This is our first time at my pie pizza. We love the atmosphere, the location and the food. We got the NY Roni and the margarita pizza. The pizzas were cooked to perfection and the flavor was amazing. Felt like I was getting a homemade pizza. I would give this place a try If you are in Holladay and are in the mood for some good New York style pizza.
Decent pizza, I was suggest getting the well-done crust other than that it will be a little bit Dowie. The margarita pizza sauce is a sweet sauce. The New York style pizza was good.
There are a lot of pizza options out there, but My Pie Pizza easily stands apart as one of the best. My family loves having a family dinner there every few weeks; their “personalize your pizza” flow makes it so easy to get exactly what you want. Make sure you try their spicy wings - they’re probably the best wings in the Salt Lake area. Not kidding.
GET IT! Soooo delicious and tasty . OOh my goodness I would have given this place 10 stars if I could have .I definitely recommend trying sliced almonds on your pizza of choice !!!!!!! Soooooo YUMMY!!! 😊👍👍
Perfectly cooked and all special instructions followed to a T! Great priced, HOT, prompt phenomenal mouth watering GOODNESS! DEFINITELY MY PIZZA PIE and my ONE & ONLY PIZZA PLACE NOW! 💯.
Pizza was great, really like the options and the taste. Had the veggie Calzone which was great. They closed the lobby right after we arrived so we had the place to ourselves. The sign on the door when we left said they were short handed even though there were at least 4 or 5 employees wandering around. Didn't really make sense to me, but food was good.
Great pizza. Especially the Very Vegan. Really haven’t tried anything else, though. Fantastic quality for the price, and a great option for Holladay residents.
If you do place a take-out order on a Friday or Saturday night it does take 10-15 minutes longer than their website predicts. Otherwise great.
Just all around good food so far, I've not had a bad pizza here.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes