Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Fish Sandwich in Menemsha

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Menemsha Fish Market
88/100 (940 ratings)
Quick Bites
Specialty Food Market
Restaurants
Seafood
Soups
American
Soups
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Crab Cake
Sandwiches
Lobster Roll
Steamers
Shrimp
Fish Sandwich
Lobster
Salad
Clam Chowder
Cakes
Fish
Crab
Scallops
Clams
Oyster
Tuna
Shellfish
Sit down
Soups
Seafood
American
Takeout
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Lunch
Mid-range
"Ok, we had a bad experience at another local fish market and decided to give Menemsha Fish Market a go. We are so happy we did, we ordered the hot..."
Robert Heffernan
"This is the best fish market on the island. Everything is fresh, especially the lobsters, any size you want. Then there are prepared and precooked..."
Brian Tran
"A perfect place to dip in for a quick bite and enjoy a nice lobster roll and a cup of chowder. The place was very busy, but they had my lunch ready..."
Bob Gomez
"Hot lobster roll was amazing and ready in less than 5 minutes. Barely any wait. Had to wait over 30 minutes just to order a lobster Mac and cheese at..."
C Mck
"Amazing chowder and lobster rolls. For some reason the “other seafood place” next door had a long line and Menemsha Fish did not. Both are great..."
Rob P
"Just the absolute best. We don't live in MA anymore, but we try to make it to the Vineyard once a year. The thing I look forward to most is going..."
Danny Olson
"Best lobster, clam chowder, lobster bisk on the island ! Bring your wine and watch the sunset behind fish market while the lobsters are being brought..."
Jake
"The very bestest most favorite seafood spot in the world. Always hitting this place first thing when we arrive at the island. The absolute benchmark..."
Artem Eliseyev
"Came here on July 4th for the most delicious dinner after cruising around the island. The lobster dinner, lobster roll & chowder were amazing!! SO..."
Jena Anne
"Nice local joint. Pricey, but expected. Most of the fish product is from elsewhere, but it looks fresh. Friendly..."
Me
"It does not get anymore fresh than this. From the boat to the dock to the backdoor. Lobster was insanely good. Seafood nachos were undercooked, got..."
Roger Shepard
"Reasonable prices and great selection. Very cool seeing a 50 year old 8 pound lobster. The fish monger was very helpful and made sure we got exactly..."
Kyle Becker
"Had lunch at this place. The lobster bisque was ok perhaps if it were hot it would've been better. It was room temperature when I got my order & ate..."
Clara C
"300 year old; still active fishing village. Had to get some seafood. Being from New England it has to be a cold lobster roll. It was delicate yet..."
Matty DeFreitas
"We go here by boat every year and love Menemsha Fish Market! They have the freshest variety of fish and seafood! We come here and seek out Black Sea..."
Dieu Torok
Homeport Restaurant & Oyster Bar
76/100 (555 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Oyster
French Fries
Calamari
Falafel
Mussels
Bass
Tuna
Sandwiches
Key lime pie
Calamares
Burger
Cakes
Pesto
Salmon
Fish
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Shrimp
Lobster Roll
Lobster
Tapas
Pasta
Fish Taco
Salad
Tacos
Clam Chowder
Fish & chips
Steamers
Seafood Platters
Crab
Swordfish
Scallops
Fish Sandwich
Clams
Sit down
American
Seafood
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
BYOB
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Waterfront
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
"Very good food and service! The reviews were scaring me a little bit but I am so glad we went! $79 for 3 courses is not expensive by vineyard..."
L G
"I remember going here when I lived on island many years ago. A lovely reboot. We were there early, food was very good. Excellent chowder, the mussels..."
mvjason1
"To be totally honest, the food is probably 3.5 stars. The views from the outdoor patio are great, the ambiance is nice, and the menu itself looks..."
David Pakman
"Had an incredible meal here with my family to celebrate my moms 60th. First time back in 4 years and enjoyed the prefixed menu. The lobsters were..."
Isabella Djerassi
"The homeport was delicious and the atmosphere was great! Peter, our waiter was amazing and so cute! We had a party of 8 and no one had any complaints..."
mollie mccaffrey
"Ava provided absolutely extraordinary service! We had the oysters, shrimp cocktail and scallops, all were fabulous. The scallops were accompanied by..."
Winnifred Lee
"Our meals were great and the service was excellent. The only reason I gave a 4 for atmosphere was because they didn't have a 4.5 option. Room got..."
Rick Lambos
"Prix fixe menu (I think $78/person), plus raw bar & a couple optional extras. No alcohol sales in Chilmark so BYO. The food was great on my recent..."
Thatcher Ulrich
"Excellent New England Style lobster dinner and clam bake. Enjoy the outdoor dining and amazing lobster with steamers as an appetizer. It’s the best..."
David
"Not like the Nixon days but the food is still delicious. Pricey , miss the twin lobster dinner. Corn bread needs maple syrup, add this to the menu. I..."
IAN FRAENKEL
"Wonderful restaurant in Menemsha with a great, wraparound deck for outdoor seating and sunset viewing. Friendly, young staff, though they seem..."
A
"Once a year I break the piggy bank and head to Home Port for lobster take out. I bring my own wine/Champagne, put the kids on the picnic tables, get..."
Thomas Regan-Lefebvre
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use