Reviews Buttercooky Bakery

5
Forum Shah
+5
Service: Quick and friendly. They ran out of happy birthday signs and the person who helped us ended up writing it on a separate chocolate square at no extra cost and we really appreciated that. Price: The pastries and cakes are all very reasonably priced. Inside: It's a pretty informal bakery. It's clean and they have a spacious seating area. Cakes/Pastries: WOW! I was really really impressed with the desserts at this bakery. We got the individual Oreo cheesecake and it was perfect. Not overly sweet or too few Oreo pieces. It also had a nice chocolate glaze on top but that glaze didn't overpower the cheesecake. The crust was also perfect, slightly crumbly and didn't taste too buttery. We also got the chocolate cappuccino pastries for our family. The tart was perfectly soft and crispy and the the flavors of cappuccino and chocolate melded perfectly, neither was too overpowering. We didn't get a big cake but the ones we saw on display looked delicious and were very beautifully decorated. My husband isn't a big sweets person but even he was very impressed with this bakery. Overall, I would highly recommend this bakery. Instagram: @TheShahLALand
5
Sandra A
+5
Always loved the butter cooky in floral park now they've opened one in Huntington... Lucky us. The desserts are fabulous... Especially love the miniture cakes which let you sample them bf ordering larger size... However I don't think you can go wrong with any of them. My personal favourite is the fruit filled cake. Moist white cake with layers of custard and filled with fresh fruit topped with fresh whipped cream icing. Now the bakery opened the cafe where you can order breakfast or lunch items. I've had both... The panini's are awesome as well as the breakfast sandwiches. I was pleasantly surprised with freshly made ingredients... Nothing frozen or microwaved. May have been the freshest ommelette I've ever had. Hesitated to write a review bc I don't want to wait to get in if the word gets out. Update... Been back several times and everything is fabulous... May be best breakfast/lunch option in Huntington.
5
Paul Vetrano
+5
Deliciousness! Nice staff. Clean. Beautiful displays. Great renovations to this awesome and wonderful bakery. I host an annual Oktoberfest and I always make sure that I stop here for the fantastic desserts. Their Apple Strudel, Apple Turnover, Boston Cream Doughnuts and Jelly Doughnuts are the best around. Love this place!
5
Jennifer
+5
Exceptional! The last cake I ordered was above and beyond! The cake was so soft, the fruit was so fresh! It definitely exceeded my expectations.
4
Paul Estridge
+4
I’ve only been there twice and I have not been disappointed at all. Their pastries and cheese cake are absolutely devine! They’re a bit pricey but it’s well worth it and I will definitely be going there again.
5
SEAN MURRAY
+5
This is what you think of when you think of a bakery. The ladies were very knowledgeable and the selection was very good from cakes to pastries. The pricing was very reasonable. I ordered an assortment of cookies and pastries and my customer couldn’t stop talking about how great everything tasted. Great bakeries are hard to find and if we don’t support them they will all go away.
5
Elizabeth Engrassia
+5
Amazing pastries/baked goods and even better customer service! We got an assortment of cookies and cakes, and I was impressed with all of it! The cookies are huge and the pastries are fresh. Francesco, the owner, is an absolute gem - he is great with customers and makes sure you are satisfied with everything. If you are in the Huntington area and looking for something sweet, definitely stop here! It gets my full recommendation.
5
Cory Avila
+5
Yummy. Stopped in for a snack and a coffee to get out of the rain for a few minutes. Great selection of baked goods. The doughnut I had was great as well as the coffee.
5
Random Things
+5
The bakery was clean, and they had a variety of cakes to choose from. The price was excellent to. The staff was fast and courteous as well. Would definitely come back here again.
5
Brandon Spencer
+5
I purchased a 1/2 sheet red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. The cake was beautiful and well packaged and EVERYONE loved the cake
4
CCG G
+4
Great, vast selection of pastries and cakes. their crullers, cinnamon pecan pastries, and eclairs are fantastic. It can get extremely busy sometimes.
4
Bill M
+4
Nice lunch spot. Food was good. Help was a little slow and they made the order wrong but it was still good.
4
Gerry K
+4
Nice place. Huge variety of sweets, but a bit pricey.
4
Amanda Fischer
+4
Buttercooky made an amazingly beautiful and delicious cake. We were so happy with the results. Most of the times I called about my order staff seemed a bit confused, but Paula was wonderful to communicate with!
Clicca per espandere