bad for a franchise Italian restaurant. The portion was good size. Definitely will need to finish it by tomorrow haha. The food was so 👍...."
Stanley Chan
"amazing. come here. order the lasagna. the lasagna is phenomenal. the calamari is phenomenal as well, especially with the thai sauce. everything on..."
Lialeska Payano
"Classic Italian restaurant. Bubbling with energy from wait staff and the patrons. Dinner guests across the floor joined in on random songs and..."
Kundan Sen
"We just celebrated my mom's 65th and my aunt's 60th birthday at Patrizia's. We opted for the family style menu and was not disappointed. Every person..."
Naila Lalla
"I celebrated a retirement lunch here yesterday. Everything from the service to the food was excellent. The food which was served family style just..."
Gina R
"This place is very Italian family oriented style they have huge dishes which is great. Everyone joins together and sings Happy Birthday it's a huge..."
Chris V
"Who would I be if I didn’t get Seafood?!? You guys are funny 😋 If I don’t get seafood somewhere, that means they didn’t have it. The squid..."
LiveThroughHope
"Went with some friends to check out the food served in there family style dining. It was delicious, and alot of it. The servers were extremely..."
Carol Ali
"Oh my. Beyond words. The food was plentiful and delicious. Every course. I have never raved over a Cesar salad before. This was just incredible. Our..."
Jack Shea
Alex Pizza
75/100 (92 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Italian
Cheap Eats
Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant
73/100 (1558 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Just about to enjoy my chicken franchise with a house salad and can’t forget about the delicious bread that comes with it. Every time I am hungry..."
david darvas
"GOOD FOOD & GREAT SERVICE! I came in to pick up lunch. Whole dining room was full so you know the food has to be good. Everyone in the back seemed to..."
Melissa Colato
"I love going to this Calda, it’s the original one. Their regular slice is absolutely top tier. Nice crust and not so much cheese and oil dripping..."
Frank Deets
"Food is delicious, excellent quality, and they have a great special on certain days of the week.. I would highly recommend, the salad , grandma pie..."
Patrick Schmith
"Elvis is the MAN ! The hospitality , the professionalism , and of course , the FOOD was exceptional ! Thank you so much for making our party perfect...."
Alicia V
"For years, Dimaggios was my go to pizza spot. They've gone downhill. Tried Calda and love it. Wide menu choice..."
Ken Norian
"In town visiting family for the Holidays and I had to get some Calda's Pizza. It is still every bit as good as I..."
Peter Del Sordo
"Great pizza! I bought two pies to freeze and bring down south for my proper NY pizza..."
Safiya
"I love the penne ala vodka with grilled chicken. Never..."
Jen C
"My new favorite pizza! The standard slice is excellent. Bakery slice was out of this world! Service was prompt. Will definitely be..."
Abe Frohman
"Grilled chicken and chicken noodle soup are exceptional, my favorite go to meal I have been ordering from calda in hicksville for 3 years and I have..."
jeanette barry
"Great pizza. It has become our go..."
Annafi Chowdhury
"Finally a great authentic NY pizza!! I'm a truck driver and order pizza when I come thru NY but have been pretty disappointed with other pizzerias..."
Michael Murray
"Elvis was great food was great I love this spot . Easily my go to..."
Anthony Cruz
"Just ordered a half mushroom / sausage pizza. The sauce was tasteless , hardly any cheese , and the mushrooms & sausage were not that good . Won’t..."
Edward Chiusano
"Good is always great and so is the service. BEST veal parmigiana..."
Lonnie Weigele
Sbarro
70/100 (41 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use