Always great. One of my top 4 and I am super picky. Use great ingredients get great pizza. Sounds simple doesn't it. I guess it's harder than it seems, Papa s gets it. Great cheese ,great sauce and crust. Wonderful
As I said in the Facebook group "You Know Your From Milford If" This is the best pizza in Milford. I'm thankful to have it so close to my home. Keep up the good work!
You don’t need to go to New Haven ! This is the best pizza you will get north of the city !
Do yourself a favor and get a white pizza with chicken bacon and garlic. The best pizza I have ever had, bar none.
Best pizza in the area. New Haven pizza without the drive, way better than that "J" place down the street.
The best pizza and people in Milford!!
Never a bad pie or experience!
Stop wasting your time going to New Haven. Papas is the best pizza around!!
That spinach bacon tomato garlic pizza is awesome!
Solid pie and great people who treat you right. They don't over promise when you call and are honest when your pizza will be ready. There are many good choices in the area for pizza, but this place has consistently made great pizza. Worth avtrybif you haven't already done so.
This pizza is incredibly good, and I would genuinely eat this over almost any other pizza. I would eat this over Pepe's and Modern and all the usuals. I'm sad it's 30 minutes away for me normally but when I'm in the area and want great pizza I know where to go. Staff are great too which is a nice plus!
My wife and I were leaving Milford to head to Bradley in Hartford and wanted a real pizza,not like we're used to here in Tucson but a real pizza so we stopped by Papa's and the onion and garlic pizza was phenomenal.....10/10 would recommend
Papa's has been my favorite pizza, since 1999 the year my first child was born , now she loves it all my kids do. To me the best Italian pie in all of Ct ....."Shrimp and Bacon" the best topped pie ever!!!!
Scott makes the best pizza in CT . I can eat a large pie and not get bored of the taste . We got a calzone to die for . I ate it without the sauce cause it didn't need it . If you like sauce on them you will not be disappointed . My advice go there , go there often , go there now .
Our neighbors had us over for pizza last week from Papa‘s Pizza ll and we enjoyed it so much. Today we ordered our own and found it outstanding. We had a bacon, mushroom, and onion and thoroughly savored it. It is now our go to place for pizza for sure! Good job guys!
Some of the very best pizza in Connecticut, I highly recommend.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes