Overall experience was amazing. Had dinner around sunset time. View was amazing. Food is good. I ordered lobster roll but overall taste was 6.5/10. Lobster mac and cheese was good. I would highly recommend to visit around afternoon-night time. Prices are not cheap but mid-high range.
Overall, I would rate this place 4/5.
Food, ambiance, and service were 10 of 10! The place is cozy with some palm trees, shadows, and sand. The food is delicious. We had calamari, pasta and a salad , beer, and a margarita! Everything was excellent, and we will be back for sure.
I get hungry after I hang ten all day at the beach! Thats why you should get your flip flops & duck dive over to the Surf Shack coastal kitchen! I had their signature Surf burger & let me tell you this is no Barney burger! It was A-frame radical tasting burger, the onion bacon jam was on point & added alot of flavor! I left amped & stoked!
Sunday late afternoon, busy with about 40 minutes waiting. Food just cooked right, those young service people trying their best for the service. We enjoyed the surrounding atmosphere. Will come again.
I am here again, the night is very attractive!
Amazing place for a bar, great vibes and scenery, but as always with these beach side bars the food is disappointing never worth the price. I would still definitely come back though for the views and great location! Love that there’s another bar/restaurant (Boat Yard) next door as well.
We love this gem of a restaurant! Who needs a vacation when this is right in our backyard! Everything on the menu is delicious 😋
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
+5
Right next store to the Boatyard on Tobay Beach on Ocean Parkway. Amazing. Food looks great, table service on the beach. Beautiful setting. You can hear the bands next store. You can watch the sunset. Such a great spot. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!
Can’t beat the view! My husband had the scallops (only 3 but they were big) and said they were delicious. I had the lobster Roll market price but a bit skimpy in my opinion. Gets crowded we had a 45 minute wait. Good service. We’ll be back, there aren’t that many places on LI like it.
Good Food , Good Vibes! Surf Burger is definitely my favorite go to dish! Bar can definitely get busy, but if you have patience you probably can enjoy a good drink and meal. Was hesitant at first with all the bad reviews but I will say I think the food is great and drinks are solid. Ask for Anthony or Carissa if you sit at the bar! Great bartenders who knows how to make proper drinks!
Place is super cool. Food is ok. Our server Juan was great. I just wish they had something to hold the napkins and menus so they don't fly when it's windy. I noticed a lot of napkins flying on the beach which is sad.
Great place to eat when you go to Toby Beach. Food is satisfactory. Service is decent. Atmospheres amazing because you are on the bay side of Tobay Beach
Excellent I posted that it was the best burger all year, the fries were perfect, the servers were great
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes