Class act establishment! Great food and great service! Thank you!
This spot gets 5 stars from me simply because of the two guys that work the kitchen. My initial interaction with the cashier hit a snag, but the food was good and the guy from Honduras(or might have been Venezuelan. I can’t remember) in the back provided a very high level of customer service. Super polite, attentive and friendly!! He made the experience a 5 star experience. Now to the food…the food was great! Had a pepperoni personal pizza, a cheese personal pizza, and wings. The sign says something about the cheese pizza being the best, oh it really is 👍🏽. The wings and sauce were perfect. We will be back soon.
![4]( "Recensione")
You’re reading this because you’re asking yourself exactly how New York is Johnny’s Real New York Pizza.
Truthfully, it’s pizza. How can you possibly mess that up? It’s got quite an extensive menu but I came here to try a couple slices out so I ordered one pepperoni and one pepperoni with mushrooms added on. Each slice was $3.75 plus the extra $1 charge for the mushrooms. Like others have stated, I was a bit disappointed that they just had pizzas laying out under a heat lamp instead of putting it back in the oven for it to be nice and crispy again.
However, since I did order one of them with mushrooms they put that in the oven to heat up and it came out perfectly. I consider a good NY slice to be big, toasty, foldable, and cheesy. These slices definitely hit the mark so I’m giving them a good rating simply because of that.
Is it cheaper than most other locations? No, but you’re supporting a local business and not a commercial chain. I think it’s actually family owned and truthfully if they just reheated the pizzas they’d probably get better ratings.
The pizza is promising and worth giving a first chance!
My friends and I ordered a few things and everything tasted soo good! We definitely will be returning.
I always have my doubts when I see places labeled as NY pizza. I lived in Manhattan and Brooklyn growing up, the Mecca of real pizza. This might just be the finest version of pizza I've had in CA. This truly was an excellent example of NY pizza. The crust was thin and crisp. The sauce was just enough. The cheese was perfect. I had pepperoni on one half, hand made Italian sliced meatball on the other. Garlic knots were bite sized for more flavor for the surface area. Garlic fries were amazing with marinara sauce on the side. I really couldn't have been more impressed with this unassuming and dare I say sterile looking shop. Bravo. Will return Everytime I'm in the area.
This is my absolute favorite pizza spot in all of Orange County! Their happy hour is phenomenal. You can get a large mug of Modelo for $3.50 and all slices are under $3! The staff are beyond friendly and will remember your order almost every time. It has become an absolute pleasure to become a regular here! The wings and Johnny Fries are also a great feature.
We ordered the clutch pizza and it was one of the best pizzas we have ever had! I can’t wait to try some of the other recommendations they gave us.
Very good pizza. The non cheese/pepperoni options are more expensive then you want but worth the price from time to time
If you're looking for an amazing NY style pizza this place is for sure it!! New to the area and this was the first place I tried and I'm so glad I did!! You won't be disappointed!!
Very hot and fresh. Cooked perfectly. Awesome pizza. I am from New York and it is really crunchy, fresh and all round delicious. My new go to. Thank you guys!
Great House Salad but the lettuce could be fresher. Great cheese and pepperoni slices. Pizza crust is tasty. They charge extra for credit cards.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes