Sluurpy
Reset

There are 7 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Seafood cuisine: the best places to taste it in Ithaca

There are 7 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Red And White Cafe
97/100 (162 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Cafe
Seafood
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Haddock
Fish
Café
Café
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The best haddock you will ever eat, With a great home-made tartar sauce. I would recommend this place to anyone that wants a great fish..."
Jessie Mae Reeves
"I had a really good BBQ 🍗 sandwich! I would recommend this place to..."
Matthew Beers Okubo-Reed
"Amazing fish dinners! The owner, John, made the day of our tourist family. The food was excellent. Our party of 12 loved everything we ordered. ..."
Stephanie Russek
"We have not had a bad meal here ever. Generous portions, wonderful people. Love, love, love the fish..."
Vince Kotmel
"The people are amazing and the food is even better! I frequent the place not only for the fish, but the atmosphere as..."
Maggie Lynne
"The best food and service around! Family-owned and..."
Ronda D Catlin
"I said it before Best Fish in Ithaca! I went at the lunch time rush on a Friday got my fish sandwich and fries in 2 minutes probably less! And it is..."
Zack Stanek
"Delicious! So glad they are open for lunch now. Great..."
Dina Banning
"Best fish fry and fried oysters in the area. Yes - better than Maxie's or Doug's in any of their locations. I wish they had more hours or were..."
Charles Pomada
""Diamond in the rough" is how my wife described the Red and White Cafe. We both ordered the fish dinner, comes with fries and cole slaw. The BEST..."
Dan Biechele
"Quality is on par with most other better-known fish fry places in the region, but I like their sauce better. Fish and coleslaw taste fresh. The place..."
A Google User
"I am remiss at having forgotten to mention what may be the Greatest Cafe in New York. And that Cafe is the Red & White Cafe, in Ithaca. For that, I..."
Edward Bailey
"Some of the best fried oysters I've ever had. The price was a tad bit steep yet for what we got, it was worth it; after all you get what you pay for...."
Christopher Church
"I really wanted to love the Cafe, but when I arrived they were very low on options which affected the quality of the food I received as well. I will..."
MaryG
"For what they serve, it is excellent. I have always gotten the Friday fish fry here but I understand their other menu items are delicious. Several..."
Andy Guerriero
"A real find. The sharp exterior caught our eye. Food was very good. Fried haddock was same day freshness and fried expertly.fried shrimp/scallop not..."
John Mcgivney
"Probably the shortest review I'll ever give. This is the only place I trust in town to make anything fried. I get a fish fry at least once a month..."
SQH
"Can't believe it took us so long to try this place! As others say - it's the only place in town to get good fried fish! Local, family owned...."
Lee Cotman
"The cafe is a friendly, small-scale restaurant great for lunch or a quick meal. The owner is incredibly friendly and gave me suggestions for local..."
Alexander Williams
"Can't think of anything that I would take a star away for. It is a small, informal place. You order at the counter and choose a seat; your food is..."
Cate T.
"Best spot in town for fish fry. Much more reasonably priced than the "Doug's" truck that comes to town. It is also fun to see all the local history..."
John Rogers
"This place has the BEST seafood dinner I've had in a long time. The Owners are nice and you feel at home. I'll be going back my next trip up..."
Ana Rucker
"Good fish. We ordered and was told 10 15 mins. We went inside and they asked did we order...we said yes we called they laughed and said they forgot..."
SingTrece “SingTrece”
"Best fish dinner in Ithaca! The owner and the folks who work there are all very nice and my order was up very quickly. They will be getting more of..."
John Fry
Maxie's Supper Club And Oyster Bar
87/100 (2750 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Cajun & Creole
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Bar
Cajun & Creole
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Late Night
Burger
Po' Boys
Andouille
Crab Cake
Fish
Pork
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Shrimp
Tapas
Beef
Fish Taco
Tacos
Ribs
Salad
Jambalaya
Crab
Crawfish
Clams
Catfish
Oyster
Tuna
Fish & chips
Salmon
Sandwiches
Shrimp and Grits
Sit down
American
Bar
Cajun & Creole
Seafood
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Seating
Live Music
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"For appetizers we had fried green tomatoes with a remoulade and the steamed clams. The fried green tomatoes were incredible, crispy and a touch spicy..."
Nikoli's Kitchen
"Babyyyy, I would give 7 stars if I could! I absolutely lovedddd my blackened catfish sandwich, the cornbread, the very friendly and helpful service,..."
L Smith
"Charming, cozy and classy. Excellent service and delicious food. Even after a bit of an ordering snafu (slight difference of interpretation as to..."
Coleman Swartz
"Great service! Delicious food. Cold beer and wine. Really nice atmosphere. We had a fantastic evening! Jambalaya was amazing! Fish and ships are the..."
Janine Ziermann-Canabarro
"The live oyster was fresh but a little bit pricey…the crabcakes and others are in medium quality to..."
Le Phuong Tran
"Great food, nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Excellent homemade cornbread. If you like oysters they were preparing them the entire time we were..."
Dane Summerville
"One of the best restaurants in Ithaca. Maxie’s truly brings an authentic and delicious southern seafood experience to Upstate NY. The quality of..."
Ben Wells
"Very crowded during the Ithaca College family weekend. Reservations recommended. Great food, and wait staff were very attentive despite the rush. ..."
Skip Zimmerman
"Loved the oysters on half shell. The Finger Lake Old Fashion was perfect. Smooth bourbon with excellent bitters and flavors. The Po'boy..."
charles lawhun
"We stopped by after visiting the Ithaca falls and we loved it! The seafood platter was so..."
Nina Brajdic
Pokeland
87/100 (297 ratings)
Restaurants
Hawaiian
Sushi
Seafood
Healthy
Hawaiian
Sushi
Seafood
Healthy
Sushi
Healthy
Seafood
Hawaiian
"My new favorite place in Ithaca! Everything in the picture is very tasty. The unlimited refill of lychee, passion fruit, and peach drink is also..."
Mingla Charoenmuang
"Food was amazing and so delicious! They never fail to amaze me. Personally I don’t eat raw fish, but their fish is always so fresh. Also, I love..."
Joyce Chen
"Food is great and affordable. Never been disappointed for the past few years. I am glad they are opening a new location..."
Natalia Lee
"Favorite place to eat near Cornell— reasonable price for the amount of food you get! I love the proportions of everything they give you and it..."
Ya Yay
"One of the best takeout foods in Collegetown. Decent quality food with reasonable..."
Chanki Jo
"Go-to spot for lunch or dinner because they have great and healthy variety of options, across my time as a student this is among if not one of my..."
Althea Bata
"food is so good! i always go there and the workers are always so..."
Paul Resmer
"Love this place! The fish never looks tired and the portions are hearty without being excessive. Love all the options and toppings, and unique canned..."
Mia Ferraina
"Ordering on line was super easy and my order was ready for pick when I got there. So the service was great! The food was also tasty and very filling...."
Carolina H
"Came here on a whim after getting sick of eating my own food. I used to get food from the dining halls, but now that I’ve moved off campus, it’s..."
Jackie Choe
"Excellent healthy options, very tasty. Always my go-to for a takeout lunch/dinner option. Even better since they opened the seating area next..."
Brooke Hinkle
"Great place to stop by for a fairly-priced quick meal in Collegetown. They have a fresh selection of fish and ingredients to build your bowl..."
Karla Wang
"best poke in ithaca, portions are great and food is always prepared quickly. love that they support local student organizations by hosting..."
Larson Ortiz
"Love that they offer so many customizable options for protein, toppings, mix-ins, and dressing. Suitable for vegans and vegetarians..."
shiyin ge
"Hands down the best ramen I've had. And I've tried many restaurants. Top notch, amazing flavor and even better..."
Crystal Cotto
"Yummy and fresh - I love their sauces and the huge portions! Crispy onions is the best topping by..."
Kimberly Liu
"Fish is always good quality and the staff are really hardworking! Also great sauce options and many toppings to choose..."
Serena Huang
"As someone who loves Poke, I'm so glad that I can eat it in Ithaca! Pokelava is the place to go for Poke, it's fresh and..."
Sanya Mahajan
"Pokelava has been a staple since I've moved to Ithaca. The service is always quick, atmosphere is home-y, and poke always tastes..."
Riya Mukherjee
The Antlers Restaurant
83/100 (1101 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Filet Mignon
Ribs
Shrimp
Cakes
Beef
Pesto
Fish
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Duck
Salmon
Burger
Crab Cake
Sit down
American
Seafood
Free Wifi
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Reservations
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Mid-range
"A modern and clean looking place that has been around since the 80s. Great steaks, the old fashioned cocktail was perfect, service was attentive and..."
E&C Cox
"My husband and I were visiting the area and the hotel clerk suggested Antlers, a locally owned restaurant. We went for happy hour and had delicious,..."
Joanne Roberts
"We had a great meal last night for our anniversary. We haven't done a nice date night in sooooo long and all I wanted was amazing food and a good..."
Kayla Thomas
"Amazing food. Worth the premium price tag. Little gem that unfortunately is missed by many. If you love steak, support this local spot and actually..."
Ian Eppig
"WOW! Not enough space to tell all the good about this place. The food was excellent, the service superb, (thanks Chelsea!), and the martini was..."
Gaye Sautro
"Service was top notch! Our waitress was awesome! Some of the food was delicious and some was just ok. We ordered the Beef Flight, unfortunately it..."
Marisa Metcalfe
"Absolutely phenomenal food. I had their 22 oz ribeye special which had the perfect crust and was super juicy. The scallops were also cooked to..."
Ray Zhou
"I don't know if they got a new chef or a new smoker or what, but we stopped in for their Friday lunch happy hour yesterday and I was seriously..."
Merardo Buquez
"Lovely restaurant with amazing wait staff and quality food. I had the Duck, and my partner had the Scallops. We also tried an appetizer special..."
Kieran Frodelius
"It's a cozy restaurant with amazing food and friendly people. The steak was one of the best I've ever..."
Elia Mariën
"Standard qualifier, I'm a tough rater. Antlers is a very good place to eat, a long-time area establishment. This was our first visit for brunch and..."
Dan Biechele
"It was very tasty! Scallop starter was really good but pretty expensive, only 3 scallops. I got burger, my BF of chicken sandwich. We came on early..."
Tiffany
"Very quaint restaurant, non chain. It's like stepping into a time machine back to 1980, in a good way. Our server was super friendly. Nichole? We..."
Neil Westervelt
"We were in town dropping our daughter at Cornell and saw this place had awesome reviews. It exceeded our expectations. We've regularly eaten at some..."
Renita D.
"Great restaurant in Ithaca area. Menu isn’t huge but all the dishes we had were delicious and of high quality. Very accommodating when we brought..."
Melvin Guan
"A hidden gem. Especially great on a cold wintery night when you're looking for a hearty meal and stiff, yet delicious drink. A local must. The..."
Heath Robinson
"Wow! We were treated so well when we came in. The service, the food, and the atmosphere was top notch! The delmonico steak was the best I've ever..."
Coreena Berube
"Had a business outing of 25+ ppl on Monday 10/2/23. I state the date because a majority of restaurants in the area were closed. Their loss..Antlers..."
Tim Cappellett
Royal Court Restaurant
82/100 (268 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Steakhouse
American
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
American
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Old school cool! Saturday prime rib special was fantastic, I highly recommend it! This is a local culinary treasure! Enjoyed the salad bar and..."
Sherwin Safir
"The restaurant could use some remodeling inside. The server was pleasant and a seasoned server at that. Very attentive. I had the Reuben sandwich on..."
Nastassjah Williams
"Fish Fry Friday! The atmosphere and service here are phenomenal! Friendly and polite wait staff. The salad bar is yummy with great selection of..."
Alina Gleockler
"Brilliant old school American restaurant. Great food great service brilliant bar area. Thoroughly enjoyed our lunch with lovely real..."
Chris and Dig Butler
"Waitress was very knowledgeable and quick with our food, friendly too. The food was bountiful, could not eat it all but delicious!!! 1st 2 times I..."
Susan Morgan
"The food was great. Service was awesome. Wait staff was very friendly! Nice salad bar with dinner which is hard to find in a restaurant these days...."
C Fish
"Delicious food, nostalgic decor, quick service, staff and patrons often know each..."
Vernon Marsh
"Great meal, salad bar was fresh and..."
Donald Brown
"My review may be different from most only because I frequent it more than others. However, if you were to frequent it as much as I did then you would..."
Edward Bailey
"This is a great restaurant. The food here is fantastic. I had a fish, shrimp and scallop plate that was very very good. My wife had the Chicken..."
Dave M (Dave M)
The Boatyard Grill
70/100 (3190 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Bar
Bar
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
American
Seafood
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Crab
Burger
Filet Mignon
Scallops
Hamburgers
Swordfish
Clams
Ribs
Calamari
Risotto
Tuna
Shrimp
Tortillas
Calamares
Beef
Cheesecakes
Salmon
Shrimp and Grits
Cakes
Lobster
Pesto
Crab Cake
Eggplant
Fish
Chowder
Cheesecake
Pasta
Tapas
Salad
Clam Chowder
Fish Taco
Tacos
Sit down
Seafood
Bar
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Television
Table Service
Live Music
Wheelchair Accessible
Waterfront
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dog Friendly
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Mid-range
"1st time here, and we will definitely be back. We had the NY cheddar burger and fish fry dinner. The food was hot, the burger was above average. The..."
Denise Smith
"Food was amazing, the servers were so pleasant. The atmosphere was very welcoming. We enjoyed out dining experience. The French Onion Soup exceeded..."
NICOLE NILES
"Came in Friday night for dinner via boat around five thirty. I had the Georgia peach chicken and my guest had Jumbo sea scallops. Salad and bread..."
Constantine Karamargin
"Been coming to Ithaca to visit for many years. Every time we come I wanted to try The Boatyard Grill. Either it was closed the day we were in town or..."
Matthew Cerasia
"We arrived between 5-5:30 and had an hour an a half wait. We had a couple of beers and the fabulous artichoke dip at the bar while the bartenders..."
Laura West
"(12/20/23) Got there a bit early, just starting to get busy. Seated right away, after the manager realised the hostess was taking forever with..."
Neil Westervelt
"I had the fish tacos. They were great. The seasoned fries they came with were also very good but only luke warm. My wife had the salmon with rice..."
Joseph McLain
"Wow !!! What a seafood experience it was at boatyard grill. One of the best seafood I've had. Ordered coconut shrimps, fish tacos, fry fish, orange..."
Saim Jawad Laliwala
"We had our friend reunion here and didn’t realise how popular this place is, especially on the weekend. They don’t take reservations so at best,..."
Hong Hanh Dinh
"I never have a bad meal here. I live out in Aurora, so we will take the boat down the lake to have dinner here. Definitely suggest to call ahead and..."
Brittney Colton
"We are out of towners who came to visit Taughannock park for the day and my wife found The Boatyard Grill online for our dinner. I had the salmon and..."
Chris D.
"After a long 1h and 10 minutes wait to be seated on a Wednesday afternoon, we enjoy the magnificent Boatyard Grill. Our server was Mark, really nice..."
Gio M
"Excellent food, atmosphere and friendly staff. Everything we had was simply awesome and delicious. Definitely..."
Dane Summerville
"Our visit to the Finger Lakes area was enhanced with our dinner at the Boatyard. Dined on the patio which was closed due to the rain. But it was as..."
Chuck Losch
"Superior staff. Service was top notch, quick and friendly. Lowell was our bartender and he was amazing. The other gentleman was great as well. The..."
Stephanie Tallman
"Highly highly recommend this place. It's totally worth the wait time and the hype. Best for seafood , but veg dishes are also equally good. We..."
Anuja Puranik
Parrilla Restaurant
70/100 (17 ratings)
Restaurants
Steakhouse
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use