I called today and basically asked for a gyro pizza not only were they cool about my kinda odd request but the pie was perfect from the sauce to the lamb (which was ground not sliced, big plus) to using cornmeal instead of flour when they made the pie it was beyond expectations glad I tried a pizza shop in a gas station once again great pizza guys
Mike is so contagious...Always happy and upbeat. Just love going in and enjoying his gift for gab. He is beyond genuine. The pizza is always fresh and cooked to perfection. Super crisp on the bottom (corn meal) and the red sauce is the cats ass!!! We froze half a large because our eyes were way bigger then our tummies... we just reheated and eat- ed (lol) and the pizza was still fantastic! This pizza is remarkable. A must try!!!! You'll be a fan in no time!
Found this pizzeria while visiting UConn to attend special events. Pizza Mike's is the first pizza place that I know of which serves a lamb pizza. I gave it a try and it was outstanding--seasoned lamb, with feta cheese, tzatziki sauce and other ingredients made it one of the best pizza I have ever enjoyed! The family-owned service was excellent and very friendly. Well worth repeat visits!
The best service around, and the pizza is to die for!!! Tonight I ordered the Philly Steak and cheese but also asked for red sauce...OMG the best ever!!! Thanks for being so awesome guys!!!
Pizza Mikes pizzeria is just as good as the person who runs it, which is awesome. I've personally had the smoked salmon pizza and it's a game changer. It's the best pizza around CT. I highly recommend treating yourself and getting to know the incredible staff.
This Pizza is second to none and I’ve had a lot of pizza. Worth a trip from anywhere. Try the Lamb/Feta and baked potato pizza. They are my favorite... �
Today we tried the loaded baked potato pizza and a barbecue sauce based pizza with pineapple. Trust me when I say you've got to try barbecue pineapple pizza. It's the best!
I can't believe I just discovered you guys deliver to Coventry thanks to my neighbors! Not your average pizza.. I had "The American" and it was amazing, also sampled "The Cherico" and it was delicious! I love pizza and this was exceptional! Very friendly and you can tell the owner really cares! Nice to see places like this are still around! We will certainly be ordering again, can't wait to try others!
The BLT pizza is amazing, and so is the Philly Cheesesteak. My kids think the cheese pie is the best around. Plus, they deliver, which pretty much means I want to adopt them.
Ordered two large pizzas today for me and my coworkers, a twice baked potatoe, and chicken parm. They barely lasted an hour. Excellent pizza, incredible service from the guys. As an avid eater (see:fat guy) I can not recommend Pizza Mike's enough. I drove out from Manchester for pick-up, and will be doing it again soon. Thanks Mike and Dave!
You can tell that these pizzas arent just tossed together and thrown in a box. Each pizza on the menu is just as fantastic as the last. Order one and you will not be disappointed. Hands down best pie you can pick up around Storrs.
Totally love the food and service! Could not ask for more!
Nicest guys and best cheese pizza I ever had plus they deliver to me ��
Honestly the best pizza I've had while at UConn! Mike and David are both so friendly and make sure you're 100% satisfied. Will definitely be coming back
Even if my topping choices are outrageous! (Pesto, garlic, spinach, onion, anchovy)
By far the best pizza around, somebody give these guys a medal!
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten fresh in the vehicle. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a Margherita pizza. If I could I would rate this 4.5. It was good, plenty of cheese, garlic on the Margherita. But I felt the crust was undercooked and the sauce was just ok. On a scale from 0-10 I would rate this 7.8. It's a good score but a better crust would have put it over 8.
Fresh taste, balanced flavor, with a variety of options. Their large pizza, for $21, easily feeds three people; I really love their white based pizza. The staff are SUPER POLITE. I really recommend trying their food. Since they don't have that much of space to sit in, I personally prefer to take out their pizza for my parties.
I tried their pizza two years back and didn't like it. But recently my husband made me try it again and now this is my favourite pizza place in Storrs!
I grew up in a pizza metropolis in the Philadelphia area so I’m picky when it comes to pizza. Pizza Mike’s is the best in the area. It’s heavy on the cheese, toppings and everything is seasoned so well. Love the thin crust. Sauce flavor was on point. We will definitely be back.
Omg. Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had.
Super unique specialty pizzas like smoked salmon and potato… yeah. Sounds insane but it’s amazing.
This man loves making pizzas. No joke
I can’t make it out of the parking lot when I pick up without eating half a pie.
Yes. The pic is me two slices down in the parking lot writing this.
I’m thinking about kidnapping Mike ….😶
Love the pizza here!! Best pizza place local to Willington and they deliver!
That was really good… got a few different pizzas but the General Tsos Chicken one is such a great idea!
The FRIENDLIEST OWNER IN THE WORLD! Remembers his customers. And talks to us! Take out plus delivery. Inside gas/convenience store.
CLEAN.
SHORT WAIT.
GOOD PRICES
YUMMY DESSERTS
Just a few pizza choices. A small business owner...please patronize.
Offers a special meatball grinder soda thing that's good
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
I was pumping gas and was drawn in by the smell! The pizza is great, with very original and bizarre options (and you can also create your own of course). But by far the most outstanding feature is Dave. He was SO outstandingly friendly, cheery and helpful. What a great attitude, talking to him put me in a good mood!
I'm a carpenter from New Hampshire working in the area on an old house. I didn't bring lunch. So I ordered a pizza for delivery and got back to work. Before I knew it. The delivery driver was here. The pizza was hot and delicious. Will order again and recommend others to as well. Thanks Mike.
I love and miss Pizza Mike's. I went to UConn and lived up the road and used to get their pizza all the time. I enjoyed the variety of specialty pizzas they make. One of the delivery drivers helped me jump start my car in the parking lot when I was picking up a pizza one day. 10/10 love this place and I often contemplate the 1hour drive to go get pizza from them again.
"It's in a gas station so it must be disgusting" This is honestly some of the best pizza I've ever had. The guys (they're twins apparently) are extremely friendly and HILARIOUS. I highly recommend their pizza. A+
Great food. Such friendly service and great $$$. Definitely worth the trip.
Awesome tasting pizza and the mozzarella has one of the best flavors i have tasted. The dough was perfect.
First time trying and it wont be the last
Pizza arrived as ordered/hot and on time. Phone contact and delivery guy very pleasant. Pizza was delicious.
What a nice surprise to find in a gas station! We got two pizzas; both amazing, tasty, with lots of cheese and crispy.
Thank you Dave! You were amazing too!
Very impressed! We live on the Stafford/Willington line and they deliver to us (which is amazing because we have very few options for delivery). Every experience the staff has been nothing but wonderful and the pizza never disappoints! Highly recommend!
Pizza Mikes is a secret that needs to be let loose. We go about once a week and this has to be the best pizza in the area! I recommend the buff chicken pizza or the crab Rangoon. You probably think the latter is not something you would dare think, but it’s our favorite!
Great service, great pizza. This was my second visit to Mike's. The prices are very reasonable. I got a whole pizza and it lasted me 3 days. On day 3, it still tasted wonderful. Highly recommend!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes