Reviews The Oyster Society

5
Timothy C
+5
This place attracts a lot of customers and for all good reasons. So it's best to reserve beforehand. Now besides the most acceptable service and attention from the staff the food was the bomb 👌 my wife and I love oysters and they had a whole menu of oysters ranging from East Coast to West Coast . The bread alone was delicious with the side of butter it came with . The drinks were well crafted . Definitely coming back here.
4
Tom Nieradka
+4
Been here a few times now. Cocktails are great. Well made, use top shelf stuff, and the happy hour deal is ridiculous. Also good wine and beer selection. Food is mostly very good. A few items seem low effort for what you pay. Island skewers and pork belly come to mind, taste fine but are overpriced for what you get. Seafood is what to get here. Oysters are fresh, cooked seafood is all good. The steaks are more hit or miss, for what you pay I’d expect a better steak that was correctly trimmed with my surf and turf. Also was under seasoned and closer to rare than the med-rare I asked for. Would definitely be back, especially for happy hour. Just know what to order here.
5
Heather Vaquera
+5
10 out of 5 stars! This place is unassuming and although it doesn't have a water/beach front view the patio, bar and lounge provide a playful, sophisticated, welcoming atmosphere. Our food and drinks were top notch - everything from the sharable scallops, seasonal salad, potato crusted grouper, the pink lady sushi roll, wine and stone fruit sour cocktail were amazing. I wish I had 3 stomachs, so we could have eaten more food, drinks, coffee and dessert. Mmmm. When we come back to Marco this will be on the must visit list. Service was excellent - our server, the hostesses and manager were excellent. We thoroughly enjoyed our experience. Almost forgot to mention they are allergen conscious/knowledgeable and have plenty of delicious GF options that leave you feeling satisfied and like you're not missing out. Don't walk, run to (it's a must)! And they accept online reservations.
5
Jess
+5
Great food, attentive servers. Loved the atmosphere, and its a very cute place. Key Lime Pie was some of the best I've ever had. We dined here twice during our week in Marco.
5
Emily Foster
+5
We went here for my mom’s birthday and had such an amazing experience! We came for the happy hour at the bar first, great cocktails! And the hostess was so nice to point out an open table for us. Then we made reservations for dinner and had a bottle of Chardonnay, a Brie and apple chutney appetizer, a salad with watermelon, feta, pomegranate seeds, onions, avocados, and more! So delicious! And then filet for dinner! We were so stuffed but it was all so great! The ambiance, the service, the food! The staff even came out with a chocolate dessert and sang happy birthday to my mom. 10/10 would recommend!
5
Anthony Bonanni
+5
My favorite restaurant, period! We ate at Oyster Society three times during our week stay in Marco Island...twice for dinner and once for Happy Hour. The food and drinks are superb. Marcel is the best bartender on the island and beyond. Try the Mai Tai 1945, my favorite drink there. The oysters are as fresh, clean, and delicious as any I have had anywhere. The grilled grouper, snapper, and lobster Thermador are must haves. If you're in Marco Island, you MUST try Oyster Society. It's well worth the visit!
4
Marco Island Real Estate BROS
+4
Went for happy hour. Was disappointed that they didn’t have calamari. Fish & Chips and drinks for $9 a piece isn’t bad nowadays. Nice atmosphere!
5
Shana Morse
+5
Anna was an amazing waitress!! we had a party of 10 ppl. this place was awesome!! the atmosphere was perfect for our birthday celebration! the food was to die for!!
5
Mark Kukla
+5
Amazing place to eat seafood! The interior design is super cool and eclectic! Service is outstanding and very attentive. Food was prompt and delicious. They have complimentary valet parking otherwise parking is not easy. Several dining rooms to eat in along with outdoor dining. Highly recommend this place and the menu had a vast selection to choose from.
5
Michael
+5
If you have a group of 8, reserve the table in the wine room. Perfect! Everything about the OS is great.
Clicca per espandere