I’ve read great reviews hence was curious to come. I liked the vibe, pretty relaxed. Great drinks and wine menu. We ordered Burrata, Beets Salad and Filet Mignon. Salads were ok and filet mignon was not very tasty. Service was great. We had to come back to taste the pastas and pizza that perhaps is a better option here.
Me and my fiancé just had our engagement party here & I will say it was amazing ! They are amazing, our families love the food (we have serious picky eaters) & the service was great !! I wish I remembered our waitresses name she was awesome considering she was handling 14 people ! Will the night before was helping us so much and he’s so polite and a helpful man ! Joe the manager is always doing awesome & loved everything ! The prices were beyond reasonable & definitely would go to them again for another party ! My fiancés family so far had 2 parties with them ! I highly recommend coming here and having parties here ! Look how cute it was when they designed our menu🫶🏼 Thank you to ALL the staff who took care of all of us on Sunday, we loved it !
Recently sold to one of the partners, Joe. Had a delicious meal and noticed it was much better than before. Came to pay I had a gift card which he was kind enough to come over and say that it was under a different name since it was sold but he was going to honor it. Smart businessman the place has definitely improved under his ownership wish him the best of luck
We just had our daughter’s wedding shower at Primo Piatto and could not be happier. All of our guests raved about the wonderful staff and fantastic food. The staff was polite and very attentive to everyone there. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone having an event or if you just want to go out for a meal. Great atmosphere also.
Very tasty , dont be afraid to ask for extra sauce on any slices . must be a good chef, right ? A slow afternoon for them and a lot of traffic , plus an inviting, charming ,,,,can I say it ? Ambiance, inside and out. Glad I ducked out of traffic. What a beautiful fall day on 25 A. And what a best kept secret for the rest of us silly commuters. Wed. 10/12/22.
I had stopped by for a meeting but let me tell you the owner and his family are amazing people and when I was ready to eat I was blown away how good the food was. I live in the city and I expect my Italian food to be good but this restaurant really surpasses my expectations and for my birthday I want to have my dinner there. Their menu, wines and service spoiled me rotten. There prices are affordable and the restaurant has such a beautiful interior and exteriors. It’s like they brought Little Italy to Long Island!!!
Got here at 3 pm today for Happy Hour with my wife and another couple. $3 bottled beers including Peroni. Personal pizzas were great and the service was outstanding. Waiter was attentive and very friendly. We will be back for certain.
We had a fundraiser here last night.
The owner John and his staff were amazing and incredibly attentive, and only outdone by the food!! The pizza, the pasta, the chicken parm sliders…..all excellent.
And last week we ordered a few pies from here for Poker Night, and the Buffalo Chicken pie was amazing!!!
Whether looking for an Italian night out, or just a few slices, you need to try Primo Piatto!!!
My family and I enjoyed a wonderful dinner experience here. Great staff, the food was top notch. Hats off and best wishes to the new owners; we could use a high quality Italian restaurant here. Keep up the good work.
An Italian restaurant at it's finest in Huntington, NY!
Beautifully decorated, relaxed atmosphere, and when the weather's nice the tables extend outside in front. The menu is simple authentic Italian with a modern touch. Everything tastes like it was just made for you; each serving is more than you can eat at once. In particular try the fried zucchini appetizer!
The waitress was always there when you needed her, and the manager, Zach, went around checking with every table to make sure all was on point.
Advise reservations, especially on weekends. It gets busy.
This is a beautiful little Italian restaurant. Great atmosphere. Hard working staff. And an attentive owner. I highly recommend this establishment for a date night or just a night out with family.
Enjoyed Saturday I dinner there. The food was very good. I did have music which was nice. My husband had the chicken Marsala said it was very good I had chicken parmesan chicken was cooked just right. Will be back soon
Ordered lunch a few minutes after they opened, orders were ready in a very reasonable amount of time. Fried zucchini and mozz were great. Penne alla Vodka w grilled chicken was 2/5. Chicken was good, pasta was cooked well, sauce was the downfall. Maybe because it was still early.
Quality, cleanliness, polite wait staff, and most of all a vast and delicious menu to choose from.
We visited from out of state and we're pleasantly surprised!
Delicious home-made old style Italian comfort foods with a marinara sauce reminiscent of nana's Sunday best!
Very friendly and quick service with indoor and outdoor seating overlooking E. Main St.
Plenty of off-street parking, great menu and a nice tasty slice of pretty much anything you like.
We were there for our friend's bridal shower. It was a beautiful event and the food was excellent. There is an outdoor patio where we sat and it has a large parking lot.
The food here is uniformly and ridiculously good. The caesar and beet salads, ALL of the pizzas, and the ravioli are my favorites. Best Italian in town.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes