Derek Draiz
First off the staff was very friendly, pizza is displayed and everything to me looks very appetizing. I had the buffalo slice and a beef patty( yes a beef patty they have it and it's freaking delicious ) everything was so good and well spiced. I've had there regular slice and you can Taste the difference in the sauce they use. Personal opinion it's the best pizza hands down around the area. Definitely looking forward to go back for there lunch specials.
Miss Conduct
I have tried a wide variety of dishes and pizza from Plum Tomatoes and I can tell you that this is absolutely fresh, homemade food. You can taste the difference when the Cook prepares your meal fresh to each order. My meal was prepared to my taste specifications with no problem. I particularly loved every sauce I have tried- from the Marsala to the Francaise, Alfredo and Vodka sauces were also spot on. The pizza dough is homemade as well as the fresh mozzarella. As a Brooklyn native... I am a big pizza critic, and I am absolutely impressed with their pizza.the resta5is very clean and the staff is super friendly and helpful. Casual- comfortable atmosphere. I highly recommend this place. Kid- friendly.
eltorretta
I love this place. I work locally and eat here at least 3 times week. Great salads. The best buffalo pizza around. They are always creating innovative pies and almost all are winners. Great lunch specials too.
Owners and staff are friendly and accommodating.
A must try if you are in the area.
Larry Kaye
First time at Plum Tomatoes and consider myself a pizza aficionado. This place is definitely one of the best places I have been too! The sauce on the sicilian is excellent and the buffalo specialty pie is a home run! Highly recommend!
Zaeem Nazir
Great pizza place, but it loses a star for being inconsistent. Sometimes the quality if a plain pie is great from here, other times it suffers from either being undercooked and liquidy, or being overcooked and the edges are burnt. On the other hand, it's worth getting the 2 pizza deal that is only available with an online order (2 Large Pies, 12 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda/$26). Great deal if you're looking to buy pizza as a group.
R. Drew Davis
A fairly ordinary pizzeria. I liked that they seemed to anticipate what I might want. I ordered an unsweet iced tea and they offered to put some lemon in. Sausage calzone was delicious. They have table service and a menu too, but I didn't explore that. Place seems popular with locals - a good sign.
Tara Berman
Simply the Best Pizza in all of Long Island. Ordered their famous Buffalo Chicken pizza and no other place I have gone too compares! By far one of the best quality Italian Restaurants on Lonf Island! Definitely recommend it.
Deborah Cerreta
Went to Plum Tomatoes for the first time today to celebrate my birthday with the family. Our first impression when we walked in was how comfortable and friendly the atmosphere was. We were greeted right away by the owner Bob. Ordered some wine and a few appetizers which included the clams oreganata, fried calamari, and eggplant rollatini. Excellent! The pasta and seafood entrees we had were even better. Definitely recommend Plum Tomatoes to everyone!
D Pick
I am a resident of Nebraska. I've never been to Plum, but through a mutual friend it has come to my attention. They raved about the cleanliness and service but most of all the PIZZA!!
You may think "Nebraska? What would he know about pizza, that's not corn or steaks." But I'm here to tell you I've sampled pizza from around the globe. It's not always easy to find a good one. So when you do you tell EVERYONE.
If/when I make plans to come out east I will make sure that, due to extreme recommendation, I stop by Plum Tomatoes even if it's out of my way, to eat one of everything!
AJ Jordan
Came in because I love Italian food and I heard alot of good feedback about Plum Tomatoes. Had the chicken parm entree & a large cannoli. The cannoli is truly awesome, considering it had chocolate chips in the creme and I'm a chocolate fiend, so that was a huge plus. This would be a nice place to take someone for dinner. The chicken parm actually tasted better to me when I saved my lunch & had it reheated later on to finish it for dinner. Definitely will come back and a shout out to Bob who is the owner and a nice guy.
Deshaun McClelland
Came in with my girlfriend and the food was outstanding. Waiter demonstrated marvelous customer service and was definitely the dining experience I needed for a good dinner. Will be coming back.
Damon Parthesius
I frequently eat at Plum Tomatoes and both the food and service are as good as it gets. That says a lot since I'm from Brooklyn!
5 stars and 2 thumbs-up!
Fred Luhn
DELICIOUS food. Reasonable prices. FAST delivery and a wonderful caring staff. A+++ Try the Shrimp parm hero and fried calamari! Eating there 3+ years and they are amazing.
Larry Kaye
First time at Plum Tomatoes and consider myself a pizza aficionado. This place is definitely one of the best places I have been too! The sauce on the sicilian is excellent and the buffalo specialty pie is a home run! Highly recommend!
Argelia Guzman
From the clams oreganata to the veal piccata we had a great experience at Plum Tomatoes. The fresh cannolis were really good. Our waitress Stephanie was very attentive and offered some good recommendations including the carafes of wine! Highly recommend this place
Tara B
Come to Plum Tomatoes regularly and the food and service is excellent! Love their grilled salmon and shrimp parm entrees. Highly recommend this place!
Bkfucci
Been here 3x. I am sorry but it's really hard to find a place where the Italian sauce is good! Their food is good minus the red sauce. I've had their chicken With lemon sauce and it was amazing. Their red Italian sauce is way too spicy and acidity.
AJ Jordan
Absolutely the best Italian food I've had in a long time. Everything is homemade, dish's are made to order. Service was phenomenal, couldn't ask for a more pleasant experience. All in all very good portions for a decent price. Absolutely worth every penny, will definitely be returning
Ronans220
This is one of my favorite restaurants. Bob the owner is exceptionally thoughtful and always greets the customers with a smile. The food is excellent and always consistent. A gem of a restaurant!
Vaccarodonna98
The best pizza around and there are a lot of good pizza places in the area. Really great variety of slices, the staff is always friendly and helpful and the newly renovated building looks amazing.
Jillian Smolen
Wonderful gluten free pasta dish! Really enjoyed our meal. Great portion size not to big.
Brandon Lang
MUST TRY!!. The Owners are new as of 2013 and the have turned this place into an amazing family restaurant. I usually get pizza slices like all their chicken slices and the best Buffalo Chicken pizza I have ever had in my life and I grew up in NYC and Plum Tomatoes is better the NYC pizza! Their salads are delicious and there such a crazy variety of them. My favorite is the Grilled Seafood Salad and the Flame Roasted Corn Salad! The service will literally cater to anything you could ask for! Its right by Mineola Train Station so I'm always stopping by before the train, its only a 3 minute walk. Im so happy this place has great food and I know they'll be around for a long time! MUST TRY
Brett
Owners Bob and Bryan bring excellent service and great food back to Plum Tomatoes! Definitely a must have constantly!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes