Catalina's on Orange has two sides, a pizzeria and a "lounge" area where you can sit for dinner. The drinks were on point and food was outstanding, so why was this place next to empty on a Saturday night in Lancaster when every other restaurant was packed? Service - I think only two people were working there. If you have time to kill hit this place up but with one waitress/bar tender and one cook/server, things were happening pretty slowly. Both employees were extremely nice and seemed to be making the best of the situation. Only fell short because of the time.
Tried many different things on the menu... They are all good! No complaints! Lots of craft beer on tap :)
Great place great food you get what you pay for here. Great atmosphere and very relaxed setting.
Accidently wandered into this gem thinking it was an average Italian joint. Was completely wrong. The aesthetics of the place was great along with their service. Food was gourmet and although the wait for our food was longer than desired, it came out hot and delicious! Will definitely come here again!
You ever like one single item on a menu so much that's why you go there? Well that's this place and its wings. I had the opportunity to get a gyro in the middle of Central Market and instead I stopped in her for lunch. The wings themselves are so good they get the entire restaurant a five-star rating.
I love it here! I came for brunch once with my family and yes, the waffles were slightly dry but the service was amazing and the pizza is great! I definitely suggest getting the fresh made margarita pizza!
such a friendly staff & amazing food. my GF & i ate there on a sat eve. we had mussels. the sausage tomato sauce was excellent! calamari was world class. she had greek shrimp pasta. great. i had a corned beef sandwich w slaw on rye. huge. & perfect. we may have found our new go to spot for quick, great food downtown
Great place to hang out, play billiards or darts, friendly staff and food is good as long as you aren’t expecting healthy. Catalina’s has two sides to it, a sports bar restaurant and a dance club. Reviewing the restaurant side only, I’ve eaten pepperoni pizza - thin crust, loaded with cheese - and chicken Alfredo- tasty sauce, pasta good and chicken very flavorful.
My favorite part is the darts/billiards room. It’s well-lit, games are well-maintained and it’s spacious enough even when all games are being used.
Jeff the bartender is nice friendly chap, will remember you after a visit or two.
The service was excellent. Our waitress was friendly and gave great suggestions. The owners even stopped by to check in.
The food was not the best in Lancaster. The desert was chewy and dry, and the lamb didn't have much flavor.
The food is really good! I love their ceaser dressing, you can definitely tell its was homemade. Good gourmet pizza too! The chicken pesto was sooo cheesy Prices aren't that bad either, glad there is another option around here besides HOP
Had an absolutely delicious dinner. Was surprised at how few people were there. Staff said most people think of the later nightlife and aren't aware of the dinner quality. They should! It was fantastic!
First time going to this establishment was yesterday ,and I had a blast...
My first thoughts about this place was based on other's experiences so I was highly hesitant to go...
But my experience was awesome...
I will definitely be making a trip maybe a few more back to Catalina's...
Now I want people to understand that we are living in Lancaster City ,and there are many who enjoy going out to a club already prepared to create a rucus...
Lancaster needs this...We need spots we can go to that we can enjoy...
I'm a lover of 80's Rock , I love going to spots where they at least incorporate some rock into the music mix , I don't do the Spanish Club scenes but in the end I had a beautiful time...
I would wish that everybody who would want to check this spot out do so because you want to...
Don't deny yourself a possible good time based on other's voices...
Owner was so nice and made sure we were all satisfied with our food and drinks.. if your looking for a Latin environment this is the place great Spanish music.. Saturday is Latin night
Wow, I was pack, but O was told it just open this summer. The music(DJ), people, and security were on point. The dronks prices were normal. I love the place and the fun energy it has. I looking forward to return there once I move back to Lancaster City.
Excellent food, clean and friendly establishment.. Best pizza we had for a long time, uses fresh ingredients. Will recommend to all our friends.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes