Sluurpy
Reset

There are 22 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Ithaca

There are 22 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pizza Aroma
88/100 (879 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The food is well prepared, always fresh, always clean. The pizza and side dishes are amazing! You are always greeted with a smile! The family is..."
Lisa Luciano
"The BEST choices of any Pizza and other meals. I Love my Gluten free, flat Bread vegi pizza..."
Cj Iannuzzi
"It was my first time there. The guy working was very nice and helpful! I LOVE garlic. So much that I have a tattoo of garlic, and the garlic pizza..."
Stephanie Matthews
"Their pizza was Amazing! The service was great! Highly..."
Shannon Barnhart Ruhl
"These guys have the best Vegan Gluten Free pizza in..."
José Luis Ferrer III
"Nice little pizza joint, accommodating and polite. Cheese fell off the pizza a lot so not sure if that’s normal, it was a very messy pizza but good..."
Allyse Tanovitz
"As expected, Pizza Aroma’s reopening is a blessing to the pizza-eaters of Ithaca! I have loved their delicious black bean pizza since I was 10..."
Gwenivere Harrington
"This is, in my opinion, the best pizza in Ithaca. The owners are super friendly and honest people. I have never had a bad experience ordering..."
MIlo Coyote
"Pizza Aroma has some of the best pizza I have enjoyed in my life. He brilliantly combines various flavors, pays attention to each creation, and is..."
Dan Jossen
"This place knows pizza! No skimping on ingredients! Full of flavor. Crust was not too thin, not too thick... just right...crisp outside, chewy..."
madonna stallmann
"First time trying, and I can see why it's a local favorite. I'm so glad they're back! Ordered a vege GF pizza, and it was stacked, perfectly crisp..."
Amy Won
"Very handicapped accessible! Nice accessible bathroom! Parking close to entrance and wide..."
Sheherazahde
"I'm so glad they have re-opened, today my black bean pizza was even better than I remembered! Thank you Pizza Aroma, I hope things are going..."
Kerry Demarest
"Their Pizza is fantastic. Good size salads. First rate customer service. Fresh Basil really makes it extra..."
Scott Hawley
"We stopped for a quick lunch after our day of hiking . The Pizza and the Pupusas(Traditional Salvadorian Stuffed Corn Tortillas)were amazing. The..."
Yanit Pineiro
"Mama mia, Pizz....latin food! Wow - was I impressed with my lunch at Pizza Aroma. Sure, I've had the pizza before, but I ordered the Papusas today..."
Zachary Drucker
"Excellent New York style pizza with some great slice options. Had a buffalo chicken finger slice and also a slice with tortellini. The slice of..."
Mike Graz
"The best pizza I ever ate. Just..."
Hilel Mosenzon
"Visiting Ithaca - I returned to Pizza Aroma and expectations met yet again! I remember when the place opened 22 years ago- toppings always fresh and..."
Bonnie R. Rabin
"Excellent Pizza every time! Fresh basil n garlic our favorite! Been coming here for years each time we visit Ithaca. No worries the man behind the..."
D K
"The crust on this pizza is crispy and delicious flavors. I would recommend going..."
Natalie Cross
"The service was wonderful. The food was typical pizza place. I would eat here again if I came back to the area in the..."
Diana Andrews
Ned's Pizza Ny
86/100 (1650 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sit down
Italian
American
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We've ordered pizza regularly from Ned's for the past two years, and usually we've been pretty satisfied. The pizza is high quality and stays well in..."
John O'Reilly
"So, I had an event that I was getting food for it last minute and let me just say that, from a business standpoint, the service I received was second..."
Hadassah Jahani
"I order from here occasionally for pizza night. The sheet pizzas have always been good. This time I used their delivery service through chownow which..."
Shelby Shultz
"We were in the area and looking for a quick NY style pizza and I’m pleased to say this hit the spot. We ordered an 18inch margherita and meat..."
Eric
"Ned's is my favorite pizza in Ithaca! We usually order take out, and everything is always nice and hot. The crust is great and the wings were also..."
Austin Hovland
"The guys are hospitable, very hardworking, and all-around excellent in what they do. Needless to say, the pizza here rocks and they make a delicious..."
John Vongas
"So right off the bat this pizza passed the flop test. Crust is A+. Perfect amount of toppings. Some of the best pizza in Ithaca. Wings are cooked to..."
Derek Brown
"One of the best pizza places in the Ithaca area! First time getting a sheet pizza here and it was delicious. I'm glad they're open..."
Angelique Marie
"Pizza was very good. Did an online order and was told I would get a follow up email. 45 minutes later no email. Called the restaurant and was told..."
William Packer
"I eat here on a regular basis. The employees are always so nice. And the food is always amazing. Great place to grab a..."
Malinda Bickham
"Friendly handsome staff! Wonderful delicious food! They even made a brand new pizza just for me to have a slice because they didn't have the eggplant..."
Kelly Griffin Sherwood
"Service is always fast! Great pizza and always have many choices for slices at lunch..."
Kelsey Murdock
"The pizza is delicious and they sell by the slice. They're quick and efficient, which is a huge plus during lunch time. The prices are also cheap -..."
Richard Matheny
Italian Carry Out
85/100 (1115 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Wings
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I used to work for Ico for a brief period while in college. Working with everyone was like an extension of my family back home. They were genuine..."
Barbara Ann Hauss
"Great large spaghetti with a meat ball. Absolutely more than enough for Anne and I to handle (esp. when you add the bread that came with it), and the..."
Chris Woodard
"Thanks for all you did at Uncle Jake's memorial today!!! Yummy..."
Rosie Perry
"Worked with ICO a few times in the past few weeks to get a party catered and to order food for a business lunch. In both cases they went over and..."
Susan Evans
"Best homemade sauce ever!!!! I love their chicken parm dinner. I highly recommend..."
Sue Watkins
"Best food in Ithaca! Best pizza, salads, subs. Oh! and the blue..."
Kristopher Terry
"Best pizza in..."
Jesse Wiiki
"The King of South Hill Pizza! Had it tonight --..."
Zoltan Gergely
"Simply put - everything is great! My favorite meal in town is the Flying Squirrel sub. First - all subs are made with Ithaca bakery bread and..."
Benjamin
"A little bit of a wait. Full 30 minutes or so. But I got free slice of pizza as they were closing and only 2 left to choose from. Ordered chicken..."
Jon Pendleton
"If I could give this business and family 10 stars I would. Their chicken wing pizza is out of this world! Their salads are fresh and they use..."
Nathanael Katsiane
"Best pizza in the region by far! They’re also the go to option for wings, bomb hot subs, crazy chicken parms, and killer salads. If you’ve never..."
Tyler Nevill
"Review: Italian Carry Out, Ithaca NY First things first; I ordered my standard “review” pizza, a pizza with extra cheese, and the pizza showed..."
Michael Angley
"Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area!! Great customer service..."
Jeremiah Clark
"Double dough, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, probably the BEST pizza we have ever had from Italian Carry Out. Full of toppings, cooked just the way we..."
Deidre Deeley
"Loved the lasagna and the pizza was good too. The pizza portion, 2 slices and a drink for $5, was huge. The Greek salad with feta and olives was..."
Kim G
"Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area by far. Never..."
Garrett Storm
"Used to be able to dine in..now only take out..food great..as..."
Bob Mcavoy
"Gotta eat a great chicken Parm sub at least once a..."
Herb Whittaker
"I asked for a pizza recommendation, and two folks sent me here. Glad I listened. The pie was very good and the price was..."
Timothy Celenza
"Beyond fantastic! Food was delicious, very large portions, staff was friendly and prompt! Meatballs the size of my fist! Will definitely be back and..."
Beth O'Connor
"Is there a sixth star? The "squirrel" pizza with their homemade blue cheese dressing has become my favorite pizza around. Great food and..."
Scott Schmutzler
"Coming to ICO for 30 years when I visit Ithica. Same great food as..."
Dana Parker
"The staff here are some of the most genuinely warm people, making their service next level and “at home”. Quality of product is outstanding,..."
Family Account
Domino's Pizza
85/100 (860 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"This five star rating is from the turn around this store has done in the past year! Very responsive, and attend to concerns fairly. The staff has..."
Destiny Durgan
"We order from this Domino’s several times a week, and the food is consistently great, and the delivery is super fast every time, no matter what..."
Sarah PB
"Had to share my experience since I was wary about ordering after seeing some of the recent 1 star reviews. I had no issues ordering online for..."
Celine Gellineau
"Overall good experience. We had two carry outs in two days. First day the person who made our pizza gave a good amount of cheese but the second day a..."
Raihan Khan
"Their workers were amazing and the service was beyond phenomenal! However the domino's app to order on..."
verble shevalier
"Great Food Like the point system Best Driver Adam Thanks Bud Delivery price is a set back but Pizza is on..."
QuickDecision
"Jamillya is very good at her job she goes over and beyond to help a customer out. She has amazing customer service and great work..."
Melissa Scott
"Great service and delicious food, wonderful employees and delivery..."
Resi Lient
"we asked for plates and cups and they gave us some and the food was hella..."
Bewly isepic
"OMG!!! I haven't been to Dominos pizza in forever but I didn't feel like cooking so I want to grab one. I would like to add that the customer service..."
SingTrece “SingTrece”
"I always love getting pizza from here. The pasta is delicious too. There's many deals daily which helps you save up to $20. The workers are friendly..."
caitlin spry
Northeast Pizza And Beer Company
84/100 (757 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Fast and accurate delivery. Spicy gold sauce on the wings was top notch and the wings themselves were very good too. Nice and meaty. Pizza was..."
Ryan Schwartz
"Never disappoints chix blt sub very tasty, roast beef sub was very fresh, grilled chicken Cobb salad is delicious, love the pizza. Staff is always..."
Jennie's World
"Great selection of slices, crispy dough, fresh ingredients, automatic 3 stars since the bathroom was clean and has paper towels. In all seriousness,..."
Chief Kaos
"My absolute favorite pizza place ever. I always find myself comparing other pizza, wings and garlic knots to Pizza & Bones.. let me tell you; nothing..."
Cassie St. Clair
"Great salads, calozones and pizza 🍕 Haven't tried anything else but I'm sure it'll be good too. Place looks like it's under construction inside..."
Michael Marron
"Simply the best pizza in town! I recently moved here and after getting disappointed for so long I finally discovered this pizza place. They also do..."
Taha Mohammad
"This is THE best pizza shop in Ithaca! Their employees know what we want when we come in even if it’s been a while in between visits. You are..."
Kara Zahradnik
"I was originally hesitant to try Pizza and Bones in Dryden because the pizza prices seemed high relative to other places in the area. With noticing..."
Austin Brown
"These guys are killing it, never been disappointed ever. We order everything from lunch slice combo, dinner pizza wing combo, philly subs etc. Good..."
Nicole Creighton
"Outstanding pizza and wings. My sons favorite pepperoni pizza on the..."
Brett Oakes
"Cheerful phone answering, fast, on time, delicious pizza! Super nice to have another great pizzeria near home! Vegetarian pizza needs little more..."
Keewi Haller
"Best pizza in Tompkins county. These are the pizzetta..."
Kristen Carpenter
"Such a nice place, amazing staff, food came out fast and taste very good. Wings were nice and..."
Kaylee J
"We ordered the veggie wrap, 3 people had chicken parm, and my dad had a gigantic Greek calzone. Everything was perfect, the perfect amount of sauce..."
Megan
"Wonderful people and great food. Best pizza and wings I've had in a while! Had an issue with Doordash not giving me all my items and they made it..."
Christina Zaidi
"Close, fast and delicious. I wish I could order online and then pay in cash. They make the kind of dough that feels like it tastes good. You pick..."
Brooke McLymond
Ciao Wood-fired Pizza & Pasta
84/100 (1798 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Polenta
Lobster
Alfredo
Eggplant
Tiramisu
Salad
Meatballs
Lasagne
Wings
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari
Arancini
Risotto
Bruschette
Calamares
Pesto
Salmon
Paninis
Sandwiches
Cheesecake
Burger
Shrimp
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Our server was wonderful and the experience was really nice. The food was homemade and amazing! I had the Gnocchi which was homemade, soft and..."
Theresa Block
"Phenomenal food. I ordered the margherita wood fired pizza, the chicken parm, and an espresso martini. The pizza was note-perfect. Excellent crust,..."
Nikoli's Kitchen
"A-MAZING! I'm not sure what more I can possibly say about this place. The food is absolutely incredible. The red sauce simply amazing. Better than..."
Thomas Craver
"Our party of 8 was seated at a long rectangular table in the back which was great. Everyone seemed happy with their meal-huge portion of chicken..."
M M
"Absolutely delicious! The place was extremely busy. We expected the wait to be an hour. The host said 25 minutes, and we were seated with a menu in..."
Lisa Wheeler
"Food was really and good! Service was great for a holiday night and the food was served fresh! We had the appetizer, 2 pastas and a pizza and a kids..."
Ali Hassan
"Our 4th visit here. Food outstanding as always. Especially good is the shrimp scampi pasta. You might even see a doppelgänger of Emily Blunt (our..."
Don Allen
"They started us with some bread and dipping oil. It was good. Then we ordered the chicken wing appetizer. They were cooked differently then any other..."
David Gow
"Ciao! rhymes with Wow! WOW will be the word used to describe this restaurant. A spectacular treat of harmonious taste tantalizes the palate from..."
Daniel Richter
"Very busy. A little loud and service was a little slow. But we didn't go to eat fast. Our dinner was delicious, and the server still paid attention..."
Kira Hyde
"Sarah, our server, is fantastic, very kind, and attentive. She constantly checked in on us without going overboard about it, and was overall..."
Jorge
"Fantastic food, my mom said her eggplant Parmesan was the best she has ever had and that's pretty good for someone celebrating their 64th birthday!..."
Forest Immel
"Amazing food with a welcoming atmosphere. Everything was phenomenal from the hostess stand to the check. One of Ithacas top..."
Appleofmyeye Heath
"One of my favorite places to eat when I want a special meal out. You can see the oven where they cook all the pizzas, and it's a lot of fun to watch..."
Daniel Goldhorn
"We went to ciao for our anniversary and my husband's birthday on Sept 11 just outside ithaca NY and we were beyond pleased to say the least. The wait..."
noel kline
"The staff here is always very accommodating and friendly. Nothing but good things to say about the people here. The food is not exceptional, but..."
R.
Sal's Pizzeria
84/100 (735 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Chicken parmigiana
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Slice
Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Stopped in while on vacation had a pepperoni and green pepper pizza garlic parm wing and pizza and fires for the kids. Everyone thought the pizza was..."
Rob c
"For me this is the only go to place for pizza. I have been going there since high school. Never had a problem with service. I'm there usually once a..."
3 crazy Cats
"Being gluten free, there aren’t many options for pizza in Ithaca, but this is by far the best. It’s by far the best pizza I’ve had in the..."
Aleksander Vaca
"They delivered to my mother in a nursing home for her birthday they won't do anything special with the toppings but she was happy and they were..."
BAD
"Got just a regular pie both times and it was always hot and fresh! I really like their sauce compared to other places in..."
Courtney Pure
"Has a comfortable family business feel. Our server was very nice and attentive and the food was great. Wings were absolutely..."
Heather Surma
"I love this place! Their pizza is one of favorites around. The employees are some of the nicest I've encountered anywhere. They quickly learned what..."
Adrian D
"Pizza was very good, a bit under cooked but good. Staff very friendly. ..."
Brian Glassman
"Amazing food and service. I didn’t think I was that hungry but I demolished that lasagna all the..."
Melody Madhavan
"Very good food. Portions are great. Fast and delicious. Nice little spot from out of town er..."
Nancy G'Oh
"They are very nice people there. Good service and good..."
Eric Bergquist
"We ordered pizza and salad for carry out. The salad was fresh. The pizza was super tasty, although the crust was a little soggy In the..."
Janet Schiller
"Dined in with family, friendly service and pizza was delicious. Daughter did say it was her favorite..."
Jason J
"Friendly service and I mean A++. The food was great and I wouldn't hesitate to come back here. Picky kids loved..."
Chris Hully
"Amazing service. We were looking for a late lunch and found this gem. The portions were huge and they happily adjusted some options for us. And the..."
Audra Bieg
"Excellent, excellent NY pizza, just the way I remember it! Good job..."
Paul Kiskis
"Was in Ithaca for a family event, went searching for palatable pizza and on the 5th try, found Sal's. GREAT place! Tried a couple of slices and..."
G Floydfan
"Got to go pizza. Solids pie. Crust cooked great a long with a great tasting sauce. Great..."
Joe
Souvlaki House
83/100 (523 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Mediterranean
Greek
Pizza
Mediterranean
Greek
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Gyros
Souvlaki
Lamb
Eggplant
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Mediterranean
Greek
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The appetizers are great! They served us with warm bread and greek salad, the dips for the fries and falafel are great! However, i ordered souvlaki..."
Diana Leano
"A good greek place to visit. Carried out a Falafel Pita sandwich. It was huge and enough for a person's lunch. Quite tasty, I must say! Cost around..."
Siddhesh
"Everything was delicious… eggplant parm, gyro, Greek salad, penne a la vodka. Service was excellent. Looking forward to going back to try other..."
Samantha R-K
"Idk why people have not posted menus for this place so I will do it. Will delete if it’s not allowed tho :))) Like you can’t just not check it..."
Claire Wang
"Delicious food in a nice casual atmosphere with exceptionally friendly service. They have both Greek and Italian favorites, like souvlaki and pasta...."
The Suave Sultan
"Visiting my girlfriends brother at Cornell and happy to say we chose the right dinner spot. Delicious food and I can say with absolute certainty it..."
Kai Anucauskas
"Absolutely amazing and authentic gyro. Everything was put together with great care and packs enormous, rich flavor. Love this..."
Laura Arnold
"Love this place. Friendly staff. Good portions. Excellent pricing. Poured me a beautiful glass of wine twice the amount I'd get at other..."
Omar Daniel
"Considering the price and quality of this restaurant, I think it is underrated in the area. Prices compared to the rest of collegetown are very..."
V
"Traditional family restaurant. It's not fancy, but it has good, traditional Greek favorites, as well as a few Italian dishes like meatballs and..."
Janet Schiller
"Since I was in the US this was the first time I had such a delicious kebab lamb Souvlaki. It was so yummy. I will definitely go back. The vibe was..."
Niloofar Hakhamy
"I’ve gone to souvlaki house for 30 years and have never once had a bad meal. Their greek salad is so delicious and included with most entrees...."
Grace Goodhew
"Excellent Greek salad and pizza. Also a filling and large calzone. Very tasty and fast friendly..."
Michelle Nye
"We had a great experience in here. The staff was really welcoming. We were four and we ordered 3 plates of pasta and a hamburger. The pasta was..."
Paula Harguindey
"The food is amazing and the owners are just wonderful. I highly recommend this restraunt for anyone that likes..."
Connie Tallmadge
"Classic Ithaca/Cornell area eatery that's stood the test of time due to excellent service and wonderful..."
Elana Bentley
"Good quality food with decent portions and reasonable..."
Biswajit Santra
"Don’t be afraid to try out the Italian menu, just because of the restaurants name! I have NEVER had such a good pesto pasta in my entire life! A..."
Tiffany Martos
Franco's Pizzeria
83/100 (801 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza
Seating
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The best pizza here around.. if you are from Italy and you are looking for a real Italian pizzeria, this is the place where to..."
Gloria Gioia
"Easily the best and most pizza belt (Google it)-worthy pizza in Tompkins County. Get the..."
Ducson Nguyen
"Hands down the best pizza in Ithaca. They are doing holy work in this..."
Justin Zoll
"This is going to be my new go to place. These guys are the real deal. And this coming from a Long Island transplant! Haven't had pizza like home in..."
Laurene Mongelli Gilbert
"The best pizzeria in the area with a beautiful staff, very nice and..."
Antonino Badalamenti
"The very best pizza in Ithaca, and the Stromboli was great..."
Nicole Parnell McGuire
"Best pizza in Ithaca! Will be ordering from here for now on! Now if you just had wings. Hint..."
Jesse Hastings
"Ithaca can FINALLY claim a real-deal, totally authentic, DELICIOUS pizza! Franco's is what we've been waiting for in I-Town. Classy, simple menu;..."
Maddy Walsh
"Best pizza ever, made by fabulous people. Welcome to the..."
Keli Carlson
"Really delicious pizza 🍕 My family from NJ enjoyed it immensely! Give it a try if you're in Ithaca. You won't be..."
Lia Evola
"Awesome people and great pizza Congrats to the new..."
Lori Russell McCravey
"Yum! Love this pizza. Whether I order a whole pie, or just grab a slice, it's all delicious! The owners are super sweet and..."
Leslie Miller
"Best pizza around! A great addition to the the..."
Jyl Dowd
"First time there tonight and I’m sold. Best pizza in town at the..."
David Williams
"We found Franco during our vacation at Ithaca. Really good and fresh food, friendly service and chill place. This place was parents approved, we got..."
Reema Mulchandani
"You can order pizza with your own sauce and toppings. We ordered white sauce with onion, spinach and peppers. The crust is perfect thick. It was a..."
Varsha Dhavale
"My only issue was the lack of AC! The pizza looked so amazing I rushed on the first bite and burned my mouth! When I finally was able to taste it, it..."
Professor Rivera
"It’s been a long time since I’ve had pizza this good. It’s clear the owner has mastered the craft of making pizza. They also had a great..."
pedro fernandez
"Easily one of the best pizzas we've ever had! Quick food & friendly service. Highly recommend stopping by Franco's. Thank you for a delicious lunch..."
Julie Carter
"Crispy pizza. Perfection. No frills pizzaria. Just pizza and garlic knots. With a cold soda. Is anymore really nexessary? Maybe some more fans...."
Michael Garcia
"Fantastic neighborhood pizza shop! Not big, so seating is limited for eat-in, and the menu is basic. BUT, the food is great. Highly recommend the..."
K. R.
"The best pizza in Ithaca! A nice crispy crust topped perfectly; it really tastes like a pizza pie straight from Italy. You can pick it up by the..."
Daniel Goldhorn
"Love the pizza by the slice. Reheats quickly in the oven. Thin crust, good ratio of toppings, nice crisp crust. Sodas are not generic pepsi/coke..."
Katharine Long
"I ordered a plain slice and a spinach, feta, diced tomato slice. Both were fresh and..."
Louis DiMarzo
"Delicious local pizza place. We each got a couple slices. Perfectly cooked crust. Nice and thin and a good..."
Luke Carlson
"Very good pizzeria with friendly service. Great selection of Italian sodas as well. Pizza crust was nice and crisp and the toppings were perfectly..."
Christa Gagliano
"I got two different vegetarian slices, one thin slice and one deep dish. They were both delicious with great crusts. The service was prompt and..."
Allie Marie
"I have been visiting Ithaca for 10 days and I have eaten Franco’s pizza twice! Absolutely delicious. Both times I chose the option to build my own..."
Chandel Metcalf
"Best pizza in town, especially for those used to New York style or New Haven style. They even have Fox in Park soda which is the beacon of a great..."
DT C
"Pizza is 1 of my favorate foods and I have tried hundreds if not 1000s of pizzas over the years including in Italy. I can say without question..."
Barry Schiff
"The pizza was delicious. We asked a person where the best pizza was in town, and he said Francos. We weren't..."
Emely Burlew
"Stumbled upon this pizzeria. Pizza was great; atmosphere was crowded, no frills pizza joint; service was pretty good despite the crush of people..."
Mark Albrecht
Pudgie's Pizza & Sub Shops
76/100 (246 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"Great staff and well made. Not the best pizza but good and well priced. Sheets have the better flavor than anything..."
Gavin Krogstad
"Best pizza in Ithaca. The owner and staff go above and behind. If your in the 607 you definitely don't want to miss out on some great..."
Chauncey Snyder
"Awesome pizza! The crust on sheet pizza rocks. They have a drive-thru and a small section for indoor..."
Sam Poat
"Great food! Im not into spicy food but their hot sauce is soo good! Their sheet pizza is the best!! Alittle pricy but worth..."
Cloud Jasper
"I’ve been going here a long time. They have good..."
John Carson
"Our favorite pizza place!! We went twice in one week during..."
Emily Thomas
"We're going to be ringing in the new year with the best pizza and..."
Dale & Crystal NY
"Reasonably priced and one of the best pizzas..."
Dale Davis
"I had their bone-in chicken wings, and they were delicious, tasty and seasoned just right. The slice of stuffed pizza was filled with toppings. The..."
Kenny Luv!
"Ordered a party pack and a some extra wings, and I walked in, and not only was there only 1 guy working (he was getting slammed, I felt awful!)but..."
Georgina Jones
"Good food. Staff was cordial. Try the..."
Bamba Ndiaye
"Wow, ok so this place isn't hugely upscale but I was so impressed by the heart of both employees there that day. The went above to make sure I was..."
Joanne Fairbanks
"Our lunch was delicious 😋 thank..."
Tam S
Casablanca
76/100 (1185 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I recently tried the pizza at this place, and I found it to be quite average. It had a good taste, but I only tried their pizza, so I can't speak for..."
Christopher Bedrosian
"The service was excellent. The pizza and wings were delicious. I highly recommend this pizzeria..."
Meldina Muminovic
"Had a fantastic time out with a bunch of friends last night. I had the chicken over fries with white and hot sauce it was great! I didn't have the..."
nicholas joswick
"For those confused, the pizzeria and the restaurant that is right on top of the pizzeria on google is the exact same - you can get pizza but there..."
Billy Tu
"The lamb shawarma over rice hits every time. Meat is tender, sauce is so good. Fast service..."
Sarah Bogdan
"Verdict: Amazing halal pizzeria in Ithaca! Highly recommend!! Loved that halal is very clearly stated in the menu too Food: I got a pepperoni..."
Mohammed Waqar
"Casa Blanca is my favorite place for a late night slice of pizza! The staff is always super friendly and the pizza is even better. The last time I..."
Cayden Kuhns
"Surprised to see all the Greek, Halal, and Mediterranean options here along their pizza. Staff was friendly and the restaurant was clean. I will..."
Anthea Cavallaro
"Great food! First place in USA where I found halal lazzania. Food is super delicious. I was surprised to find a halal restaurant in Ithaca. Must..."
Musavvir Mahmud
"It's a great place for grabbing a casual bite to eat, whether you are out after drinks, out before a show at state theatre, or just plain want a..."
Jae S
Pat’s Pizzeria
76/100 (1025 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Pizza
Lunch
Dinner
"Enjoyed Pat's Pizzeria recently on a visit to Ithaca for a baseball tourney. Carried out a large thin crust pepperoni and a large regular pepperoni...."
Ron K.
"This is a small pizzeria in the city of Ithaca. Slightly on the expensive side but probably one of the better veggie pizza I have ever had. The..."
Pratik Gaitonde
"I've always loved Pat's but they have this girl there now who is outstanding. She knows how to make pizza like call Barstool good. She needs her own..."
Ricky Stewart
"Second time coming here! The mozzarella sticks are amazing!! We love the $19.99 deal!! Pizza is good too!! Friendly service..."
Vanessa Bouton
"Serves one of the BEST gluten free pizza’s that I’ve ever had! Well..."
Jennifer Miller
"Pizza was delicious. In our party, there were 3 different types of pizza ordered and everyone liked everything. Kids and adults were pleased. I had..."
Melissa Fraley
"The service was good, pizza was delicious. Highly recommend the garlic red sauce. They went the extra mile to make sure we were happy with our order..."
Ryan Cleare
"This was the first pizza I had from Pat's. We would be getting more too but it is a long drive from Syracuse to Ithaca. The staff was great, I called..."
Darlene Hyde
"This is among the tops for pizza we've had in Ithaca. Highly recommend the garlic red sauce, very tasty. We liked the crust...not too doughy, a bit..."
Gustave Axelson
"Since my wife has a gluten free diet, I was excited to see that Pat’s Pizzeria offered gluten free pizza. When I tried to call in an order,..."
Scott Griffith
"We get pizza usually once a week. Have tried every place in downtown Ithaca and Truman's urge. I have to honestly say Pat's pizza is the only 1 that..."
Kimberli HUBBELL
"Always good, but can’t seem to follow through on the white garlic sauce if red sauce is on a pie in the same order Edit: I was not able to take..."
Mary Elson
"Fantastic customer service and food! We originally ordered thru GrubHub the night prior and that was super late - to no fault of the restaurant! They..."
Irene B
"Edit: The owner was kind enough to reach out to me and remedy the situation. After talking to him personally on the phone and receiving an apology we..."
Riley Davis
"We were from out of town and my husband and son wanted 5 guys. I don't eat meat so we drove down the plaza and saw the pizza place pats. Went in and..."
Diana D
Papa Johns Pizza
75/100 (2692 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Pepperoni Slice
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Oreo Bites
Papa's Chicken Poppers
Mild Wings
Sit down
Pizza
Reservations
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great. Order Papa John's through Eatstreet. First time orders get $10 off using code FOOD67616. Ends May 31,..."
Tiffany Hart
"Quick Work Lunch 8" pizza takeout review! Thank you Papa John's Pizza Family Run owners! You made my day by reassuring me that I can order a mini..."
Sharon Nelson
"Only tried a few items but it's worth the five stars so far. The papa bites oreo bites are to get! Or get two, they're worth it. The papa bites..."
caitlin spry
"Value is my biggest reason to keep buying more pizza from here. The Shaq er oni pizza is fantastic and full of cheese and..."
Jay Davis
"I love Papa John's pizza! And I especially like the garlic sauce it comes with. It's good for dipping your crust or even pizza in. Always comes with..."
Mike M
"Great pizza. Only thing is that they run out of dollar slice pizza on tuesday earlier than..."
dushyant deshmukh
"Helped us to provide good veggie pizzas and the preparation was excellent. Even the dough was eggless. Highly recommended for vegetarians...must..."
Bhaarat Vyas
"Lately all I've encountered here are friendly and personable workers. Foods always..."
Nicole Williams
"Papa John's is my favorite pizza! I love how nice the Staff was, and how they helped me bring My pizza to my car even though they were smashed with..."
Samantha Townsend
"I've never gotten someone else's order or an uncut pie here. Can't say that about 75% of other pizza shops. Staff are always nice. Greeted upon..."
Gary Ayres
"Cheap pizza but depending who makes it they always have different cheese consistency. Too much and it make it so greasy there is a shiny circle where..."
Rachael E
"This is a pretty good location. It’s your typical Papa John’s, so nothing terribly different here. Food usually comes out on time and correct. A..."
Anton
Sicilian Delight Ithaca
75/100 (606 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Fast food
Pizza
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Wings
Fast food
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Delicious Chicken Riggies with the best pizza pies. Can’t go wrong..."
Shaina Pleeter
"Always been my favorite ! The best pizza in NY, and maybe the world!..."
Rhiannon Bolos Da Cunha
"I've been to pizza shops from NY to Cali. I honestly can say Sicilian Delight is by far one of the best around. You can tell a good pizza from not..."
Rick Policastro
"Love their selection of pizza. What great creations! The chicken wing pizza is the best I've ever..."
Jackie Terrell Hobika
"Great pizza whenever I have a chance I eat at Sicilian..."
Chad Vandermark
"The best damn pizza in New York hands..."
Dominick Salvaggio
"If I could give more stars, I would! Stefano is the perfect example of a customer focused business owner. The food is absolutely amazing, and the..."
ALLISON REID
"We visited after the store closed, and the owner was extremely kind to invite us to have free pizza! Very delicious! Best pizza I’ve had in..."
Anonymous
"The staff are always very kind and funny. The food is delicious. Literally can’t decide what my favorite thing was. If you’re looking for good..."
Danielle Aiken
"If I can give 6 stars I would. They are so friendly. The people that own it treat you like family. They are not picky about every single thing and..."
Micah Page (Metulburr)
"Amazing new owners very kind ! I haven’t been to the mall in a long time. Decided to stop. i purchased a variety of their slices they all tasted..."
Jennifer Nash
"If yall never came here before, yall don't know what a real pizza tastes like. Staff is always friendly, always gets us right, makes some great..."
Kaleb Reeves
"Wow 🤩 Best pizza ever ❤️.. Stefano is the best pizza man I have ever seen . I will be back for sure … if I could give 10 stars I would . For..."
The italian Job
"The food here is great. The place has an amazing friendly atmosphere thanks to the people who work here. They’re all extremely kind and great at..."
Byron Quevedo
"I would take a picture of the rest of the food I got but it was so good I couldn't hold off! Meatballs are amazing and made fresh as well as my slice..."
Maxwell Shapiro
"Stefano and Lucy are great and I appreciated how kind they were!!! The pizza is also one of my favorites in Ithaca, a go to when at the mall or..."
Adriana Lima
"Their pizza is the perfect balance of affordable and delicious :) Everyone is very friendly! It's clear that they love what they do and care about..."
Hannah Barden
"I was just passing by and stop here at itacha mall and let me tell you , Sicilian Delight did not disappoint, I order a chicken parm, Stromboli , 2..."
Patricia Lopez
"Great pizza and service. Sicilian Delight provided many pizzas for a large function. Everyone at Sicilian Delight was really helpful in making sure..."
Delia Herrin
"There’s a guy named Stefan who works here and he’s great. He’ll give you a discount for being a college kid and serve you great food. If..."
SammyPerDue
"The pizza is delicious, the people are very nice, the perfect spot for lunch. Chef Stefano and company have all kinds of great recipe ideas, note to..."
Matthew McVey
"Sicilian Delight has the loveliest and nicest staff/cook in the town! I was actually here yesterday as a door dash driver. When I arrived there,..."
Simon Gim
"i’ve stopped by a couple times while i’ve been in the mall and have always loved there garlic knots and garlic pizza and i showed up right as..."
Emery Erickson
"One of my favorite pizza places in Ithaca! Almost just like downstate NYC. They are..."
Dani Bruso
"The employees here were some of the nicest people I have ever met. The food was perfect. Would highly recommend coming..."
Jake Wilson
Ned's Pizza Ny
74/100 (1260 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Pizza
Italian
Mediterranean
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
American
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sammy's Pizzeria & Restaurant
74/100 (1559 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Awesome food on the commons!!!! Great pizza, wings and cheese steak sub..."
Nick Tomaras
"The best place to go to get pizza and excellent service I may deliver there food every night for a 3rd party delivery service but I order pizza every..."
Heath Phillips Jr.
"Un lugar muy tranquilo y sobre todo Exelente y rápida..."
Deo Rojas Fernández
"Delicious Pizza! My favorites are "chicken ranch and margerita". Never ate better calzones than Sammy's. All has ricotta cheese as call the tradition..."
Sandra Chafee
"Quick friendly service with a smile! Truelly the best pizza in ithaca you cant beat true fresh ingrediants homemade dinners and single pasta dishes..."
James Drake Chrisp
"Best Pizza In..."
Sam Chafee
"The gentleman who greeted us was so kind and helpful in a pinch! We are from out of town and didn’t realize that everything would be closed so..."
Martha Dunkelberger
"Convenient location in the commons. Everything seemed relatively clean when I went. The bomber sandwich and fries I got were nice and fresh. Good..."
Desh Cooper
"The pizza is very good. I would go back for a pizza any day of the week. Thin crust, perfect amount of cheese and..."
Sanatana Infiniti
"I'd take some of these reviews with a big grain of salt. It appears some people don't know what pizza is supposed to taste like. But that's okay,..."
CS RG
"You walk in the door and get greeted with smiles. The food is great, and the atmosphere is just right for a quick lunch, dinner, or late night snack...."
Scott Burun
"Really love their pizza and atmosphere. Always very happy 😊 and friendly. Reasonable..."
Debi Davis
"There's plenty of schools of thought on what's the best style of pizza. Ultimately, it's subjective and everyone has their own favorite, or a style..."
Timothy Crowley
"Sammy's is the best & im most definitely not the only one who thinks so. It's been the favorite among Ithaca college and Cornell kids for years...."
Mar C.
"We love Sammy's! We strolled to the Commons on our night walk, and picked up Eggplant Parm dinners. We hurried home and dined amongst the birds and..."
a mzo
"Grilled chicken salad AMAZING! wings absolutely amazing! My kiddos and I enjoy them so much they have been eaten three times this week! Keep up the..."
Kim B
"Come here if you need a quick slice! Tastes like real NY pizza. Been living upstate for 5 years and this is the best regular slice of pizza I've..."
Sidney Mclaughlin
"Amazing pizza as good as francos and Thompson and bleecker. Better service and price. Slices are really big and filling. Reminded me of the brooklyn..."
Utkarsh Jain
D.p. Dough
73/100 (620 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Italian
Fast Food
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I love D.p. dough I always order 3-4 calzones when I go to Ithaca!! Psst. There all for me�and I was so sad when the closed the Vestal ny location..."
Henry E. Jaworski III
"Thanks for taking care of my boys last night with the best calzones in town. Much appreciated, and your first beer is on me in..."
Mike Davie
"Slam bangin got free bizzle on my shizzle!!! Way better than buying one chopped clam for 5 bucks at the..."
Nick Monico
"Best calzones ever and so many types to choose from. It's a priority to go to DP dough anytime I'm in upstate..."
Jessie Mac Garvey
"We just got one in Rochester that I order from now and then so when I was in Ithaca for work and had been working very late I was so glad to see a..."
Julie Heizyk
"Fast delivery, great food, and open later than..."
Brian Miller
"Best place to eat and the price is awesome. College student life..."
Josef Edward
"Best buffer zone..."
Bill D Ayers
"After a long day of hiking, then getting clean after we ran out of places to eat. Thankfully D.P. Dough was open at 11 and delivered our food. We..."
Emily Karsten
"The quality of the food is like 6 to 7 out of 10. However it's the only late night restaurant in town and they have great service, so that makes up..."
Cory Walaitis
"These are the type of people that you want to make a calzone for you. Food was delivered fast, hot and delicious. We got two calzones, the garlic..."
Caitlin Lawrence
"I ordered a calzone and the cheese sticks. They were delicious. The people working were very friendly and had my food out quickly. Best food..."
Ryan Friedman
"calzones are good and its super clutch to have someplace open late at..."
A Gallagher
"the food was fresh & hot and the workers were SO..."
Abigail Gordon
"Been ordering from them for years now and can honestly say they’re one of the best, especially late night, restaurants around. Great Calzones as..."
Paul Morgan
"They must put cocaine in those calzones. How do you make a creation this good. The oozing cheese off the soft fresh bread crust dipped into the..."
Jonathan Segal
"I have loved DP Dough since my own college days at UMass Amherst 30 years ago. The quality of calzones are even better now and I am never..."
kelly Molito
"Seriously the best calzone I have ever had. People who work here are to the point and honest (no BS about wait times). Highly recommend the Bro Zone..."
Joseph Spak
"I've ordered you guys on and off for years ( I work nights). Recently I lost my phone while doing some late night post-work dog walking on a sketchy..."
Jonni Campbell
"Good calzones with a ton of selection. This place is a staple to many in Ithaca, but I rarely find myself going or ordering. Takes on average 10-20..."
Nathan Adara
"Ate lunch at the Green St. location at least a handful of times a month. LOVED the End Zone - beef and onions and green peppers... so good! Franchise..."
Phil
"DP Dough. Man. What can I say about this place? You come out of one of the pubs near commons after a night of drinking. It's late. And you are..."
Bhargav Sanketi
"An Ithaca classic. DP Dough serves up the best, most fresh, customizable calzones along with some awesome cheesy bacon tots and an amazing calzone..."
Meagan T
"this is my go to when i go to ithaca. arriving in ithaca at 1 am? no problem! dp dough has got you. i've had so many delicious calzones but i'm dying..."
Eva Spak
Big Al's Hilltop Quikstop
71/100 (32 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Sit down
Pizza
"I have been buying gas and and occasional pizza slice for years and have always been happy. Last night I ordered a whole cheese pizza planning to put..."
Inn on .Columbia
"Hi I am a customer that has been going to the store for years... I am writing this email.. to say what huge improvement .. the store has been..."
Ed Merrick
"Quick easy in and outas well as store is clean every time I..."
Kristen Tofsrud
"Nice..."
Joe McMahon
"Great..."
Jacob Ball
""
Cat Doane
""
Nick Alexander
""
Adam Miner
""
Dustin Soper
""
The Throttles and Life of Jessi
""
Joan Chandler
""
Rick Packard
""
TIMOTHY LAWRENCE
College Town Pizza Incorporated
70/100 (99 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Lunch
"Typical college town pizza place- low cost. Their best pizza might be chicken bacon ranch. It's open late at night. The staff there is very..."
Viju Vijayan Pillai
"Got the eggplant parmesan sub. Came with a side of fries. Great, tasty food! There's a TV on the wall so you have something to watch if you're eating..."
Rishi Advani
"Just tried the Gyro over Rice meal I always see people ordering and it was delicious! Way better than it looked and I’ve always thought it looked..."
luruns
"It's the best pizza in Ithaca by a long shot, not that that's saying a whole lot given how the Ithaca area isn't all that competent or diverse in the..."
Todd Bollinger
"Got a large cheese pizza, thin crust tastes great!! I called ahead for 6PM, got there a few minutes early and the owner had it ready for me for 6 on..."
W
"First time and loved it! Ordered on a Sunday afternoon, delivered with in 1/2 hour and it came hot and delicious! Definitely ordering you pizza..."
esther escobar
"Spicy Chicken wrap and chicken tenders are delicious. Owner is a welcoming person, definitely..."
Haider Niaz
"Super fast! The guy was exceptional friendly, even gave me a discount! Pizza is closest to NYC style you can get in..."
Dani
"Pizzas are solid, prices are a little pricey, but on the better side of pizzas in Ithaca. The location is also really..."
Christopher De Jesus
"There are new owners this semester so we decided to give it another try! If I could give TEN stars I would! Burgers, pizza, and mozzarella sticks,..."
Raymond Taylor
"Food and service was great. Have done both take out and in person dining and food has always been great, will definitely eat there..."
Christos Vlahos
"The Pitzza is good for the price. It’s not a fancy place for Pitzza. I think the writings on the wall, give it a very suburban atmosphere which is..."
Amy R
Bella Pizza
70/100 (2 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Fast food
Italian
Pizza
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Rogan's Corner
70/100 (681 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
American
Pizza
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Tastes just like it did 20 years ago! Class of '99 in the..."
Fred Topel
"I love your pizza! I am originally a LI girl, so I am very picky!..."
Kat Walters
"Atmosphere+food=..."
Thor Dickquist
"I have a sub and as well as their pizza........wow! The meals were great and the prices very reasonable. I could not believe how large the sub was..."
Walt Bitler
"great breakfast sandwiches, solid subs, great..."
Mil Stojanovic
"Sandy S was awesome! Very customer oriented and even brought our pizza out when it was done (we were waiting in the parking lot)! Definately an..."
Jess Golden
"Definately an employee that is great for your business! Thanks again Sandy! We will definitely be..."
Anais Vautrin
"I live near Rogans but have never bought pizza there thinking that it was just low level greasy gas station food. I ordered a large Margarita pizza..."
Inn on .Columbia
"This review was written before the Dandy took over the store. I cannot attest to the quality now, but before it had: Best pizza and wings in the..."
Cristina Carter
Pronto
70/100 (76 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast Food
Fast food
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Fast food
Pizza
Seating
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use