Pvs Phone
Was passing threw town so read there reviews people said the Italian Beef was great. So I thought I would give it a try. Overall it was okay. The beef slices were sliced thicker than I'm use to seeing on a Italian Beef. It tasted okay a little chewy because the beef was cut thicker. Would have again if I was in the area but, I would likely try other Italian dishes on the menu or maybe try the pizza.
Carolyn Graves
Delicious! So hard to decide, but went with the Big Bruno sandwich and a RC! So yummy! My daughter loved the tortellini and my husband inhaled the Italian beef pizza with giardiniera. Very friendly staff, can't wait to go back and try something new!
Jennifer Samuels
Their pizza is awesome. We have a large family and each time we have ordered the 24in pizza we have always had some left over. Another plus is that they are open till 1am when no one else is. Also their pasta is great as well. I recommend you trying their food. The staff is always polite and nice too.
Mara Jackson
Was visiting the area and it was late. The place I was staying (Holiday Inn - Grand Geneva) recommended Mama Cimino's Pizza Delivery. The Pizza was delivered on time, but they had forgotten my ranch that I had requested. They made it right very quickly by bringing me the ranch and gave me some of my money back (despite my trying to argue) and apologized profusely. Top notch customer service! I will order again if I am ever back in the area. So refreshing to see a business care for their patrons. Thank you so much!
Chris Starkey
Not impressed. Ordered 2 hurricanes and the stuffed pizza was significantly burned. How does the cook let that pass on a $45 dollar pizza?! Should've paid by credit card but they requested cash. Lesson learned
Tom Smith
If it's late, everything else is closed and you absolutely have to eat... i would go to McDonald's or wait for breakfast.
The pizza is nasty. Sorry, I'm used to pizza with flavor. This place is worse than the typically bad midwest pizza. To you people saying the pizza was excellent... I'm sorry that you've never had good pizza to compare to. Either that or you were too drunk to realize how bad it was.
The calamari was a joke(see pic). For $12, i expect something other than overcooking the cheapest bag of frozen food you can find. Yes, that pic is really what we got for $12!
The cheese curds could have been okay, but they overcooked them with the calamari. It was just hardened breading.
I tried this place before and it was just not good. This time it was bad enough to complain about.
Fiona
We are staying nearby and decided to give them a try. Their food is awesome! And very hearty! The margherita stuffed crust will probably last us three days ☺️. We'll stop by again the next time we're in the area.
G Amettis
The Chicken Wings are huge and Very Good.
The Pasta Pizza will feed 5 (Lg) to 10 (XLg) people.
The Baked Rigatoni w/ Mozzarella (My Favorite)
The Sausage Roll is like a Pizza Kringle...Yum.
As hard as people are trying to get back to normal, we need Respect and Dignity to help heal. The food here is very good from hard working people.
B Ruce Wayne
We come to Lake Geneva to have a mini vacation. I Google local pizzas and decided to try this place. I ordered takeout to take back go hotel. Was greeted by friendly staff who explained how the sauce was made and offered a water while I waited. Let's just say, the pizza we had, each bite was worth it. You won't be disappointed. Great taste and great price. We will have to make special trip back just for the pizza!!!!!
Lori Cagney
On vacation strolling around Lake Geneva went into a local bookstore asked the guy behind the counter where we could get some good pizza and gave us directions to Mama Cimino's. Walked in sat down greeted by a very nice guy. Had the place to ourselves, pizza was fantastic. Friendly staff. Would come back.
Igor Zapadinsky
Awesome! Best pizza and best taco ever! Expensive yes, but worth it. We are very happy!
Jessica Floren
I really liked it. We had wings and stuffed pizza. The wings were good, not the best I've ever had but they were alright. The pizza was amazing and at a price you just cannot beat. BUT, what I really loved is that I have finally found a stuffed pizza joint with Sobe Lifewater :-) Cha-Ching!!! You've got my business Mama ;-) Can't wait to go again and try the pasta. Yeah, that's right, they have pasta too... Mmmmmmm
Vanessa Nicosia
They just said an XL pizza "wasn't worth their time for delivery" they may consider it if we add more food to our order?! I will not give these jagoffs another penny.
Tammy Jorgensen
We loved the food. It was our first visit and we will come back for sure. The pizza and breadsticks with red sauce is amazing. Very pleased!
Vinny Cimino
The best pizza and wings around very clean place and owners very nice!
Chip Hinds
Really enjoyed the pizza . Servers young, what can you expect.
I'll eat their again .
Kris L. Bunnell
I grew up on Ciminos pizza so happy to know I will not have to drive to Freeport to get my Ciminos fix. Just wish we could get them to Janesville/Milton so that way I can have it whenever instead of driving 30-45 minutes.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes