Gordon Shaffer
What's more apropo when visiting a small town than to eat where the locals do? As we walked into the diner large booths lining the establishment and the customary counter w stools were seen. Past expansions of the restaurant over the years has turned the diner into a large eatery with a more modern feel. We came for lunch and found the prices high, but the menu offered a wide selection of plates and sandwiches. I chose a Black Russia Wrap containing hefty slices of pastrami, slaw and Russian dressing tightly wrapped in a tasty tortilla. For my side, I switched out fries for a bowl of creamy potato with bacon as did my wife. We both liked the chunky potatoes in the hot soup. Oddly, when she ordered avocado toast, it came as a toasted sandwich. We didn't see much of our waitress. Good food in a simple setting. Just what you hope in a diner.
Brotherhood Gear
We went for breakfast. I had the delicious French toast and scramble eggs, my child had waffles and four pieces of fried chicken which he took some home and the hubby had sausage omelet with toast and home fries everything was delicious but 4 dollars for a glass of orange juice that came from a container is ridiculous. The service was nice and sweet
sidney dulman
Place is cute to go to, service was good. The food though was out of this world. I got a Texas burger rare and it was amazing. I am usually skeptical about ordering such basic things like a burger. Why order what you can probably cook yourself better? Well the chef here did a pretty darn good job of making me feel like I got that home cooked meal. The burger was delicious and the onion rings had that perfect crisp to it. 5 star on the food and restaurant. Would definitely make the hour trip to eat there again.
Zack Tauber
Stopped here while In town, it is your usual diner breakfast, nothing to special or different about it. There is a diner down the road called village diner that is absolutely amazing, Recommend that one overall. But nothing bad to say about this diner either.
J R
This was my second time eating here, overall my experience was great. As soon as I came in someone greeted me, and led me to a table. The waiter came over quickly to ask if I wanted coffee and or something to drink. The food didn’t take long to be prepared, I was able to switch home fries to French fries last minute without any issues. I would give the Milford Dinner 5/5 stars. Great place to eat, sit and chat.
Aaron Santiago
Milford Dinner is one of those classic tastes of old world Americana. Coffee is always hot, food is always plentiful, and the staff always has a smile. Either you're just passing by, or a regular, Milford Dinner is always a welcoming place to stop by.
The food is as you expect it for this kind of establishment. Big plates of comfort food, just like home made. The staff is always attentive even as the sun sets.
Doug W
I had the liver and onions with bacon was perfectly cooked to perfection. Had a nice salad which was lovely. Be sure to check out the specials when you first walk in cuz that's where they're listed at. There is no listing inside. I'll definitely go back if I'm in the area.
T S
Selected this place for an early dinner after a great hike at Stairway Lake.
The service is fantastic with one person dedicated to getting your drinks and clearing dishes.
Nice portions. The stuffed crab is 90% filler, thus the 4 star rating.
Plenty of parking at 4pm.
Kellee Fiola
On road trip home stopped in Milford PA for the night-had dinner & breakfast there.
Loved the food, the crowd & the staff-
lots if excellent Greek food..suspect the owners are Greek-excellent Spinach pie & a terrific baklava- rather big- for the way home. Homey feeling. Our waitress was terrific-she had a very ladylike manner.
Hope to have to go by there again.
Edward Green
This diner strikes a careful balance, consistent with Milford's status as a tourist destination: it's a place with a comfortable locals feel to it that's also welcoming for out-of-towners, local but not too local: you can enjoy that regulars vibe without the sometimes uncomfortable feeling that you've intruded on a private social club.
The menu is large and varied, and while not everything can be a "gee I wish I'd ordered that!" triumph, nothing is a terrible disappointment. The breakfast grits were excellent, and next time I go I'm going ask for extra grits, hold the toast. I'm getting hungry just thinking about it. With moderate prices and ample parking, it's worth a drive from nearby Port Jervis.
Carla Schneider
Great service and exactly what we wanted. It was a cold dark day and the homemade chicken noodle soup and Manhattan clam chowder were welcomed and delicious. We both got the turkey dinner, very good, I ended up taking half of it home and enjoyed it in the hotel room later. The turkey was so tender and the gravy was decent.
Stacey Cooper
Had breakfast and got the breakfast burrito. When I went to pay I realized I left my wallet iny jeans pocket from getting gas the night before. The owner was very accommodating and understood, he gave me a business card and told me to call him with my card numbers. I was back a little while later to pay my bill. Will definitely go back if in the area.
Karyn Swingle
Let me start by saying that I have loved their food for 20+years. I haven't been there for a while so I called in a lunch order today. I just picked up 2 wraps and a side of onion rings. THIRTY SEVEN DOLLARS.🤯 Never again.
Steve Bee
Excellent diner food. Clean place. Extensive menu for either breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Great omelets for breakfast, or anytime during the day. I get the Primavera Omelet and get a side of marinara sauce to make a delicious omelet. The onion, pepper, and American cheese one is especially tasty, also. Try scramled eggs with home fries and gyro meat! Ooooo so good! Many, many lunch and dinner choices. They make the best Greek salad with wrapped grape leaves and anchovies (if you ask). Service is always good and attentive. Great corned beef n cabbage on St Patrick's Day. I've been going here for years and years and never, ever, had a bad meal. You'll be surprised to find one of the best burgers anywhere, right here at this diner. I usually order it with fries with delicious brown gravy. Good portions, too. "Ol' reliable" Milford Diner. If you try it, you'll like it! It's the best.
L P
Very crowded for 11am-1230pm Sunday breakfast/lunch crowd. Got seated for a table of 7 fairly quickly, but the wait time to make the actual order was about 30min. Inexperienced drink order waitress got the order mixed up, but it all worked out since everyone ordered similar drinks. More seasoned waitress who took our main orders got everything right and the food was fresh, good, and filling. Had leftovers for another meal.
Keystone Omelette for my husband had a few small pieces of eggshell in it so he had to chew extra well.
Home fries were tasty, not too oily, not burnt. Turkey club was stacked and fresh with a side of crunchy fries.
Blueberry pancakes came in a pile of 3, were large (about 8" across), and had a good amount real blueberries. Had some leftover to eat as a snack for later.
Chicken caesar wrap was fresh and just the right size to satisfy that morning hunger. French Onion soup was delicious although small and topped with a slice of white cheese.
Taquitos that my nephew-in-law chose were slightly soggy by the time they reached our table so his order might've been sitting for a bit before getting to us.
Restaurant was really bustling by lunchtime and we finished our food at a convenient time to escape the larger lunchtime crowd. No opinion of the bathroom since me and my husband did not use it.
Parking is limited (10 spots?) so not ideal for a large SUV or for drivers not used to narrow spaces.
Sidenote: Only reason I gave 4 stars and not 5 was the very slow service in the beginning. New customers' orders were taken before ours and we were ready to order before our 7th guest arrived. Perhaps this place will be better on the next visit 🤷♀️
Luis Rodriguez
O email of the best steak and eggs I have had in years. Great food, great service and a lot of parking .
They were not shy 0n the strawberries for the French toast!!! All wa yummy.
My only observation is that if they were to have maple syrup available...oh well that would make a lot of people happy!!
John Anderson
Great place!! My wife and I had breakfast here while our truck was getting Mx across the street. Awesome breakfast and service! Menu is awesome! You name the omelet and they will have it. Establishment is very clean, well maintained and has 1970s vibe that is very cool. Service is on the mark! Meal: country omelet, hash browns and toast (plenty) were delicious well cooked! Coffee hot, and always refilled. Great location, food, customer service. Leadership has it figured out!! Highly recommend
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes