Stopped in while on vacation had a pepperoni and green pepper pizza garlic parm wing and pizza and fires for the kids. Everyone thought the pizza was delicious wings were delicious. Highly recommend if your in the finger lakes area.
For me this is the only go to place for pizza. I have been going there since high school. Never had a problem with service. I'm there usually once a week. If your in town and would like great pizza and service, this is the place to go.
Being gluten free, there aren’t many options for pizza in Ithaca, but this is by far the best. It’s by far the best pizza I’ve had in the country.
They delivered to my mother in a nursing home for her birthday they won't do anything special with the toppings but she was happy and they were quick
Got just a regular pie both times and it was always hot and fresh! I really like their sauce compared to other places in town.
Has a comfortable family business feel. Our server was very nice and attentive and the food was great. Wings were absolutely amazing.
I love this place! Their pizza is one of favorites around. The employees are some of the nicest I've encountered anywhere. They quickly learned what my "usual" is and get it made super fast! :)
Pizza was very good, a bit under cooked but good. Staff very friendly. Clean.
Amazing food and service. I didn’t think I was that hungry but I demolished that lasagna all the same!
Very good food. Portions are great. Fast and delicious. Nice little spot from out of town er 👌
They are very nice people there. Good service and good food.
We ordered pizza and salad for carry out. The salad was fresh. The pizza was super tasty, although the crust was a little soggy In the middle.
Dined in with family, friendly service and pizza was delicious. Daughter did say it was her favorite pizza!
Friendly service and I mean A++. The food was great and I wouldn't hesitate to come back here. Picky kids loved it.
Amazing service. We were looking for a late lunch and found this gem. The portions were huge and they happily adjusted some options for us. And the lasagna was incredible.
Excellent, excellent NY pizza, just the way I remember it! Good job Joe!!
Was in Ithaca for a family event, went searching for palatable pizza and on the 5th try, found Sal's. GREAT place! Tried a couple of slices and they were better than 99.9 percent of CT pizza and would hold their own in the Bronx. Circled around after wife also approved the pizza and got a chresest
Got to go pizza. Solids pie. Crust cooked great a long with a great tasting sauce. Great service.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes