I grew up in Menomonee Falls, but have since moved away. The fact that I can come home to a place that has unchanged since I was little is amazing! I get to reminisce in the same quaint and cozy place, and have the most amazing custard! I also try to bring friends and family when I can, so they can step back in time with me! The prices are fair for delicious food. The smells that hit you while walking in, (popcorn, burgers and custard) never fail to get your tummy rumbling! I will always recommend this place. Always.
Best place in town ! Sharon is the best !! Even though it’s under new management same family and love for the customers is still there. Best custard , best burgers and best atmosphere !!!
Literally best EVERYTHING! No burger compares. Ice cream is the best and they have a very large menu. Awesome mom and pop vibe and they are active in the community. Take my money! Great memories are made here.
Best. Burger. Ever. and Best turtle sundae too! Been to this ma and pop shop since i was a toddler. I bring my son here regularly. Love love love this place
The custard reminds me of when i was a kid, everytime im in the falls this is one of my first stops!! The brat is a great price & a meal in itself!! Love this place!!!
I have been a customer of Pops since the eighties and I absolutely love it! I will drive past Culver’s to go further to Pops. I highly recommend.
Great chilli cheese fries! great food and great service! This place is a gem. We’ll be back
Great tasting custard. Very thoughtful attendant offered a smaller dish option for our young grandkids. We will definitely be back.
Christine Bosshart-mulock
+5
Love this place so much! Even though we moved away my kids still pick it for there dinner of choice. They are so friendly!
I love this place! The custard is great the personal is so nice. Its a
great place for everyone and its not a chain :)
My opinion is biased because this is the place I loved since I was three but I think it's that place that is cheap has cheap food and ok custard but you can't not like it
I HAD THE ANGUS 1/3 IB BURGER WITH CHEESE ketchup mayo fried onions pickles. The food was hot and freshly made. The fries were coated with light batter. The food was delicious. Their staff were friendly and professional. They have a very large food and custard selection. Will definitely go there again. The restaurant was clean, the decor was unique. I give it a check it out if in the area. So much better than Wendy's, Burger King or McDonald's
Love this gem my #jbabe took us too!! Babe said they have been around for a long time and I’m sure I know why?!! The place itself is very welcoming and cozy. The staff and service was perfect, and the custard was on point!! We have yet to try the all American food so that will definitely be our next visit. So far the BEST custard I’ve ever had!!! Way to end our Sunday Funday!!! Thanks guys!!
Pop’s custard is sooo Good!! I haven’t been back here since my High school days. It brought back some fond memories. I took my girlfriend here and she loved it. She added the puppy chow to her sundae and she ate the whole thang. She usually doesn’t finish. We will definitely be stopping back anytime were in the neighborhood!
Was around the area and found this place seeing all of the good reviews figured I stopped by ,nice little place a bit small only a few tables on the inside and some on the outside,the food selection is fairly decent but basic (burgers, hotdogs, ice cream etc) not a bad thing just fyi
Price to quality is great according to them everything is made to order on the moment, can't get any fresher than that and the quality of the food is great. We tried the swiss and mushroom burger the parmesan chicken sandwich and the loaded fries everything felt fresh and delicious 😋 .I'll be honest the mushrooms and swiss burger patty was a bit plain imo everything else was great the portions where perfect I didn't have room left for ice cream at the end, so didn't get to try it i was too full so I will have to come back to try it out I definitely recommend pop's.
Great place for a quick bite or to socialize with friends and family. From ice cream to burgers and fries this is your mom and pop style ice cream shop. You can chose from many of their custom shakes, malts, and Sundays! No single flavor of the day because they offer so many different flavors that you can basically build anything you want!
Samantha Hawley Heckert
+4
This is a small establishment and the ice cream was delicious. There were a surprising number of options. I tried to come here in the summertime, but the lines were too long and there was no parking. If you can get it, it's worth it. The ice cream portions were generous.
I was out with my granddaughters trying to find a fun place to eat. I saw Pop's Custard sign & just decided to try it. The menu is large, the employees were friendly & helpful & the food was excellent! The girls announced to me that this was their new favorite place!
Grew up coming here as a kid and now take my kids here every time we're in town. Today visit included sundaes, scoops, cones and a quart. Their chocolate chip, cherry amaretto is SO GOOD! Highly recommend for both food and frozen custard!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes