The owner and everyone who works here is SO friendly! The food is AMAZING as well. This is the best homemade eggplant pizza I have had in a long time! They also have delicious homemade Jamaican Patties! Add pepperoni inside and you WILL NOT be disappointed! Due to the wonderful customer service, food, and affordable prices, this will be the only pizza place I will be ordering from, from now on. I highly recommend this pizza place!
My regular pizza place temp closed so I looked at local reviews, chose Mama Lucia's. Someone mentioned the Sicilian Supreme, so I called it in. Owner is a nice guy, easy to talk to. Look at this beautiful pizza, I swear it weighs about 5 pounds - just like another reviewer said.
Just ate a slice, outta this world. They sautéed the toppings before putting it in the oven👌 crust cooked perfectly👌 generous meat & cheese 👌 sauce just right 👌 there's serious flavor going on here.
First time there, telling you I'm impressed.
...editing this review 2 days later, still eating that pizza. When they pan-fried the toppings I think they put in something, some extra flavor. What Tumeric? I don't know. But this is the best pizza of my life.
All i can say is scrumptious,My wife and i both thought about our honeymoon in Taiwan in 1987 after tasting how amazing this slice was.Hopefully i can get my grandson clayton to try some too haha that boy don’t like nothing !!!
Best Pizza i've had in the whole Suffolk County!
Don't sleep on them!
And the 2 slices deal is a giveaway at this point!
Love their pizza ..onuo. mushrooms and sausage..nom nom nom. Delicious.and a heapliad of toppings.cannolis are crisp on the outside.. house salad is very colorful ..
Wow, was in the mood for a meatball parm hero..and thats exactly what i got. Very good,
Yes total neighborhood pizza joint
Good pizza, nice people fast
Feels like a long island joint, good hero's, chicken cullet and Meetball were the best 2
Pizza by the slice was also good nice bread and sauce combo
They treated me well when I was there
I didn't see beer
Sane with wine but I could be wrong
No bar
I will go back
Reminded of this place because it popped up in my Facebook memories. It’s been 12 years since my parents and I went searching for NY pizza and the lasagna pizza is still the best pizza I have ever had. Been trying to duplicate it ever since. If I ever make it up that way again, I hope this place is still serving up such deliciousness.
The best pasta ever. The prices are very reasonable the service is always friendly it's very clean. I can't emphasize how great the food is here. My favorite is their Penne Ala vodka. Cooked to perfection always creamy. Please do yourself a favor and try this great little pizza place. I live in Farmingdale and will drive to Huntington because it's worth the trip
The pizza that we ordered was really delicious. I prefer a thinner crust, but with this pizza, the 1/4 inch crust is very nice.
The sticker price was a shocker as I have never paid $30 for a pizza. Once we got it home and found it was stacked with the toppings, it eased the pain somewhat. One slice is more than enough for me, 2 for my son.
Good pizza ,great tasting sauce
Joe is the best so is his wife good people food is good to
Really great atmosphere. Typical neighborhood pizzeria with consistant, delicious food. The owner Joe is a really cool guy who will remember your name and order after your first visit. Very happy with my experiences here.
Love the food here! The owner is always there and very nice as well! Always has a smile on his face! The prices are reasonable and the food is delicious!
Friendly spot, great tasting pizza, good prices. Garlic knots are perfectly soft and covered in garlic; the way they should be!
I've been going to this place for over 20 years. Their quality of food is what I compare all pizzerias to be because they've always been amazing. The people there have always been great as well, always leave with a smile.
When I worked in Huntington years ago, This was a frequent lunch spot.
Not sure its still on the menu, but this time of year the pasta fusilli soup was such a favorite! I may have to stop in and inquire!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes