Jersey Mike's Subs - Middletown - Photo album

Hands down and without a doubt Jersey Mike’s offers the freshest and most authentic subs you’ll find anywhere. The bread is freshly baked, cold cuts are sliced to order. “Mike’s way” with lettuce, tomato, onions, and “the juice” oil and vinegar and spices (salt, pepper, oregano) make for a nearly

Went here for a quick bite before a hockey game at the Middletown ice arena. The flavor of the bread was good but really it was an average sub sandwich. We're not from the East Coast and this is our first Jersey Mike experience. I would try it again though.

This is not the first time I ordered from here. They must be so busy that they can not label the bags or even read the comments. Just put the pickles on the side, like it said.

This location is excellent. Quality sandwich and great staff.

They deserve a zero after this morning's experience. I go to the North Middletown, NJ store as I often do. I ask for a breakfast sandwich and wait for it...they tell me "there is no room on the grill". Keep in mind that it's 10AM no one in the store. So clearly an on line order was more important t

Just ordered a sandwich asked for Mikes Way kid forgot the “juice” and seasoning, made for a super dry sandwich. Everyone in there is too focused on the online orders to focus on the walk-in customers.

Online order pickup scheduled for 5:30. Sandwiches were on time and on point. Cheese steak 🥩 sandwich (big kahuna) is always tasty. Crew pleasant and helpful. "Go to" spot for our needs.

Wish I could give this location a 0 star rating. Will not be returning to Jersey Mike’s of Middletown after they told me “oh well” when my order was messed up. Then the minor employee lied and told me he was putting his store manager on and I found out it wasn’t the store manager, it was just anothe