I ordered shrimp parmesan and it was superb! Excellent sauce and 7 jumbo, jumbo shrimp in the dish. Then I ordered a specialty ice cream (spumoni surrounding a generous portion of cherries, then covered with a chocolate shell and a side of whipped cream) Definitely returning. I came home with enough for 2 more meals as the parm dish also came with a generous side of pasta. Casual relaxing atmosphere with a very friendly staff. Mrs. Pal Joey even called me Mrs. Presley as I admired the Elvis décor on one of the walls. Her and I have both been to Graceland. I saw him in concert, and when I was in 2nd grade, he was definitely the man I was going to marry!!! Definitely give this place a try!
Really nice little restaurant. ... we had the fried zucchini and the portion was huge! The pizza is really tasty and the staff was friendly. Very clean too :) I have definitely found a new place to order pizza from. We even brought home Lasagna for Pops and he is sitting at the table eating it right now and raving about it.
Wonderful pizza! Just like it was at Pal Joeys on Forest Avenue on Staten Island. The crust was thin yet chewy, cheese was plentiful and sauce was not acidic with just the right amount on the pie. Not oily or too dry, just perfect! Can’t wait to try the rest of the other menu items!!!
10 inch personal pizza with sausage topping was delicious!!
Linguine with white claims sauce was best I ever had!!
Baked Rotini with eggplant or sausage is excellent!!
Our favorite Italian place in town! The pizza is incredible! Eddie makes the best ribeye hands down! Always great service and the owners are super friendly!! We love to support a family owned/run business🙌
Eddies made from scratch lemon sauce for the chicken was Amazing. I was literally drinking it with a spoon!
Was so excited when we saw they were moving to the neighborhood. They have not disappointed us. Thin crust pizza is great. Linguine and white clam sauce is amazing! Portions are generous to say the least. Hope they stay for a very long time!
Pizza and pasta dishes are As Good As It Gets at Pal Joey's. Food is all homemade and cooked to order linguine and clams in the white sauce is the best I ever had
Food is always Fresh and Amazing ! Wait times can be a little longer than other pizza places but well worth the wait.
They have great food glad to welcome t hem to the neighborhood eggplant parm is delish so are the calazones
Great menu and atmosphere. Met one of the owners and so nice. They toss the pizza right in front of you. Pizza and calamari were awesome!!
Madeline Carnevale Nesci
+5
Love the pizza. Just like NY pizza. We will get it again
Yuck. Rather not. Never again. Would rather have not had dinner. Publix looks better all the time. Consistency
![4]( "Recensione")
I went here for lunch. The person who took my order was extremely friendly and accurate. The flavors were very good but if the execution was better I would have been able to enjoy the Cheesesteak more . The sandwich was delicious but was just hard to eat. And I believe it was made with care but using a better hoagie roll that could stand up to all those delicious ingredients and care would have made the difference. I am definitely going back. Very solid experience. I thank you and your wonderful staff. Delicious food that may be a little messy isn't a big deal. The big deal is that the food is delicious. Thank you again I will be back. I normally don't do reviews because I believe most unfortunately are unfair and describes a singular experience good or bad . But to be fair is a rather rare occasion. I believe you have to go to a place more than once but the fact that I am willing to go back speaks volumes about my personal experience. I am from the Philadelphia area and I found your Cheesesteak comforting and full of flavor. Thanks again.
Staff are very nice, they are from New York, and actually know what a cheeseburger sub is. We had to drive an hour to find one, and it was worth it. The prices are very affordable and great for what you get. We tried a slice of pepperoni pizza too and it was great. Overall loved the food and the decor. 11-3 they have great lunch specials. We'll be back.
Family time at City Nights Pizza.
We had a wonderful time. Treated with kindness and sweetness. The Waitress was very attentive.
Not to mention the food is yummy 😋
Pizza pie & Eggplant Parmesan. Garlic knots so delicious.
And also, delicious Cherry and Strawberry slices of cheesecake 😋
Everything is good here... I happen to love their wings. But the chicken parmesan is also excellent. Come try it out. Enjoy😋
Awesome food!! Very very good! We will be back, next time in person! The food smelled delicious and tasted even better!!!! Well done!!
I frequent Pal Joey's and have been for four years now. The new owner Billy is doing an amazing job! The chicken parm tonight was awesome and the cheesecake I have to say was probably the best I have ever had and I have had a lot of cheesecake! Keep up the good work! #great job
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes