When I think of NY pizza, this is the ideal that I’m looking for. Great crust with just the right amount of crisp. Delicious sauce. The perfect amount of cheese. And plenty of extra topping options for when you’re craving a little more than a basic slice. Round or square, it’s all really good here.
This place was reasonably priced and very filling. I had 2 chicken slices with some tangy sauce on it. They were delicious I easily could have eaten the pie. They have so many choices to choose from I will definitely have to come back here again to try another slice or 12. They were very profession
Amazing pizza place, everytime we go to the mall we stop by to grab a slice. Went in a couple days ago to grab my son a slice and they we’re closing out and they ended up give me a couple of different slices to take home which was really nice of the employee. Please go try there pizza i would really
Pete was a great help ! We ordered 1 regular 1 pepperoni and a chicken roll. 🤤 everything was delicious but I’m still thinking about chicken roll.
I also can’t wait to try those Buffalo knots 🍴
I know this sounds crazy, but I think the best pizza on long island is in the food court of a smith haven mall.
Lets start with the food. The ultimate test of any pizzeria is the plain slice and these guys got it right, enough said. Beyond that, the daily specials are unique and each day is better
Honestly, this place has some of my favorite pizza. The honey pep pizza is amazing and the buffalo knots are great too. If I lived closer to the mall I honestly would get this a lot more.
The best!! The people that work there are really just the nicest ever! They had a leftover pie at closing time and they gave it to us for FREEEEEE! No one does stuff like that anymore! You can tell the gentleman working there is truly an honest and hardworking man. Just great people making great pi
Pizza is always fresh any tasty. Owners and workers are extremely nice. Amazing place :) creative and beautiful flavors with a wide variety of options for any style. Best Sicilian slice Ive ever had and the uncle Benny is a must
This place has the potential of being an excellent pizza shop. The first time I tried a regular slice is was crisp, tasty and well enjoyed. The second time not so much. It was soggy even after I asked for it to be cooked well done. Time will tell.
The only food place at the mall with good food service, the staff are beyond amazing. So nice, especially the girl with colored hair is super nice and polite.
Great quality pizza amazing staff Georgie is the man great atmosphere here very helpful as well and informative with telling me of other location that are more convenient for me.
Not only is this places pizza delicious but they have great service. Nothing better then service with a smile and a delicious slice. Hope everyone else enjoys as much as my family and I did.
One of my favorite spots to go to whenever I was on break working at macys. The pizza was banging and it was always full of flavor. The workers were very friendly and would always listen. If you’re a macys employee they give 15 percent off which was nice. I will definitely be coming back here and wi
Best deal in the food court, I've never had spicy Buffalo garlic knots like they have here,but I have had about everything slice here and there all amazing
My son and I stopped by to grab a slice last night. It was the end of the night and they were super nice as we pondered which yummy slice to choose. Tried something outside our usual choices and it was fantastic!
Not only the most delicious slice of pizza I’ve had but the best customer service. Brian and James were sooo nice and helpful! I’m so happy The Pizzeria is in this mall!!
Best pizza around. The chicken roll is to die for.
Had to try the new place in the food court and they DID NOT DISAPPOINT! They had several varieties of awesomeness that I can't wait to come back and try. Today, I had the Thai Chicken Chili slice and it was amazing. Just the right amount of heat and such a unique flavor. The more traditional options
I have to agree with the other reviewer who said
have the best pizza on Long Island. I’ve only had the grandma slice and a margarita slice my second time here. This pizza is absolutely delicious.it’s true you would never expect to find such great tasting pizza at a food court.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes