I saw a lot full of cars at the new Your Pie on Beach and Hodges. Thinking they were open for business, I walked in to an enthusiastic greeting and found it to be the soft opening. My name was not on the list. They let me in anyway.
I went through the pizza assembly line where the eager rookie pizza chefs piled on the sauce of my choice along with cheese and toppings. I grabbed a drink cup, filled it with ice, pulled the spigot on the sweet tea... Drip, drip, drip. All out. I asked if there was any more. Negative. I got some water and sat down to eat my handcrafted pizza. 5 minutes later a manager comes over, puts a cup on my table and says, "Let me know how that tastes." Perfectly southern sweet tea. Made by a New Yorker!
Well done Your Pie, Beach and Hodges...Well done!
It is it was really good and I especially love their giletto which is a type of ice cream but better just really good it tastes just like Pieology they've got salads they've got you can build your own pizzas they got five they got drinks they got Panini you can pick your favorite but customize it as well the things you can look put it on your pizza is like like white wheat gluten free bread bowl Panini bread kids Panini bread kids white kids Wheat the songs you can get marinara extra virgin olive oil buffalo sauce BBQ & paisal best pesto the cheese and get
shredded mozzarella CT fresh mozzarella ricotta parmesan provolone vegan cheese need to keep up pepperoni bacon chicken Italian sausage meatball ham turkey salami veggies you can put artichoke cards Banana Peppers basil black olives broccoli cilantro garlic green bell peppers jalapenos mushrooms oregano pineapple red onions Romaine spinach sun-dried tomatoes and tomatoes and Justin's you can put balsamic vinegar blue cheese Caesar Greek Ranch jalapeno honey mustard it's all just really good and that's all I have to say about your pie please come and join your pie and get to taste the wonderfulness of pizza.
I moved to Jacksonville 2 years ago from NY which is known for the best pizza! I have not been able to find a good pizza in JAX until "Your Pie" opened...thin crust, crispy, absolutely delicious! A must try and the staff were very friendly and helpful. Congratulations and best wishes!
Just had the most delicious pizza at Your Pie. So many items to choose from and gelato for dessert. Wait staff are so accommodating. I'd recommend it to everyone. Reasonably priced, too. Grand Opening is Friday, May 12th.
Loved Your Pie! I tried it for the first time last night and was pleasantly surprised by how fresh the ingredients tasted and how fast my pizza came out. I tried the whole wheat crust and it was delicious! The owner/manager came up to our table and was very helpful and friendly as was all the staff. They even have gelato which looked amazing. Didn't try it on this visit but definitely will on the next.
The place is clean and small enough for your family. I loved the vegan pizza. Also, I was able to create my own pie. Hence the name 'Your Pie'. All in all, I don't have any complaints. The kicker is that it doesn't take much time to prepare. Love it!
Staff was a tad offputting with whatever inside joke they had going on but the food was GREAT! Bbq Chicken pizza. Fast service at 12pm on a Saturdat. Very clean!
Today was the first time I've ever eaten at your pie I've got to say I am not disappointed this place was very spacious clean food was cooked perfectly bathrooms were nice you can customize a pizza the way you want it you can have a large side or a small slice I have kids menu a wide selection and different varieties plus tables outside I will definitely be returning in the future
My daughter and I met my husband here for lunch during his work day. They made the food very fast and the staff was all super friendly. There was very little wait even though it was lunch time. The building was brand new so it was super clean and well kept. The menu had a great selection of choices and the cost is reasonable. Each person can eat for under $10 in most cases. I like that they offer salads along with pizza and panini because I am not always in the mood for pizza even thought my daughter is. The food was really good and we will be going back often! My daughter, who is a very picky eater, said this is her new favorite pizza in town. I recommend trying it for yourself. it is well worth it.
The food is made from scratch right in front of you. The red sauce had a nice tangy bite to it.
Very good service and the pizza is delicious! Im pretty picky with pizza and I would totally come back here again.
Great pizza, quick to order and receive. Definitely recommend to anyone wanting good pizza. Serving size is perfect.
Stop wasting your money on Pizza Hut, Domino's and the rest of them, this place is awesome.
Have become a repeat customer!
First of all, I wasn't expecting my pizza to be as good as it was! I had a 7inch grilled chicken and veggie pizza. My pizza was LOADED with veggies and just the right amount of chicken. I added marinara w/pesto. I drizzled olive oil on top, after it finished cooking.
Not to mention the PEACH PROSCIUTTO pizza, tastes like HEAVEN in a box!!! It has a peculiar flavor, but it’s DAMN GOOD!!!!!
Unfortunately I have to travel to Jacksonville often now for treatments at the Mayo Clinic, but I will look forward to visit Your Pie. Thank you for putting a smile on my face, after receiving not so good news today!
Was excited to see this location finally open! We have been to other similar "make your own personal pizza" type restaurants, and we couldn't wait to try this one. I loved the brick oven cook on my all meat pizza. We got the meal deal with the gelatto, which was amazing! A tad on the pricey side, but worth every penny :-) The crust wasn't too thick, which was nice. Service was great as well, very friendly and let us sample the gelatto before deciding which flavors we wanted. We will be back!
Great pizza pie. Loved the ability to personalize it to my taste. The crust was thin and perfectly baked. If you like thin crust pizza you will enjoy their pizza. The place was busy but no one waited very long.
Great experience, will definitely be back. My 3 year old son and I had a lunch date here and it was fun for him to get to see his pizza baked in a fire grill and have a whole mini pizza for himself so he could build it however he wanted. I was very pleased with the 2 gentlemen that helped us and most importantly the food was awesome too. Thanks for a fun date with my little man.
Here in the area from Dallas, TX (for business). Working next door. Popped in for an unexpected, AWESOME pizza. My first time here, and John (owner) walked me through the process. Perfectly prepared pizza; offered in a very clean establishment!!! What more does one want? Thanks, again, John!!
THE BEST PIZZA IN JACKSONVILLE. Same price for any toppings you want, the size is perfect and very filling. You could easily have half for lunch and half for dinner. I always ask for mine well done, love it crispy!
New management and it was great! I ordered 10 pizzas (most gluten free & 1 vegan) and Eli was able to complete my order without a problem Saturday morning for my child’s fifth birthday celebration. Everyone loved it and it was plenty for a group of 19 adults and kids. I paired it with Greek salad, finger foods, and paleo cupcakes. Eli was professional and responded to my emails.
So glad to have found this place, my go to for GF pizza.
I really like this chain. I have a son with food allergies, so this is a great place. I'm always up front about them and check for cross contamination. However, after the pizza was done cooking, one of them used a community slicer on my son's pizza. I was in a hurry today, so I didn't make a big deal about it. Just something to watch for. My son's allergies aren't so much severe as broad.
This location was really great! Friendly staff took my order and built my pizza like a well-oiled machine! Restaurant was clean and efficient. I almost didn't give this location a try after a lackluster experience at another location in a diffet state - but in glad I did, everything was great and the staff so friendly.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes