Sluurpy > Restaurants in Melbourne > Michelli's Pizzeria
Michelli's Pizzeria - Melbourne - Photo album
Ordered a pie tonight October 21, 2023. Was one of the best pizzas I’ve had since I’ve been in Florida. It was cooked to perfection. Also had the chicken parm with Alfredo on the pasta and let me say that Alfredo was out of this world! The girls at the counter were so kind and helpful. Looks like th
I tried Michelli's Pizzeria for the first time, and I was very impressed. I come from south Florida (which is the makeshift capitol of New York) where there is a pizza joint on every corner, and in every shopping plaza. We know our pizza in So. Fla! So far the pizza in Central Florida has been unimp
This was a first time trying Michelli's. We got a flier in the mail. Former Bizarro's customers, and current Papa John's. Just bc PJ always comes hot and fresh and not overcooked. And I'm the first person to tell you, sometimes Italian, especially old Italian restaurants ive tried are either horribl
I’ve been going here since they opened. I love the food and the service is amazing. They know me by name when I walk in or call. When I was a manager I would take my team here for lunch or order to be delivered. The delivery is exceptional. Everything I’ve ever ordered has been earlier than the time
The pizza is so good! I love the pizza special, and the wings are great. The meatballs are good but I wish there were more in an order. I keep saying I'm going to try other things but keep coming back for that pizza! Great service and friendly staff
i’m not sure what her name is but the woman who’s always running the counter is literally an ANGEL!!! she’s so sweet, kind and helpful every time i come in. i have severe social anxiety so knowing there’s a place i can come to and always be treated so kindly is so amazing. oh yeah the foods really g
I'm in the area for a potential relocation. Had to try out a local pizzeria. Ordered the spaghetti bolognese (meat sauce). Sauce is made to order. Absolutely delicious!!! Brought me back to the days when I lived in Italy. Thank you!! I'm definitely coming back!!
Pizza is awesome. Cheese bread fantastic. Meatball and mushroom pizza was a hit. Found my new favorite and I’m a pizza snob. Highly recommend!!
One of many New York style pizza places in Melbourne. Nice crispy crust on outside but somewhat soggy underneath. Also somewhat greasy. Sausage topping comes in nice big slices with just the right amount of spiciness. I like this pizza, but I like some other nearby New York style pizza places be
Recently switched from our favorite local NY pizza shop, and it is crazy how good this place is in comparison.
Wait times can be a little long but honestly I am okay with it, as they give accurate timing when orders are placed!
So plan an extra 20 min if you are ordering delivery, otherwise amazin
Michelli's is a long-time favorite of mine!
I've gone there so often is like walking into Cheers where (almost) everybody knows my name.
Their pizza is delicious because using quality ingredients is of the highest priority to them.
The eggplant rollatini is one of my favorite entrees to order. T
Family-run, Michelli's is our go-to for pasta, calzones and cannolis. Salad is fresh, pasta always cooked al dente and the different sauces are great. I think the meatballs could use more garlic, but honestly no complaint from me. The Cannolis. Oh my!! So GOOD - crispy shell and creamy filling
Update:: they're doing soo much better these days! Glad the service and quality returned to the usual!
They have made my day plenty of times with such delicious pizza I mean the other reviews aren't lying when the right cook is making the pizza it's like I'm back in New York BUT there is one white
Fantastic place! My best friend who's lived in town forever recommended it as the best pizza in Palm Bay / Melbourne... She was right! Plus, very sweet family atmosphere, treated us great and a nice homey vibe. I told the woman about my friend's recommend, she not only remembered my friend but made
First time eating here. Pizza was amazing. Ready when expected. Garlic knots with Alfredo was delicious.
Just picked up my order cheese pizza and teriyaki garlic chicken and this is the best tasting I have ever had! As ther say in Brooklyn, “Furgettaboutit!” Make Michelli your one stop New York style Pizza! All the others are Fake! Service is fast and the staff is welcoming! Thanks guys!
Excellent meatball parmigiana hot sub! We were also offered free drinks while we waited!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes