Review Maddy's Mexican Restaurant - Lake Hiawatha

Everything was so flavorful! The tortilla soup was amazing, I tasted so many great flavors. Great portions for the price as well. Great authentic Mexican cuisine. The staff was very kind as well.

First time here with a group. Every single dish we had like the mole and birria quesadillas were excellent. Literally tasted almost like my mom's cooking. Music was on point. The customer service was great. We really enjoyed our time here.

Nopales con chorizo, mole carnitas chimi, tacos de birria were all super tasty. Will be back!

This has been a great local go to for quite a long time now! The staff is always so friendly and the food is always delicious! If you get a chance to try their birria tacos, do it!!

My hubby and I went there for quesadillas and tex mex enchalladas, they were delicious! It was made promptly and Karla was the best! She was extremely thorough, accommodating and nice! The rice was so soft and flavorful - best Mexican Resturant in the area for SURE!!! Don’t miss out!!!!!

The food is EXCELLENT. One of the best restaurants in Parsippany/lake Hiawatha. Whether you dine in or get it delivered the quality is always amazing. Highly recommend.

Pleasantly surprised how amazing this place was. Hole in the wall but man the food was amazing. Fresh. Nothing felt heavy. Packed with flavor. Will be back for sure !! Thank u

Delicious food, generous portions, and great prices. Will definitely come back.

This is the best mexican food i have had in a while. The tacos are phenomenal and the churros are so good as well. I definitely recommend this place if you are looking for a mexican restaurant. I will for sure be back!

Amazing, delicious food! Absolutely recommend! Their salsa is fresh and crisp, and the menu is mouthwatering. Large portions for a great price, it is BYOB. Parking is limited though, you might have to parallel and walk a little but it's completely worth it. I've never had delivery from here since I love the atmosphere so much, I always eat there!

Like what the new owners have done to the menu. Most of the dishes look to be the same as what the former restaurant (Maddy's) served but they have added their own twist on some and added some new dishes as well. We tried some of are standard dishes and were very happy with the changes to them. Both the rice and the beans are different and we were very happy with the changes. Their guacamole seemed to be a little simpler then what we were use to but was still fresh and tasty. Only complaint is they only included one bag of chips with our order which consisted of Enchiladas, Quesadillas and a large guacamole. The chips were gone before we even got through half the guacamole. Maddy's would have included 3 bags of chips with the order. Still a great place for good Mexican food.

Great food and great friendly people!!! Would bring all my friends and they would leave very happy with this family owned and operated restaurant

Small but cozy. Big portion of the food. The service is also very friendly.

Food is authentic, service is excellent ambiance is good and prices are cheap,

Good food and nice service, could have been. More tastier.

Absolutely fantastic. I ordered via door dash for the first time tonight. And I am completely and udderly blown away. Everything is and was spot on! It was like one of mi amigos Madres just cooked for me in their kitchen. I will definitely be visiting in person time and time again Damn that was yummy. Well done Maddy's well done !!!

Food came out quickly and fresh! Taco salad was very crispy (bit too much lettuce imo) but chicken was cooked perfectly. Chicken burrito with fries was super tasty