As fresh as it gets. No frills just tasty food! As the other reviews said the lobster roll lived up to the hype! Crab cake sandwich also hit the spot. Setup is like a convenience store. Walk in check out all the fresh fish, caviar, drinks, etc. If you see something fresh in the case they can prepare it for you. There's also a menu hanging on the wall to order from. There are only 2 seats inside and the rest of the seating is outside. Once you place your order they will bring it outside to your table. Then it's time to dig in and enjoy. Everything you need is outside: napkins, condiments, ice cold water, etc. Plenty of shade and fans outside to keep you cool. Saved them in my favorite list because I'll be back.
The best place for Fish in Key west. I am super picky about the fish I eat. This place checks all the boxes. Everyday locally caught fresh fish is brought in. The selection isn’t big and I like that. The people who work here are terrific. They take the time to help you make the right selection. I’ve had black and red grouper blackened and they were both incredibly delicious. The locally caught shrimp are large and awesome. You can get tacos with either corn or flower tortillas. I don’t think people realize how good fresh fish can be. The own Damen is a stand up guy whe is doing the right thing.
Thank you!🍤🐡🎣🐠🐟
I have a new favorite spot in key west! The absolute best shrimp rolls, hands down. So fresh and tasty, it stays on the mind long after you finish. I had the conch fritters as well and they were beyond delicious. I returned the next day to make sure I tried the crabcake croissant and that didn't disappoint either. Tha patio outside was cool and clean which is a big plus considering the heat. Staff was friendly and service was very fast. It's a must the you stop here if you are in key west!!!
Pricy as advertised but also the food was as fresh as it gets. For 2 orders of shrimp tacos and a beer was about $50 bucks. With that being said, they tasted absolutely delicious. Whats very cool about this place too is that when you order your food, you are basically picking what you want from the raw cuts in the Market. Cool experience and worth a try.
Best lobster roll in town 🙌
Lots of lobster meat. Nothing extra. Not much mayonnaise. Very, very fresh!!! ❤️
We had lunch here and was pretty decent!
Lobster sandwich was decent but little over priced.
Tuna sandwich was literally tasted like the canned but not sure.
Shrimp Taco was pretty good 👍🏻 wish there were three instead of two 😋
Building itself is cute, neat, and unique restaurant. It has a good atmospheric view and mood👌🏻
I'm a big Crab lover and Key West did not have any in the restaurants until.....I ran into Eston Street Seafood Market & boy was I surprised.....I was so happy! 😋 Yum Yum!!
The scallops and lobster roll were delicious. We ordered 2 lobster tails, and they forgot them on the grill, so they were overcooked. I'm sure if they were cooked correctly, they would have been delicious as well.
Eaton Street Seafood Market is a culinary gem in Key West. This restaurant is nothing short of spectacular, offering an array of mouthwatering delights, including amazing lobsters, delicious clam chowder, and much more.
The lobsters at Eaton Street Seafood Market are truly outstanding. Cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor, they are a must-try for seafood enthusiasts. The clam chowder is equally delightful, offering a warm and comforting bowl of goodness.
The restaurant itself provides a cozy and inviting ambiance, making it a perfect place to enjoy a memorable meal. The staff is attentive and friendly, ensuring an exceptional dining experience.
If you're in Key West and looking for a restaurant with amazing seafood, including lobsters and clam chowder, Eaton Street Seafood Market is the perfect choice. It's a five-star destination that I can't recommend enough!
Delicious food. Seat yourself. You order inside at the counter. We shared the spinach artichoke dip, conch chowder, and crab cake sandwich. Easy walking distance from Duvall St. Food was a tad on the salty side. Laid back outdoor seating. Neighborhood street parking.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes