Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Miller Place
7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Family owned Italian restaurant since '72, the dad Nick was the cook and his 2 sons were working the front. Absolutely the best Italian place (the..."
Juan Ortiz-Rivera
"There are lots of pizza options in this area but Rubino’s is by far the best!!! Thin pizza crust and zesty sauce, their cheese pizza reminds me of..."
Yvonne Williamson
"Best tasting pizza locally and the owner is one of the nicest people I’ve ever met. The rest of their food is delicious as well. Highly recommend..."
Lisa Fazio
"After a lifetime of eating and making pizza I can say that Rubinos regular and Sicilian pies are excellent. They have speciality pies that are..."
Anthony “Tony” Cipriano
"Love this place! The pizza is amazing and the staff is always so friendly and helpful. Feels like family when you’re in there. Highly recommend if..."
Michelle G
"Best pizza around... cant emphasize enough how much effort Nick and Joe put into their food and pizza... picture perfect every..."
AJ DESIGN
"Pizza was very good. Young lady at the counter was lovely and..."
Kenneth Rivalsi
"Outstanding off-site catering (in addition to a great place to eat)!! We had an 80th birthday party catered. Feeding and serving people with their..."
Planet Patsy
"This was the 1st time i ordered from Rubinos and have lived in sound beach for a year already. I dont normaly trust italian resteraunts ive never..."
Michael Montefusco
"first time here and the pizza was SOSO good. Got 2 regular slices and 2 specialty all very good. They have good service came out fast good variety of..."
Spencer Burns
"Such an awesome place and owned by great people!!! Love it here it’s my favorite..."
Samantha Cunningham
"I almost feel bad for the other pizza places I pass by to get to Rubino's. Glad they are nearby. I kid you not, I got family, and after eating..."
Edward Stewart
"Amazing! Ordered the pizza and large Ceasar salad. They said 45 minutes. They delivered it in 30! Fresh ingredients, hot pizza, polite delivery guy,..."
Andrew B
"Best Pizzeria restaurant on the island! Joe and Nick are class acts! Amazing food and great company— the staff is great and always making me laugh!..."
kayla branca
"Joe and Nick are the best. Their staff is wonderful. We had our daughters baby shower here last Sunday. Was a great day can't thank them enough. And..."
"This place is AWESOME. First of all the people that work there are so nice. The food was absolutely DELICIOUS 😋. They had no problem answering..."
jill bassi
"This was a GEM find last night. We are new to the area and we have been looking for our go to date night spot. We definitely found it here. Cute..."
Katherine
"Went in for pasta night, which was a great deal. Staff was all nice and attentive. The food was honestly fantastic, had some pasta fagiole that was..."
Shane Manzo
"Former New Yorker, been living in Florida, missed good Italian food! Visiting relatives, been here twice. Excellent food, prices are great, Sydney..."
Grace Reeber
"⚡ Lisa - Update✨- They're so friendly & curious. Great service, concerned about customers online orders. Efficient & happy. Nice Aye!
- Lisa..."
Lisa Lichelle Hill
"Amazing food. Great friendly service. Had grilled chicken Alfredo. Will definitely go..."
Shawn Hendry
"Pizza was great: crispy dough, friendly staff, fair priced, clean bathrooms, would definitely come..."
J E
"I’ve ordered from here twice first the margherita pizza second time their focaccia pizza. Both were the best I’ve ever had. Live here for 28..."
C K
"Super clean, great food and friendly attentive staff. Pasta not overcooked, pizza was crispy and the panini was..."
Paul
"I love this 🍕 place. I've been here a long time and they are really great!!!!In the summertime my granddaughter and I would stop in and grab a..."
Sandra Jacobsen
"I have celiac, so finding a good place for gluten free food is a challenge. I've ordered a couple of times from Fusilli. Today my order was..."
Jennifer Suchoicki
"This is the awsome place to grab and go pizza slice specially for vegetarians a lot of healthy stuff to..."
Tapasya Rana
"Facili pizza excellent restaurant talk to the owner Joe fabulous person really concerned about his restaurant and his customers get a beautifully..."
Antonino Atl
"Great pizza! I've had their personal pie and their regular Neopolitan pie. Absolutely delicious! I've also had their chicken francese, that was..."
Brian Downs
"Really good and tasty pizza 🍕
Service..."
Taj Toojy
"We had bacon chicken ranch pizza it was Sooo..."
Dina Powers
"This is my favorite place to get pizza ! The staff are always ready and the service is top notch ! Chicken Bacon Ranch here is my favorite ! Thanks..."
"First time here and what a meal! We started with the fero which was delicious! The ravioli special was my favorite! We had the lasagna and the..."
Pat B
"We had a stunning experience at Orto. To go!
The restaurant doesn't look as a restaurant because it is located inside the historical house called..."
pas
"Went here for the first time last night with my cousin Taylor who knew about the Chef’s tasting. The food was delicious is an understatement. The..."
Jessica McCarthy
"Great food, reasonable prices, you can bring your own wine, staff is super attentive. Historic building... will definitely be going..."
Heather Swanson Photography (& Art Director)
"First time here and it was absolutely delicious!! Service was good, no complaints! Good prices. The site says it’s BYOB so we brought 2 bottles of..."
Gina T.
"Everything you could ever want in a restaurant experience. Charming location and historic location and building in Miller Place. We were seated..."
Kevin Wood
"Came to Orto again last night, and as always, they didn’t disappoint. This is one of my favorite places to eat. The food is outstanding. The staff..."
Theodore Nardolillo
"Our meals were impeccably prepared. The service was outstanding. But, it was the personal touches that made it a special night. The private nook..."
seanb66
"Orto came high recommend to us and it did not disappoint. A very warm and cozy restaurant, perfect for celebrating our wedding anniversary. The..."
Sal Miliotto
"Great 4-course meal. It is a historical local house from the 1800's. The food is always excellent. Bring cash because no cc. My favorite is the..."
"Amazing food and service. We order to pick up and the food was ready when promised, 15 minutes! We had a big order but on got pictures of the..."
Anne DeSimone
"We have eaten here for pizza a few times in the past, and it was always good, truthfully, probably much better than most pizza places. We decided one..."
Cindy Serra
"My moms favorite pizza place, very great food and always quick service. Thank you and happy Mother’s..."
Ryan M
"Best pizza place around! We drove from NJ just to have their pizza. It's one of a kind! Family owned operation that truly cares for their customers...."
GC Vaghasia
"Favorite spot for Italian food! The food here is really delicious and the staff is very friendly! Best meatballs and everything. The garlic and oil I..."
Stephanie C.
"Branchinelli's is always a good idea. Be sure to ask for your garlic knots to be served wet for the best experience..."
Danielle B
"Dined on the chix parm w vodka sauce!..."
Tara E Toolan
"I am used to the location in smithtown. This didn't have as many options, but the food was delicious and service was..."
amanda kearns
"Best Italian food and bang for the buck anywhere!!! I highly recommend..."
Steven Lance Levine
"Perfect take out and dine in pizza joint. Highly suggest the food and atmosphere are..."
Katherine
"I had fettuccine in white clam sauce. It was a good portion and super delicious. It hit the..."
Jonathan Valentin
"Best salad I had in a long time it had beets in it and cranberries grilled chicken on the side waiter was very nice service was good. The table next..."
June Mccarthy
"This is by far the best Italian restaurant in the world. I have been eating here for years beginning in their hauppague location. Highly recommend..."
Donald Mcdouglas
"Best penne alla vodka I’ve ever had in my whole..."
Hailey Purpura
"This place is the best, great service, Anthony is the man. I usually pick up super good. Hot and Cold salad is Amazing. Pizza is fantastic. Go..."
Oren Taub
"Really good parm. I especially like the grilled balsamic chicken Primavera. Can get..."
Amy Lee
"Been here a bunch of times.. Haven't been here in many years but remember how good it was, so came back
.. 2 days in 1 week lol
Very pleasant..."
"Always an excellent treat- my favorites are strawberry Twisters, chocolate milkshakes, and vanilla soft serve cones, but I definitely need to try..."
Emilie Pellenz
"Nice place, very friendly staff, Ashley had a good attitude. Helped me pick out what flavor I liked best. She was spot on. Love the chocolate peanut..."
Cindy Serra
"⚡Lisa - Their so nice. Thank God they opened a pickup order window. Ooffaa! Lol! Their Ice Cream must be Good! Cause that line be long, Jack. Lol...."
Lisa Lichelle Hill
"Truly a great time! I brought the family and got the peanut butter crunch, wow was it good! It was fan flipping amazing! I highly recommend anyone..."
Kayin Cline
"Staff is great and polite always.The ices are the..."
Richard Woodward
"Who doesn't love ices from Ralph's!..."
Marc Cohen
"The one in miller place is always packed but do they make an excellent black and white milk shake but sometimes the service is wack but it's worth..."
Rib Rosa
"What can I say. It's summertime And Ralph's Italian ices are always the best the crew were amazingly friendly and fast...."
ralph ottenwalder
"Great customer service, very busy always. Don't like owner leaves such young girls alone. As they were robbed and those poor..."
Tiffany Pliakis
"My favorite part of summer. Half cannoli half cappucino. And of course a vanilla cone for my puppy. Never..."
Mella Bella
"Love their..."
Steven Kuehne
"Friendly, quick service and..."
Chinh Chinh
"Excellent service, many delicious flavors to chose from , happy and smiling adult faces..."
"We had a huge family dinner party not more than 15 in the back room and it was perfect the girl was on it too and everyone loved everything! Not..."
Christina Wahl
"Saw the ratings for this pizzeria and since my son lives in Miller place I wanted to try it. Other closer pizzerias near his home I was not impressed..."
Carol B
"Thin crust pizza is great. We enjoyed a white, margarita and alla vodka slice; all were delicious.
The tables and bathroom are clean. The table was..."
Ukulele Lover
"Waitress Megan was very friendly and polite on Mondays and Tuesdays and Wednesdays are pasta night for 19.95 get a choice of wine or soda, salad or..."
June Mccarthy
"Amazing service. Had a bad day while dog grooming. These were super sweet, jumped as soon as I asked for something, and probably the second best..."
rachel maligno
"spot on pizza, excellent service, coming back here for sure. thank..."
b rokash
"This place is fantastic, it's rare to find an authentic Italian restaurant with a full range of Vegan options. Vincenzo himself was so incredible to..."
John M
"Enjoyed my go to slice with garlic knots. Only reason to knock down one star is that 2 slices a couple garlic knots and a drink will run around $9..."
Mohsin Saber
"I cant believe in all my time living here i havent gotten pizza here more often. I called in the order for a large pie and heard the voice of a man..."
Haden Hunt
"5 stars across the board. Great food. Great service. You can taste the difference, it's obvious they use quality ingredients. Best knots on the..."
Rob Meoli
"My husband and I are self proclaimed pizza foodies LMAO. We always try to make a point of stopping at a new pizza place and trying their regular..."
Jennifer Guilmette
"I love the place, and they have great food. I was upset when they were chased out of Port Jeff. Probably the best pizza on Long..."
"This is such classic pizza. It came out hot and fast with such great flavor. The sauce has a raw sweetness and the crust had the perfect amount of..."
Mary Behringer
"Pizza is in my top 5 best I have ever had. Every time I order from here the pizza is so fresh and they do not skimp out on the toppings. I love the..."
Ryan M
"I have never ordered from here before. We ordered a plain pie, pepperoni pie and garlic knots. I couldn't be any more happy with what we got. Let's..."
Jamie Gundersen
"Incredibly sweet staff and amazing food for a fair price. Had such a great time with my girlfriend there and the chef herself was incredible..."
Hunter Gelfman
"We miss You When We are back in North Carolina And Love You When We are back on Long Island
Great Variety of Food and Deserts are fantastic. This..."
Jim Capobianco
"I am so happy with my choice to hold my daughter's baby shower at C.P. LaManos! When my family first moved to L.I
In 1970, "Have a Pizza" was a..."
Sharon Cares
"Excellent like homemade pizza. Personal service with a great dining room and..."
Richard H
"New favorite pizza spot! Their pan pizza is KICKASS. Love that their house salad has 3 bean salad in it. The Tuscany chicken hero was amazing too...."
Alyssa Cottone
"Took my family there for my daughters birthday, excellent food and service. Our waitress sang happy birthday to my daughter and she has a beautiful..."
John Curtin
"I enjoy their pizza once a week. Most of the time I order the two pan pizza special on Wednesday nights. It’s my kids favorite. I like..."
Monie Lee
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes