Open til 10 on Sunday which is great if you coming from a long day of traveling the keys. Very comfortable atmosphere. Very nice staff. Dog friendly (brought a bowl of water for my dog without asking) Now the food was amazing from the garlic bread being soft and crispy with full of flavor, to the shrimp cocktail sauce being one of the best I’ve had in Florida. The entire meal was good even dessert.Everyone in my party said the food was good.I would definitely come back.
We went for an early dinner hoping for some decent Italian. I was a little worried as nobody was there. Helen was our waitress and she was amazing! I had yummy chicken parm and hubby had the lasagna. Both dishes were generous in size and better than expected. Took home tiramisu.., delicious! Every worker was very kind. We also learned the serve Nicaraguan food so we will be back tomorrow! Thanks Helen for an enjoyable experience!
Great service. Michelle was friendly and quick. Food was good. The only complaints, my husband's pasta with shrimp and lobster, the shrimp still had the tails on. So he had to pick through the pasta and get the tails off. Also salads were just a tiny plate with lettuce, carrots, and one cherry tomato.
Meatballs were delicious. My son said the lasagna was also amazing. Tiramisu was perfect. Oh and don't forget the garlic rolls.
We will be back.
We visited about a month ago, seeking a nice Italian dinner not too far from our hotel. Helen was our excellent server. The garlic notes are a great complimentary starter! My husband had the Veal Parmigiano and enjoyed it. I tried the hog fish special in a light (champagne? ) lemon cream sauce with kalamatta olives. It was great! There are also a few Mexican favorites sprinkled across the menu. Service was excellent, food was great. We will definitely eat here again next time we are in Marathon!
This place may be the most underrated in Marathon. 4 of us went and each was impressed. I had the special which was crab stuffed ravioli in vodka sauce. It was outstanding, homemade pasta.
"Update"
Was in town again so we had dinner here. It was as good as last time and our server Ellen was fabulous!
Food was amazing…service a bit gruff at times, but attentive and fast. The garlic rolls were soft and warm, a nice change from garlic bread. The conch chowder had big chunks of potato and carrots among the bits of conch and the flavorful broth. I was a bit leery ordering the octopus salad, but I loved it! The octopus was tender and the beans were swimming with flavor. Hubby ordered the grouper sandwich with fries and was happy with it. The menu is huge, so we will be back to try other items next year!
Overall nice restaurant. The food was very good. Service was somewhat slow, I don't understand why as they were not really busy. When we did get service it was very friendly. A good place to have a good meal no matter if it's seafood or italian.
We asked when we called if we needed reservations and were told yes , but when we arrived it was not busy so we were seated immediately. We ordered conch ceviche and it was so flavorful and fresh. We also ordered the fried shrimp platter and grouper francaise and they were amazing. The staff were attentive. This is definitely a place we will return too!
Grouper tacos were AMAZING! Ask for some hot Sauce ( it adds a perfect kick!)
Poseidon salad was great, the grilled chicken was ok, very thin. But I would absolutely get it again!
Staff was very welcoming, made a fresh hot pot of coffee for us.
We had dinner here service was good. Garlic roll is a must order. Shrimp pasta is good too not spicy as I thought.
This place is a gem. Only a few people were there when we arrived, so I was a touch worried. No need at all! Our waitress, Helen, was sweet and very attentive and helpful. The food was delicious, excellent, large quantity! We had shrimp cocktail -lovely! Both entrees were so good, the special Hogfish and Mahi mahi prepared fresh, so good! Everything came very quickly. I can't understand why there weren't more customers enjoying this place. Just go!
Had dinner here after a sunset cruise. Most places were packed so we chose Triton. Was skeptical at first because there was only 1 vehicle in the parking lot. Once we entered. We were greeted and seated. The restaurant atmosphere was very nice. Our waitress, Helen, was super nice. My husband had the hog fish with angel hair pasta and salad, I had the homemade meat lasagna with a salad. We also had the garlic rolls. It was a good portion. Everything was delicious! When we return for another vacation, we will definitely be going back.
The lasagna was delicious! I took everyone's advice and got the garlic rolls,they were yummy!!! Helen was a great server. The Tiramisu was good,but it didn't have enough coffee flavor.
Michelle our waitress was attentive, hard working & spot on with recommendations.
Calamari was so tender & batter was light! DELISH!
Now that's a Jersey Girl!
We'll be back...
We were on vacation looking for a bit of a change from the seafood/American food we'd been eating all week. This was the perfect answer! Sweet little place, looks like a hole in the wall from the outside but it's quaint. Food was really very good. We ate out practically every meal and had some good and bad experiences but this was one of the best! Excellent pasta dishes, we all had pasta and were all very satisfied. By far best service our whole trip! Since it's not very touristy we had it wasn't super busy on a Thursday evening. Definitely check this place out!
Had dinner there with my son. We both ordered specials. Extremely satisfied. Friendly people and met the chef. Thanks for a great experience.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes