Sluurpy
Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cheesecake in Holmes Beach

There are 6 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe
99/100 (318 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheesecake
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
Scott's Deli
95/100 (477 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Deli
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Roast Beef
Breakfast Sandwich
Pork
Salad
Cheesecake
Tapas
Tacos
Sandwiches
Sit down
Deli
American
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"This place was awesome! The sandwich was really tasty. I was very happy with this last-minute stop for..."
Megan Kofol
"Amazing food and choices! Loves everything I have tried! The key lime pie was amazing and the kitchen sink cookie was..."
Brandon Hoff
"Great food. Near the end of vacation you start to get sick of eating out but I really enjoyed this place. BBQ turkey wrap is 10/10. I’ve also heard..."
Glutz
"We've been on Anna Maria Island for two weeks and had lunch three times at Scotts Deli. The food is so fresh and delicious we just couldn't resist..."
Ruth mcallister
"Ordered a cheesecake (Chocolate/Vanilla) swirl and it was sooo good and very reasonable. A real treat for Thanksgiving. Also their individual..."
Sue Luginbill
"What do a couple of Sandwich Heads do when they are are on holiday in Florida? We asked the locals and original members of Sandwich Club STL...."
Sandwich Club STL
"We ordered for the first time last week and the food was amazing. I also want to note we ordered from our beach chair and they brought it to us in..."
Jana Clemens
"My Italian sandwich was amazing and my mom loved her turkey bacon avocado. The Lemon bars were also delicious! A perfect lunch after a morning at the..."
Amy Johnson
"We had Scottis deli do a taco bar for our family who was visiting from Maine. The service and quality of the food was 10 out of 10. This is the..."
Trudy Chelminiak
"A little hard to find but it is inside the building. We drove around the entire building before we noticed the store is inside and to the left...."
Meredith Buikema
"Scott’s deli is super legit. The roast beef sandwich is ridiculously good and a few the other sandwiches. I’ve had there have been just as tasty...."
J Q
"We got an Italian sub,it's was delicious! Service is good, food good and atmosphere is..."
BRANDY Samuels
"This place has the BEST deli sandwiches!!! I've tried several and have loved them all, but my absolute favourite is the Coquina - it's got the..."
Kathryn Tyrell
"My family and I had carryout from Scott's Deli on a recent vacation to AMI. The sandwiches were very good. I enjoyed the Coquina with its interesting..."
Ed Paff Jr.
"Food was phenomenal and great customer service. Highly recommend a stop..."
J K
"Quite possibly one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. I had a Reuben and my wife had a GF Cuban. Loaded with meat. Huge bread in both cases. The..."
Rick Leichter
"By far the best sandwich shop we have visited. Plenty of food, the taste is great. We stop every..."
Brad Messerschmidt
Vinny's Italian Kitchen
93/100 (807 ratings)
Specialty Food Market
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Romana
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Southern-Italian
Vegan Options
Sicilian
Tuscan
Central-Italian
Lazio
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Cannoli
Chicken Parmesan
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Bolognese
Lasagne
Sandwiches
Sit down
Central-Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Tuscan
Pizza
Romana
Lazio
Italian
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Smelled heavenly when we walked in ❤️❤️ Ordered the garlic cheesey bread and the sauce was to die for 💕 Had dessert it was great too..."
Janice Lynne McDonald Penney
"Fantastic authentic Italian food, perfect for take out!! Love the Roma, Caprese (with prosciutto) and chicken parmigiana. We stayed in Anna Maria..."
Dean Merola
"My only complaint is this is not a sit down restaurant! This place would kill if it was. We need a good authentic Italian restaurant. Please expand..."
Amy Elizabeth
"Simply fantastic! If you love italian, this place will rock your world! #meatlasagne..."
John W Felix III
"Had a wonderful time not just eating but visiting work Vinnie!!! Thanks for the..."
Erin Henshaw
"I've been there several times and I'm always impressed with the..."
Carla Whaley Swartz
"Amazing! Like being back in Brooklyn 30 years..."
Ray Spezzacatena
"So glad I heard about this place from a local.... The food is amazing! Definitely will be..."
Meaghan Craven
"This place is adorable!! You can tell there is so much love in this place. We had pizza which was great, but they have so much more. If you go in,..."
Christine B
"Take out only at this restaurant which was perfect for a night in for dinner. When the menu says “feeds 2” per entree it means it. The portions..."
Griffith Osburn
"Vinny’s is a must have for lunch every time we vacation here. Hands down best sub sandwiches and value. One large sub will easily feed four people,..."
Michael Law
"As an Italian, I adore finding a great deli/ market that is so authentic. Vinny’s is just that and I can’t wait to return to pick up a few..."
Nancy Doda
"I love it when they answer the phone and you can place your order and not have to stand around and wait! Hoorah! We ordered the carbonara and garlic..."
RodeoGirl
"Our group wanted pizza for dinner the last night of our visit. We scoured reviews to find the best pizza. We selected Vinny's and we're not..."
Edward Knight
"Great Margherita pizza, really thin crust. And the chocolate cake! With a cold glass of milk was outstanding. Quite service even though the place..."
Marian Purzycki
"Run there.. do not walk. If you want seriously some of the most delicious fresh baked bread sandwich.. then you have found the place. The bread is to..."
barbara lon
"Vinny’s is a great restaurant on the island. We tried Pasta, hot sandwich & a pizza. Everything was great. Service is quick & responsive. Store is..."
jaydeep sarvaiya
"Came here on recommendations and was sure not disappointed. Pizza was great. Thin crust and just the right amount of sauce. Also tried their..."
Tom Litsogiannis
"We ordered the spaghetti and meatballs for my son for his birthday because it’s his favorite food. We initially had planned to eat here but many of..."
W. Matthew Gooch
"The whole family enjoyed this meal. I have to order GF and had the chicken parmigiana, it came with the best piece of gf bread I’ve ever had and..."
Tabatha Smith
"Went here for the first time in a good minute (I live on the island) and left wondering why I hadn’t been back sooner. Atmosphere was rustic and it..."
Daniel JDP
"Absolutely loved the food from here!! We had the premade food from here and it was delicious. 3 boxes and a garlic bread fed 6 of us (2 per dish) as..."
Amy Lambton
"Awesome experience!! Love the food and the service was great!! All the employees have a vast knowledge of their wines, cheeses, pastries and products..."
victor florenciani
"Picked up party size dishes for family dinner. Very pleased with the value and service. Will definitely come back on my next visit to..."
Will Johnson
"Take out only authentic Italian food right on the island. So busy you need to order in the morning to make sure they will be able to prepare for your..."
Sarah Pawley
"Best pizza ever! Can’t wait to try some of their other food as well. Also love the market and wine selections, this place deserves 10..."
Joe
"Oh my goodness, this place is the best Italian restaurant I’ve ever been to. I have celiac disease and have a hard time finding decent Italian food..."
Katya Klein
The Feast Restaurant
91/100 (3054 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Soups
Seafood
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Risotto
Fried Green Tomatoes
Escargot
Mussels
White Pizza
Sandwiches
Key lime pie
Calamares
Shrimp Pasta
Burger
Grouper Sandwich
Cakes
Salmon
Black and Bleu Burger
Pesto
Mahi Mahi
Fish
Beet Salad
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Escargot
Cheesecake
Chicken Parmesan
Garlic bread
Fish & Chips
Clam Chowder
Lobster
Greek salad
Crab Legs
Firecracker Shrimp
Pasta
Coleslaw
Ribs
Grouper Cheeks
Salad
Fish & chips
Hogfish Captiva
Clam Chowder
Fettuccini Shrimp Alfredo
Tropicale Salad
Crab
Scallops
Fried shrimp
Shrimp and Lobster Alfredo
Lobster and Shrimp Risotto
Calamari
Caprese Salad
Alfredo
Sit down
American
Seafood
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
"Really enjoyed our meal and service. We will be back for dinner on our next visit. The lobster bisque was one of the best on the island. We tried..."
Casey Lynn
"The Feast is literally my favorite dining location on Anna Maria Island. The food is always fresh and local. The staff is knowledgeable, efficient..."
David Lee White
"Food was good and the service outstanding! And good..."
Isabel Bales
"The food is fantastic well worth the time and..."
Barry Sargent
"Absolute PHENOMENAL food and staff was..."
Jen Sargent
"Surprising little find in a strip center near Decoy Ducks and Tortilla Bay right across from the new Marriott Waterline Hotel.Made ressers..."
Pierre Le Beach
"Great find in a old little strip mall. Beet salad was delicious and I wish I could have tried more dishes. Reasonably priced and available parking..."
Tammy Phelps Cimaglia
"The best meal we have all had all week on the island.Price and portions were complimentary. Lobster, scallops, steak, shrimp,..."
Venus
"Really great food in a very ugly strip mall. If you come to Anna Maria to see the sunset this may not be the place for you. But if you are tired of..."
Linnalou
"Go here hungry!. Generous portions and a diverse menu! We had the firecracker shrimp as an appetizer plus three entrees that were ALL yummy! We can..."
Dpmahoney_2
"A great dinner. For a special occasion we chose The Feast Restaurant. Having never visited before I envisioned a place with greasy chicken where you..."
Art
"We had the Pretty Tasty and The Works pizzas. It was good. The crust could be a little crispier in the center. We called 20 minutes before they..."
TheItalianCajun
"Great choice for authentic feel of Anna Maria. Cozy, friendly , home like food . Clam chowder is delicious. Not a typical tourist trap..."
Vadim Klochko
"Ignore the decor...the food is so worth it!. I was skeptical when we first found this local eatery in a strip mall near Anna Maria, & the whole..."
M M
"This place has great apps- firecracker shrimp, Ahi tuna and fish bites are super tasty. Grilled Snapper sandwich, pasta salad and house salad main..."
Andy Payne
"Really like it.. Can't say we've ever had a bad dish/bad experience in a half dozen visits. I like the..."
Booyakasha
"Soups were excellent. Bowl isn't much bigger than a cup though. Caprese salad was fine although I've never had it with green tomatoes before. Prices..."
BDA
"Good, Reasonably-Priced Lunches. We've had a late lunch at The Feast a number of times the past two winters. The lunch menu is reasonably-priced and..."
Bob
"Outstanding. Ahi tuna app was huge, fresh and tasty. Carbonara was nontraditional with bacon but very good. added scallops which were very good and a..."
Lauracooks
"Just off the plane from Houston Texas visiting friends that rented a beach house in Anna Maria. This place has excellent pizza. Hit the spot after..."
Holly Willms
"Had them deliver a meal when we arrived on the island, ample servings , prompt , food was good. It is a little pricey but you are paying for them to..."
Joe B
"YUM!. Really happy the Feast finally moved from Longboat to Holmes Beach. I'm a vegetarian, and really like the veg options - the pizza and veggie..."
Foodie1
"It's "ok"..."
Taylor D.
"Trey did an outstanding job taking care of us. He made the kids feel special. We had the crab and artichoke dip, the lobster and shrimp risotto, a..."
Lisa Hubbard
"We came here based on the reviews. Grace our server was super friendly and nice. We got calamari as a starter and it was very fresh. We ordered 2..."
Nardeen Morkos
"We at here with a party of 11. We made reservations a few days prior so we didn't wait long once we got to the restaurant. They had to seat us..."
IRONMAN27
"The Feast is one of our family's favorite restaurants on the island. We've tried many things on the menu and there's nothing I wouldn't order again...."
Debbie Wright
"Amazing food and outstanding service! Our server was super attentive and patient! Best dining experience on the island so far and definitely worth..."
Grace Haynes
"I came looking for Snow Crab Legs and this was the only place on Anna Maria Island that felt sure to have them. We came early and still had to sit..."
Kimberly Moy
"I had the Tropicana Salad with Salmon cooked just right. Husband had all you can eat crab. All dishes observed to other tables looked just as..."
Robin Parker
"Food was good. Coconut shrimp dinner was good, got 9 shrimps and two sides. Sides were a bit small, and could of had more of selections on sides..."
Maryann Rainey
"Nice little spot! We found this place through Google while vacationing here in Anna Maria. My husband got the Wagyu steak, and I got the Wagyu..."
E J
"Have been coming here for years and always make sure to get to this restaurant. Food is great and reasonably priced. We had a group of 9 people and..."
Jacklyn Faulkner
"If you want great food this is the place. No working bar so I deducted a star for atmosphere. But whoever is running this kitchen knows how to cook...."
Jansen Honberger
"The crab and shrimp linguine is fabulous !! The servers are always courteous and friendly. I recently found out they have pizza, and it turns..."
Doug Zandstra
"A new find and favorite! Knowing the sunset madness timing we found this spot and loved its menu. Delicious seafood pasta dishes and a nice..."
Erin O'Connor
"Ordered take out and ended up getting the wrong order (innocent mistake) went back in and not only did they give us the right one but they went..."
Jennifer Eads
"This restaurant was AMAZING! We ordered the crab and artichoke dip as an appetizer and it was great. I ordered the shrimp, lobster, and scallop..."
Megan Severson
"AMAZING pizza. We got it one night to try some new pizza on the island and OH MY GOSH - best pizza I’ve had on AMI. Brought it home and it was gone..."
Elissa Earp
"You were able to fit us in yesterday evening at 7pm. It was ours last evening on AMI and always come to The Feast for our Last Supper! Trey, our..."
Lorrie Hawker
"While on a family vacation with my fiancés parents, we decided to try this restaurant. The food was great and had a pretty decent variety for those..."
lauren dill
Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff
86/100 (1944 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Sorbet
Cheesecake
Gelato
Cheesecakes
Ice Cream to Go
Ice Cream
Banana Splits Soft
Frozen Yogurt
Fish
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"We had such a wonderful experience in this family owned business. The flavors were beyond wonderful. They helped us with our smallest child’s..."
Yvonne Jones
"My husband & I enjoyed getting ice cream at Holy Cow! We were greeted with smiles when we came in. The owner & his family were very kind. We had..."
Mackenzie Pruitt
"We started coming to Holy Cow in 2020. The ice cream was the best and the owners were the kindest! We visited again in 2021 and finished each night..."
Jessica McLain
"The ice cream is locally made, and the service was great! I am pretty sure it is owned by a multi-generational local family. We look forward to..."
Rebecca Miller
"We absolutely love this place and it is a nightly ritual for us to visit when at AMI. What is better than supporting a small family business........"
Cara Newham
"We loved Holy Cow! We randomly found this cute shop and ended up stopping here 3 times on our vacation. The staff was super friendly and the..."
Noble Churovia
"We stopped into Holy Cow after lunch next door at Los Chiludos and were greeted with a smile by one of the owners. The store is incredibly clean and..."
Sarah Iwanski
"this is my first time visiting the island, and i LOVE Holy Cow’s Ice Cream!! it’s taste is rich and full of flavor, but the customer service is..."
Molly Vestal
"We could not wait to come back to Holy Cow Ice Cream this year on vacation. Last year was our first visit and ice cream was our first stop this year...."
Mary Williamson
"We love coming to this ice cream place! Melinda is so funny, as are the two owners. They have a variety of flavors, as well as cups, cones, shakes,..."
Cassia Cobb
"Our family has been visiting AMI for years and this was our first visit to Holy Cow Ice Cream. We arrived close to closing time . The owner and his..."
Jackie Rutkowski
"We have been coming down to anna maria for almost thirty years.. This is one of the most friendly and great experiences we've had. The ice cream is..."
Janna Bartlett
"When Joes closed we had to find a new place for ice cream and this place is great ! They have a very large fresh water fish tank, and contrary to..."
Doug Zandstra
"The ice cream is delicious with lots of fun, unique flavors to chose from. The owners are wonderful and do so much for the local..."
Alison Nora Hainline
"The ice cream was delicious and the servings were more than generous! Owner is super friendly and personable. Will be..."
Paige Boon
"Holy Cow ice cream is the best ice cream our family has ever had! You cannot go to Anna Maria Island without visiting this awesome small business!..."
James Skov
"Very friendly staff and extremely good ice cream. The whole family run business is very kind. The family takes donations and treats everyone with the..."
Calloway Walsh
Eat Here
81/100 (2110 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Salmon
Burger
Tempura
Grilled cheese
Kale Salad
French onion soup
Cheesecake
Fish & Chips
Shrimp
Tapas
Beef
Fish Taco
Tacos
Filet Mignon
Lobster
Ribs
Pasta
Meatloaf
Salad
Surf And Turf
Poutine
Clams
Oyster
Escargot
Mussels
Sandwiches
Cheesecakes
"This place was incredible. We were deciding on where to eat when we saw the “Eat Here” sign. We knew we had to stop in. Our server Shaun was..."
hayley wester
"Very creative eclectic menu options. Excellent wine and beer options including local craft beers. Very crowded so make sure you make reservations..."
Tony Lopapa
"I was thoroughly impressed by Eat Here. The menu and quality of the food was surprising considering the appearance of the signage from the road..."
Dominic Lane
"This restaurant is small with bistro casual vibe. The food was delicious and generous portions. We had the filet and the ribs. Servers are helpful,..."
Julie Koziol
"Wonderful little restaurant with great atmosphere and tasty food. Had the blackened shrimp fish taco and it was unbelievably fresh and..."
Thorsten
"Casual upscale dinning. poutine house fries and debris demi-glace, with a healthy dose of parmesan, added rich bites of foiegras-..."
Jeanna Kerchner
"Love the name. Great place right next to the Waterline Resort. Just had a round and apps. Nothing stood out but service was nice. Very busy inside..."
Jose Matos
"Great food at reasonable prices. My wife +I ate here 3 times and we're never disappointed. The roasted vegetables we're good enough that my wife..."
Jim Tolbert
"My wife and I have been going to Anna Maria for the past 7 years and try to go to Beach Bistro at least once during our stay. Much to our..."
John Hronek
"Delicious food! A small restaurant with high quality food. Not fancy or dressy, they served crackers and pimento to start. The stew was delicious, ..."
Adrienne cw
"The shrimp & lobster tacos are amazing! I ate at Eat Here on Halloween night when I was visiting Anna Maria and they took great care of my elderly..."
Brian Lowry
"The food was incredible - I mean that. I was not expecting such outstanding, gourmet food at a casual restaurant. We totally enjoyed the informal..."
L.E. E.
"Truly phenomenal! This was the best meal we’ve had in 9 months since quarantine began. So attentive to our allergy concerns and everything was..."
Chris Buettner
"WOW! Just returned from an amazing dinner with my wife and son -- couldn't be more pleased with the food and service. I had the meat loaf and it was..."
Joey Thomas
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use