Sluurpy > Restaurants in Manhattan > Aj's New York Pizzeria

Aj's New York Pizzeria - Manhattan - Photo album

The first time I went to AJs I was not impressed and didn't return for a long time. What a mistake. I have to say this is my favorite pizza place in Manhattan. Their ingredients are fresh. The menu has a large array and my sons really enjoy any pizza we get. Their favorite is the buffalo wing pizza.

Good place and setting. Can choose to eat inside or out. Pizzas, pastas and calzones are create your own. Few choice of things to eat but plenty of ingredients!

Great garlic knots. You could taste they are hand made and the pizza was amazing.

The pizza and atmosphere here are great. Crust is nice and crunchy, but may be too hard for some by the time you get to the end of the slice. Pizza comes out piping hot, I love it like that, but be prepared to let it cool some. Allegedly Monday nights you can get 50 cent beers with your pizza, so if

I almost thought I was in Manhattan NYC the pizza was that good. Margarita 14” pie was perfect. High quality toppings, crust thin and crispy, cooked perfectly. Would most definitely recommend!

Never order from them. It is awful. Rude employees. Awful customer service. Worst pizza I have had in my life. Called and they told me to deal with it. Never ever order from them!!!!!!!

As someone from NY for me to actually like a place in KS is rare. But this pizza was delicious. Sauce is exactly how I want it. Cheese game on point. And crust is delicious. It’s worthy to be considered pizza in my opinion.

4 Garlic Knots- wasn’t impressed- basically tasted like knotted bread. Boneless Buffalo Chicken - very light covering of sauce. Chicken cooked fine. Pepperoni pizza 14” had extremely hard almost burnt crust with a lack of pepperoni for a 1 topping pizza. Very lackluster and won’t be trying again.