Cynthia Field-Torcasso
+5
Visiting from NC and stopped in to grab some breakfast pastry and their Famous Crannolis. Everything we had was fabulous and fresh. Definitely worth the visit. We can't wait to make the trip back!
First time there to get Irish soda bread. Was the most delicious I’ve EVER had. Probably one of the most delicious things I’ve ever eaten! Everything in there looked amazing & it smelled delicious! I’m now a loyal customer.
Catherine Hock Lamberti
+5
I absolutely recommend this bakery the baked goods are always fresh and delicious its worth a ride from wherever you live. I've been to other bakeries in and around town and had gotten stale cakes so I only go to sweet surrender a must for great service and fresh everything.
I have never been disappointed with anything I have bought here. Just had the Lemon Meringue Pie for the first time and it was the best I ever had..
Ellen Schuff Kornrumpf
+5
This is downright the best bakery on Long Island. Their scones are to die for. Everything I have ever had from here is just delicious!!
Elizabeth Sidote Brody
+5
1st time there Loved it Definitely will be going back. Apple pie was awesome .Italian Bread
Hot out of the oven
Best Italian cookies on the island !! Great assortment
Love sweet surrender! Delicious and beautiful cakes!
Elizabeth Costa Hernandez
+5
We ordered a birthday cake for my son and we asked if they could draw Kermit the frog on the cake. It came out amazing and it was delicious!! Thank you so much!! The Oreo filling was amazing too!!
Amazing service and cakes are out of this world! Must call ahead for custom cakes. From the cookies to cannoli be prepared to be in shock and awe!
Best bakery on long island. There is not one thing that wehave tried that we didn't like.
Sooooo good!!! Glad I found you! I recommend everything haha
Sweet surrender has made my son's baptism cake and first birthday cake. They do amazing work and everything tastes great. I've gotten a variety of things from here and it's all wonderful.
Ordered my god sons Blaze bday cake and it was not only beautiful it was delicious ..many thanks
My favorite bakery! I make a trip for a dozen donuts and I always end up buying 10 other items because there is always something new to try. And it's always Delicious!!!!
Rainbow Cookie Cake!!! Had it for my daughters birthday and everyone was asking for seconds. Amazing
Bought a New York Cheesecake today. It was the best cheesecake I've ever had! Great job.
Everything is delicious! I love their holiday themed cakes.
Watched on Fox News excellent
Thank you for the amazing cake that was made for my Godson's first birthday! The Curious George decor was so cute and the cake tasted great! We all enjoyed it, including the birthday boy! :-)
I stopped for some donuts, and the woman working was very friendly. It is very hard to find good bakeries on Long Island, and this place has many Italian favorites. Delights your senses when you enter. 🎂🍩🍡🍰
I went to this place for something swweeeet! I really wanted to get a donut but my stomach started talking to me and said hey Mike leave the donut and take the cannoli! The lady behind the counter suggested the cannoli filled donut. I looked at her in disbelief and said " a cannoli filled donut Shirley you can't be serious " she said" I am serious and don't call me Shirley "! I said ok bought 2 and the rest was history! The cannoli cream with the chocolate frosting and the flavor of the donut all came together very nicely and tasted delicious! But I wanted to save the other one for tomorrow. To make sure my other donut is safe tonight theres only one place to keep it, under my pillow! And if anyone in my house gets sticky fingers I'll be sleeping with one eye open! Sweet Surrender Bake House and staff are awesome go there and get something swweeeet!!!
Got our Too Good To Go surprise bag last night. A dozen assorted donuts and other stuff plus two loaves of bread, one with sesame seeds and one plain. Just great.
We ordered a black out birthday cake for my son-in-law and it was delicious! Everyone raved about the cake and wanted to know where we ordered from!
My daughter ordered a Rainbow cake, cupcakes & filled pastries for her dad & my Anniversary.
I’m not a lover of rainbow cookies etc but your cake was sensational as were the creamy cupcakes and pastries!
My other daughter & son-in-law raved about everything as well!
We will be ordering from you whenever we need desserts.
Congratulations on your wonderful desserts!
One of the best bakeries on Long Island. Delicious canolli donut..not to mention tiramasu, exclaims, napoleons...this list goes on and on..
If you havent had a crannoli, you have to try it! It's a cronut (croissant donut) with cannoli filling and topped with cannoli chips. The strawberry Cheesecake cronnoli is absolitely delicious! Their cakes are beautiful and whimsical. The staff is very friendly and helpful. The prices are fair for what you receive.
The is street parking in the front, and there's a small parking lots inbetween the pizzeria and south of the border restaurant.
It’s so nice to find a good bakery!
We needed a treat for my niece, she loved the cookies with sprinkles.
Best Jelly Dounuts you will ever have, Again! The Best Jelly Dounuts EVER!!! Period!!!!
Great bakery and friendly staff. Its soo great that they have sugar free options as well!
My family and I love this bakery! It's our go-to for birthday cakes. Everything is always delicious and fresh. The woman that works there are always nice! I highly recommend this bakery.
Can I buy everything? Many delicious baked treats to choose from. Great customer service and delicious baked goods.
Picked up a too good to go bag. Excellent donuts, cupcakes and bread/rolls!
If you are into sweets, this is your place! They also offer coffee in the mornings and carry a variety of baked goods, including assortment of bread loafs.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes