Sluurpy
Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Key Lime Pie in Islamorada

There are 6 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Bayside Gourmet
93/100 (3116 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Contemporary
American
Pizza
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Meat Lovers Pizza
Shrimp
Grouper Sandwich
Portobello Mushroom
Cakes
The Works Pizza
Lobster Bisque Soup
Lobster
Burrito
Saltimbocca Pizza
Pancakes
Bruschette
Pesto
Omelette
Bread Pudding
Fish
Cheesesteak
Key Lime Pie
Lasagna
Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta
Greek salad
Lasagne
Meatball Appetizer
Salad
Carbonara
Grouper Reuben Sandwich
Tuna
Tortellini
Shrimp Francese
Tortelloni
Spicy Fish Taco
Caprese Salad
Sandwiches
Saltimbocca
A Real Philly Cheesesteak
Tapas
Hawaiian Pizza
Burger
Key lime pie
Blackened Grouper & Fresh Pico Omelet
Fish Taco
Tacos
Antipasto Salad
Philly Cheesesteak
Veggie Pizza
Cuban Sandwich
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Okay... This might take a second.. from all the places we've visited in the upper keys and lower to be honest, this one had the audacity to feed us..."
Thomas Hens
"Stopped at this gem on our way to our vacation site after traveling all day. Little bit of a wait if we wanted to dine in or immediate seating if we..."
Michelle Moua
"This is a very cool place. Walk in and you see a bunch of retro arcade games and a very warm atmosphere. I was by myself and ordered the bruschetta..."
Brian Gordon
"Visiting in town and went and had beers and cocktails at a local place and decided to stop here for some food. Everything in these places here are..."
jody smith
"We got a large size works pizza, and it's enough for at least three probably four adults. Very homemade ingredients, unique homemade tasting sausage,..."
Fisherman Me
"Always love coming here. I've tried tons of their dishes and I have yet to find soenthing that I didn't like. Their pasta dish portions are..."
Cohean Levi's
"This place was the best place we have eaten while on vacation. The food is amazing!! The fun little outside courtyard is a great place to share a..."
Tony&Kami Venditte
"We were tired of cooking so we read the reviews and decided to place a take out order for pizza and the key lime pie. The pizza was very good. We..."
Annette R
"Came in from out of town and went here because of the great reviews, it did not disappoint. Loved the atmosphere, really great vibe, very kind..."
Kati Aumack
"Listen, i have travelled around the world with my family and I can tell you that this place does it right for a family pizza night. The pizza is..."
Nick Steers
Morada Bay
91/100 (5966 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Caribbean
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Caribbean
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pesto
Big Boy BBQ Beach Burger
Bahamian Conch Fritters
Crab Cake
Shrimp
Fish
Key West Pink Shrimp Scampi
Lobster Roll
Morada Caesar Salad
Tapas
Fish Taco
Lobster
Piña colada
Cocktail
Tacos
Peppers
Tuna tataki
Ribs
Key Lime Pie
Pasta
Fish Sandwich
Lobster Sliders
Salad
Curry
Whole Fried Snapper
Thai Shrimp Tacos
Crab
Tostones with Guacamole
Calamari
Torte
Morada Bay Margarita
Mussels
Key lime pie
Fish and Chips Morada Style
Tuna
Sandwiches
Ceviche
Thai Key West Tacos
Calamares
Salmon
Burger
Cakes
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Caribbean
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Seating
Waterfront
Table Service
Beach
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Late Night
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Went here with a local friend who said we needed to go here because of the amazing sunset on the private beach. and boy, it delivered! It might be a..."
BJORN VAN DEN BREMT
"We stopped for lunch on a beautiful sunny day. The weather was perfect and we got the best table they have right next to the water. Paula was our..."
key lime
"A beautiful property right on the water. Lots of seating outside under umbrella. The staff was wonderful. The food looked/sounded promissing but..."
Stephanie Findlay
"We stopped here for a drink and a driving break. Had a refreshing lemonade and a slice of key lime pie. A little sugary but not a bad slice for a bit..."
Jo Patman
"Nice place to go and enjoy a drink/snack together with a view. We popped in at the beach cafe on our way back to Miami from Key West and felt very..."
Frida Nguyen
"A Culinary Gem by the Sea! 🌊 I had the pleasure of dining at Morada Bay Café during my trip to Islamorada in the Florida Keys. This restaurant..."
Clement Amato
"There are not enough good words to describe this place. The food, service and amazing location...heavenly!! I had the watermelon salad with grilled..."
Julie wingate
"There is no better place to enjoy the most beautiful sunset while tasting delicious food in an unmistakable key ambiance where nature and spirits..."
Daniel Ocampo
"Food was pretty good here. The fried fish was more breading than fish which was a disappointment. Overall, good local place to eat. You are paying..."
Zerbe Adventures
"Been here a few times and it’s been good generally! The sunsets here are amazing and the full moon parties are great!! There is live entertainment..."
Ron Tiah
Chef Michael's
87/100 (2878 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Late Night
Triple Tail in Adriatic Sauce
lobster tail
French Toast
Conch & Rock Shrimp Fritters
Lobster
Toasts
Lobster- Juliette with Shrimp and Scallops
Pasta
Escargot
Shrimp and Lobster Ceviche
Salad
Cheesecakes
Catch of the Day Fried Lion Fish
Carrot Cake
Seared Tuna Tatiki
Crab
Wedge Salad
Key lime pie
Scallops
Fresh Veggies
Ceviche
Duck
Mahi Mahi
Tempura
Tuna
Shrimp Ceviche
Crawfish
French Toast
Filet Mignon
Catfish
Bread Pudding
Lamb
Chowder
Key Lime Pie
Pesto
Cheesecake
Conch Chowder
Fish
Filet Mignon
Swordfish
Tile Fish
Shrimp
Lamb Shank
Lion Fish App
Prime rib
Sit down
Seafood
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Live Music
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Always a pleasure eating at Chef Michael's , food is flavorful and filling and customer service is on point feel at home eating there. Went yesterday..."
Keisha Sanchez
"Best place north of Marathon in the Keys. Must call and get reservation but it's OFF THE CHAIN!! #MustStopAndEat ..."
Warren Sapp
"HI,I was visiting my Aunt and Uncle in Key Largo, and they took me to Chef Michael's for my birthday brunch. Elena was our server, and I was so..."
Kori Layla
"A must stop for steak or seafood. Great service, great wine, fantastic food. Best in the keys that we have ever had. David the bartender is funny..."
Joe
"Delicious! The menu was simple with plenty of vegetarian & seafood options. Chef handpicks his fish daily, a freshness we savored in our appetizers..."
FrenchieKW
"Anyone who doesn't like this place is impossible to please. You're in the keys. This was by far the best meal we had. The portions are huge! Share...."
Memphis235
"Three of us had dinner there last night and it was wonderful. Knowledgable friendly and helpful staff. Offered great suggestions. The sautéed..."
Chet
"It was a great experience. We ate inside. The outside terrace is beautiful, though. Very clean. Exceptional service. And the food surpassed our..."
Lili
"Two nights of heaven!. Thanks to Mary, Chef Michael and the incredible staff at this exquisite restaurant. Our group loved the steaks and hogfish...."
Georgiakb
"Mike's is good. The wait staff is weak and the wine list is poor. The food, however , is surprisingly good. The MUZAK is too loud. Thi9s is a good..."
J Rowland
"Excellent food and professional service in a casual but elegant surroundings. No liquor license yet but solid wine list. Well worth..."
Kim Schmidt
"Father's Day 2012. Everything from the wine, appetizers and food were awesome!! We will definitely be back and..."
Dana McMillin Williams
"WOW ! Highly recommend this restaurant. Great food and superb service, Food is worth the cost . I will certainly return. Hog fish and scallops were..."
Traveling Man
"Was just there celebrating our five year wedding anniversary and had the most amazing meal! The service, food, and dessert were all exceptional -..."
sarah app
"Best restaurant in Islamorada, if your looking for a fancy date night or a place for celebration this is your spot! Incredible fish to choose from &..."
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
"Amazing restaurant! Staff, food, atmosphere, absolutely everything. My new spot when I'm in the keys. Definitely coming..."
Nicky P.
"Fantastic all the way around. The bar tender is a doll. She was so patient and knowledgeable about the food and drink. We decided to eat at the bar..."
Kimberly Martin
"Our favorite place to splurge in the keys. We got the shrimp & conch fritter appetizer, seafood pasta, hogfish Juliette, and key lime pie. We’d..."
Nicole Fernandez
"BEST RESTAURANT IN ISLAMARODA!!! Everything we had was super delicious!!! Service is excellent!!! Great ambience!!! Would definitely come back again..."
Vera J
"Have had Chef Michael’s on the list for several years after reading lots of good things on a Boat Owner’s Fishing Forum. Also researched and saw..."
Janeandmel
"Outstanding meal, great atmosphere, very friendly and courteous staff. Went for dinner, was able to get a reservation the same day, but not much..."
Bill RB
"The food is amazing! We had the shrimp and lobster ceviche, and escargot for appetizers. For main course fried lion fish and the fish trilogy...."
Belkys Carrillo
"The best meal I had in Islamorada and it's not even close. There were some people who commented expressing frustration about needing a reservation...."
David Junkins
Ziggie & Mad Dog's
83/100 (2842 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Beef
Escargot
Fish of the Day
Key lime pie
Lobster
Espresso Martini
Pesto
Wedge Salad
Fish
Pasta
Shrimp Cocktail
Pork
Salad
Creamed Spinach
Ribeye steak
Mac and cheese
Burrata Salad
Red wine
Key Lime Pie
Crab
Mac and Cheese
Porterhouse Steak
Scallops
Phyllo Crusted Escargot
Duck
Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Burger
Tuna
Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Filet Mignon
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Seafood
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Fine Dining
"One of the best steakhouses I have ever been to in my life. I got the Delmonico steak which was so flavorful and tender. The garlic butter that they..."
Alex
"Do not let the unassuming exterior deceive you - Ziggy and Mad Dog's is a 4-star, high-end steak-house, but without the oppressively-pretentious..."
Bardakjy
"Fine dining. Late dinner so we skipped appetizers. Dinners were great. The libations from the bar were citified! My husband asked for an unusual..."
Raquel
"When we walked in the door, we were pleasantly surprised! What a great little place, definitely a favorite. Food is great, service even better. Worth..."
Keyz Girl
"The service was unbelievable ask for Jennifer to wait on..."
Heidi Mangold
"The filet was cooked perfectly and the pistachio creamed spinach is amazing! Also great friendly..."
Tracy Staiger
"The Best in the Keys. As a "local" I can attest to the consistent quality of this restaurant. We love it and dine there often. John is wonderful and..."
Local Girl
"The best steak place in the mid-upper Keys. Top flight. Prices are in line with any top steak houses in..."
Bill Hempel
"We rated it as liked it, but be aware--the food is good but not outstanding and prices are outrageous. It's all a la carte, even for sauces. On the..."
Food Lover
"Exceptional. This place is a wonder. It's the best service in the keys. A quaint little place that is formal but friendly. We did spend quite a bit..."
Citychef1
"Great food and service! Price was a little steep. One of the best in the..."
GRJ
"Excellent food. Great waittress. A bit pricey. The hostess was snooty. Still, one if the best in the upper..."
Mad Viking
"BEST Yet!. Went to Ziggy's for dinner again, as we had tried it before and though it was good, had always liked Braza Lena better....not any more!..."
TCGRAY
"Can you Say Buckhead Beef?. After you ask all the local's on the island where to eat, you will be sure to have several recommendations to try out..."
Florida Escape Artist
"Celebrated anniversary here-- great choice! Exquisite food seasoned and cooked to culinary perfection. Wonderful ambience, superb staff. Worth the..."
Mary
"The food is amazing!!! Very cozy....the staff is always on their feet. It is a good place to..."
Isotta
"Special guests and occasions. The best steaks in town... and the seafood's great too! Best is the atmosphere, staff and John... the guy really knows..."
Mary Griffin
"We visited the restaurant on the last evening of our vacation in the US… and it was the best choice ever. I love to eat and I can say : this meal..."
Pizzacat
"The food was outstanding and our server, Leslie was top notch. From the very beginning of our meal to the end, it was perfect. I was very pleasantly..."
Grace Hussey
"Very intimate place. The entrées and sides were amazing and cooked to perfection. The dessert (creme Brulee) was OK. I think I would try a different..."
Nestor VINAS
"What a hidden gem. From the street, it looks bad. However, from the moment you walk into the restaurant, wow. They don't do a lot of steak in the..."
daniel packard
"Loved it! Great food. Great staff. Great indoor dining area. Great music. Roadside curb appeal made this place "not" our first choice. However, it..."
Troy Wilcox
"Our, experience was fantastic ! We had the best service . Sheri was absolutely amazing and we had the best experience. Joey Dee Thank you for..."
Jessica Cook
"We stumbled upon this place last year and fell in love, I kept thinking about their lobster Mac and cheese !! Needless to say, the food is amazing..."
Andrea Carey
"passed this place for years. we have had our favorite go to places and never got past them. this trip all were closed so we decided to try ziggie and..."
dana taylor
"Really surprised. White table cloth restaurant in the Keys. Excellent food and service. Super catch of day was snapper almandine with garlic onion..."
Robert Lawrence
"Our first time to Islamorada so picking places to eat was taking chances. Whether it's goods or services, I tend to depend on reviews. After..."
Aaron Waner
"Absolutely scrumptious. The key lime pie was whipped perfection! lobster Mac and cheese and escargot were things I've never had before and it was..."
Tracy Bier
"One of our favorite spots in town. Steak cannot be beat, as well as the amazing a la carte sides. Don’t leave without checking out the Pistachio..."
Joe Bell
"The ambience was nice inside and waiters were excellent. We had scallops and steak both delicious. The sides we had were sweet potatoes and..."
cathy webber
"Our friends recommended Ziggie & Mag Dog's and joined us along with another couple. We shared 3 12 Oz filet mignons between each couple, salads,..."
Ted from Florida
"Would actually be a 4 1/2 star place( I hardly if ever do a 5 so this is super for me!!!) This is a wonderful place. Unobtrusive in outside looks,..."
Susan Collier
"The service here was great. The waitress took our drink order while giving us enough time to look over the menu. The appetizers came out which were..."
Joe Acavino
"We loved it here!! Super friendly staff. The food and drinks were amazing!! I highly recommend a nice relaxing dinner here!!! Great for special..."
Jeep Cherokee
"The best steak in the keys ! Everything from the lobster bisque to the appetizers to the service, all of it was fantastic. Make sure you make..."
CS
Hog Heaven Sports Bar & Grill
82/100 (5022 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Barbecue
American
Seafood
Pub
Barbecue
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Chowder
Bloody Mary
Mangrove Mai Tai
Tapas
Shrimp Tacos
Fish Taco
Bud Light
Shrimp
Tacos
Fish Fillet
Ribs
Hog Burger
Fish Sandwich
Hamburger
Nachos
Taco
Pasta
Key Lime Pie
Salad
Key lime pie
Clam Chowder
Wings
Fish
Pig Wings
Mac and cheese
Pork
Mahi Tacos
Pork Belly
Smoked Fish Dip
Crab
corona
Key Lime Colada
Calamari
Burger
Coleslaw
Pig Candy
Calamares
Hamburgers
Sit down
Barbecue
Seafood
Pub
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Waterfront
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Mid-range
"Love this place and we always stop here either going to the key west or back from. Meredith was our awesome bartender out on the deck bar and helped..."
Jim DeGennaro
"I absolutely loved this place. I'm a BBQ snob, and this was easily in my all-time top 5 BBQ places. I went ahead and ordered the Ultimate Hog..."
living_maas_life
"You have to stop in, it's set back off US 1 cost to the water but this is a great place. Atmosphere is awesome and the staff were great. Shane the..."
P Murphy
"The food here was good. We had a few of the appetizers like the wings and pork shanks. They were tasty and they have a full bar. We enjoyed our..."
Domingo Silvas
"Such a good time!!! Definitely the best spot we’ve been to in Islamorada, and we’ve hit most of them. Food was fantastic, the Brisket Burger was..."
Sean Stuart
"Fun place to go for dinner, drinks and keeping up in the sports of the day. Service was fast and professional. Our highlight was taking our drinks..."
Christopher Walsh
"We had a good time at Hog Heaven. The place is great! We chose to sit outside on the dock. We had the best view of the sand bar. The food was..."
Cheryl Bono
"Merideth served me both times I stopped in to eat lunch, the service was Awesome and spot on. The corn bread and fried shrimp were to die for!! Will..."
Richard Moore
"It’s nice you can park you boat to eat ! Staff was friendly. Food was..."
Lo Ja
"If you're looking for some nightlife and a pretty chill but upbeat place, this will be your best bet. They have a variety of music to a live band...."
Daniel Patterson
Reelcatch Restaurant
80/100 (92 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
American
Dinner
Drinks
Breakfast
Belgian Waffle
Ceviche de camaron
Oceanside Breakfast
Zucchini Fries
Oysters on the Half Shell
Cauliflower Bites
Breakfast Panini
Black & Blue Burger
Tropical Ceviche
Key Lime Pie
Mahi Tacos
Frito Misto Calamari
Whole Fish Branzino
Burger
Calamari Rings with Sweet Peppers
Fish Monger Burger
Florida Lobster Bites
Blackened Lobster Tacos
Coconut Shrimp
Chicken Quesadilla
Black N Blue Burger No Bun
Bar
Pub
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Drinks
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"Super amazing hotel bar and restaurant! Burgers were good, service was awesome and the beach was..."
Barb Martin
"Outstanding service, very friendly employees, not a single mistake on the orders, prompt attention to every need or request, we are a small local..."
Nelson delgado
"Visited just after Memorial Day during a trip through the Keys and while we did not stay at the resort, it was looking for lodging establishments..."
Shereen De Jesus
"Outstanding! Food, service and the hotel manager who was helping clear tables. I LOVE it when there is a stellar hotel team in..."
Shellie Smith
"THE BEST BURGER IN TOWN!!!! THE BEST COFFEE IN TOWN!!! I'm picky when it comes to coffee. So I was SUPER hesitant when I first ordered a caramel iced..."
Karie Dawley
"Our breakfast was amazing..."
Carolina Gonzalez
"We stayed at this hotel called Amara Cay. The restaurant is located on site. The service is excellent and the hotel is awesome. I highly recommend..."
Glen Tallman
"Bartenders are awesome as is the food and scenery. Recommended..."
Chuck Wiggy
"Delicious Food! Gunna go for a Swim..."
scott roman
"Pretty good food in Amara Cay Resort not a huge selection but still good, if you don't feel like going out. Still have views of the ocean and..."
WA HA
"Why haven't you been here? Because it is Islamorada's Best Kept Secret. Best appetizers. Best cocktails. Best live..."
Liz H
"What a nice surprise. We needed a quick lunch stop driving home from key west. Food was great atmosphere great (we ate outside) hotel impressed us we..."
Chip DiComo
"Very gpod burger joint. Fast, delicious, reasonable prices, and good portions. Variety fpr different diets. My husband eats meat, I don't, and we..."
Saribel Ayala
"Reasonable prices and wonderful outdoor atmosphere. The lobster and fish tacos are both..."
Rob Smura
"One of the best burgers I've had in years and the scenery is outstanding the bartender was very..."
Richard Donati
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use