Probably the best pizza I have ever had in my life and the staff is filled with beautiful people.
The owner had only just met us and felt like he was family by the end of our visit!
Thank you for being so kind to us
Love,
Your friends from the Sunday forest hills Greenmarket ❤️❤️❤️
I ve been eating here for a few years. And I just wanted to write a review finally. I have been getting there chicken cutlet hero’s probably 1-2x per month and it has always been excellent. There staff calls me by name and extremely polite. This place is a must if ur in the area. I’ve tried several other things including there pizza. And it’s all amazing. Worth the stop. Great food and great service
When you walk in, it's a little dated, but the food is very good and reasonably priced
One of the best plain cheese slices you’ll ever have. Garlic knots are the right amount of soft and gooey. Prices are great. 20 out of 10. Never change
went to take my kids to hicks and we were looking for a pizzeria... my family has owned pizzerias in the past and I'm certain critical. THIS PLACE KNOWS HOW TO MAKE PIZZA. PIZZA IS SUPPOSED TO BE CRUNCH NOT FLOPPY. Cooked perfectly. Old school! Great service also.
Not wasting my time anywhere else. THIS IS REAL PIZZA
Great pizza! Cooked to perfection especially the bottom of the crust. Need to go back to try more 🙂
Great pizza - try the BBQ Chicken pizza slice!
The pizza was very good they have a wide choice of places to choose from and Specialty dishes customer service is excellent good place for the family
The sauce is very good. My granddaughter ordered mozzarella sticks were delicious. We had Sicilian pizza and it was very good. Just the way we like it light crust.
We've never had a bad pizza experience here, eat in or takeout. It's further than our local place but worth the trip.
I come here before or after work from time to time, overall the pizza is solid, however their Sicilian slice in particular is one of the best I've ever had! I would give it 4.5 if I could. 10 dollar minimum for credit so make sure you have cash if you only want a couple slices!
Worth noting:
Service is very friendly and restaurant is fairly quiet.
Their pizza and other dishes are really good.
The buffalo pizza is kinda hit or miss. They could probably add bigger chunks of meat but it's still good.
The regular slices are often greasy. Not so happy about those.
The garlic knots are great but can use more garlic sauce.
They're pretty fast too.
My first time coming here with some friends. Calm and quiet spot.
Pizza was 9/10.
Food was very tasty. So nice to come across a good pizzaria. Dine-in 29 bucks for 2 adults. Half order of delicious Penne Al Vodka sausage slice, buffalo slice and a Sicilian. 2 drinks. Everything was very good. Please a must try. Pasta was so good I wasn't sharing!
Their pizza top tier my dudes. From the savory dough the heavenly sauce and I don't even need to compliment their cheese cause all you need for is taste it and you won't want to have a slice from anywhere else ( save a few notable exceptions). their lasagna is good too.
Their pizza is the best tasting pizza within 20 miles of Westbury! Pizzas on display look fresh and not like petrified cardboard. I stopped at Gino's of Carl Place 1st, walked in, looked at their old petrified cardboard pizzas on display and walked right out and drove to Mama's in Jericho! I usually order a white slice because I'm not a fan of tomato sauce (even on my pasta) but for some reason i ordered their regular slice and Sicilian...my God! The "sauce" on the Sicilian was DELICIOUS! It was sweet and not acidic! The crust was crispy and slice was thick and soft also. The regular slice was also delicious. So, i never get regular slices with sauce and never EVER get Sicilian BUT, from now on at Mama Felicia's, it's Sicilian ALL DAY!!! YUM!!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes