Best Bakery in MKE. My family has been ordering Simma's cheesecakes for years. We even get requests from out of town relatives to bring a cheesecake when we come to visit because they're just that good. I have also tried many different items from the bakery and can say I have never been disappointed. The morning buns are out of this world (they're best early in the morning when still warm). If you're looking for something really special, Simma's is the place to go.
Ditto to Mongolians review!
Simmas in the best place in Milwaukee for cheesecake They made our wedding cafe. It was fantastic.
We chose Simma’s as our wedding cake vendor and couldn’t be happier! Friendly and courteous staff helped us each time we visited for a planning/tasting meeting. Very good communication between us, the Simma’s team, and our venue for an easy drop off and set up process on our big day. Plus, the design is exactly as we envisioned: simple, elegant, and ready to add a few flowers from the bouquet. It turned out so wonderful (and was incredibly tasty too, which multiple layers of flavors!). Thank you Simma’s!
My husband and I had the opportunity to taste a piece of their cheesecake when we stopped and sat on the bench in front of their bakery. The gentleman that served us was very kind. The cheesecake was so delicious! It had a layer of chocolate on top with a layer of raspberry filling. It was the perfect balance to compliment the smooth and creamy taste. I would highly recommend this bakery. Thank you again :)
Great service, Beautiful Wedding Cake for our daughter’s wedding. The icing paired beautifully with their signature cheese cake. We were able to sale the top layer for our daughter and son in law’s one year anniversary as well. Delicious, timely and reasonably priced!
This bakery is simply delicious. The beautiful cheesecake layered with chocolate and raspberry was such a hit. Everyone loved it and asked where we got the beautiful cake from. So glad they are so easy to work with and service is with a smile.
Great Milwaukee bakery! Have picked up their dark chocolate raspberry cheesecake for several birthdays in the past. They have 3 size options to accommodate your event. Plenty of little snacks and treats in the case also.
I had a lovely experience working with Simma’s for my wedding cake and desserts. Everything tasted amazing and my guests loved every treat! The planning process was smooth and with the help of Simma’s staff, I was able to execute my vision and have the wedding of my dreams! I can’t recommend them enough. Aside from their special event desserts, I love stopping in and trying new things periodically! 10/10 experience.
From the time I placed my Christmas cheesecake order from the time of pickup it was perfection! Rochelle was the most customer friendly person I have ever dealt with and the cheesecake tastes amazing!!!!!! Keep up the great work!
This was my first visit there. My friend ordered me a birthday cake. It was the best I've had. Simply delicious. I can see why there was a line. I can't wait to go back.
I first had their cake at a few weddings I worked at and I always had to ask where it came from. Simmas. I then vowed that this would be my wedding cake too lol! Which, guess what, 10 years later, and it was. Everyone loved it 😁
I would just recommend sending a picture of the cake you want instead of calling it in. The staff is very very kind!
Simma's cheesecake is the BEST, hands down! We ordered one for my daughter's wedding and there wasn't one piece left! The waitstaff at the venue even asked where we got it because it was the most beautiful cake they'd ever served! The groom loves carrot cake, so I ordered a smaller cake for him and anyone who also enjoys that. There were only a couple pieces of that left. I hope our waitstaff was able to enjoy it!
Alexandra Johnson (Alex)
+5
We felt so lucky to be able to book Simma's bakery for our wedding cake. They put together a wonderful tasting experience that was one of the highlights of the wedding planning process for me. Trinity took very detailed notes. We picked the marble cake with European vanilla buttercream frosting with raspberry and chocolate mousse. The cake itself looked beautiful and was delicious. So many guests commented on how great the cake was and hardly any was left by the end of the evening. Thank you again for helping make our day so sweet.
Can’t say enough about this bakery. It is a must for any special occasion and holiday. It’s so easy to order ahead of time and even if you don’t they always have fresh cheesecakes in multiple sizes available to grab and go that they can write on. The chocolate cake bottom with the raspberry filling is phenomenal. Always a crowd pleaser. They also have an extensive selection of desserts readily available and the only downside is having to choose because you truly will want to try them all. Highly recommend stopping by if you haven’t tried already!
Jessica Pauline Grimm Hernández
+5
Amazing cake and cheesecakes. There are a few GF options (more in the freezer by other local businesses). You can order cakes ahead of time and pickup later. We went recently to pick up my sister's baby shower cake. This place was super busy but goes to show how well known and loved it is. They have a number system so it is organized and smooth running. Lots of staff and service was great. I have had the cake for various occasions. Either bought it myself or at other events (birthday, weddings, just because). High quality every time we have ever had it. The buttercream frosting is a perfect balance and not overly sweet. Pictured is a half sheet cake that feeds approx 30 people. Everyone loved the cake and depending on the size of slices can be for over 30 people easily.
Most delicious cakes in the world!!
Cheese cake is a dream. Can’t describe how creamy it is. Carrot cake so moist and all of them simply delicious
I love Simma's cheesecake. The chocolate cake layer is moist. The cheesecake is rich and creamy. The raspberry layer is delicious and compliments the rest perfectly. The chocolate layer is rich and delicious as well. It is a wonderful treat for a special occasion. They have many other great bakery items here as well. It is definitely worth trying. The bakery is wheelchair accessible. There is enough space to maneuver around as well.
My birthday cake was really good. Not too sweet, moist and rich. The outer layer wasn't too thick/sweet/buttery. Upscaled version of a good home baked cake. Highly recommend.
And then they have this cashew brittle which is out of the world. Don't miss it!
My family has been going to Simma's for years, so when I got engaged and started planning my wedding for last April, it was pretty much the one no-brainer in the whole process. All of us agreed--both my family and his--that Simma's would have to do our wedding cake. And what a beautiful job they did!! Their cake and cheesecake selections are extensive and delicious (their cheesecake is easily the best cheesecake I've ever had from a bakery), and working with Meredith Bowar was a breeze. She made everything so easy and ensured we got exactly the dream cake we were hoping for. If you need desserts for anything, Simma's is definitely the place to go!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes