My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 12 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in United States
Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Mineola
There are 12 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Ardito's Italian American Deli
95
/100 (254 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"Outstanding Italian deli. Family owned and operated. Simply delicious. I am a big fan of this Italian deli. It's a great neighborhood spot that..."
Christopher J. Pizzo
"This is a special place, the food is incredible. The hot bar or sandwiches you can’t go wrong, and you can tell there’s a lot of years of Italian..."
Eric Wendt
"First time here, it was a pleasure from entering to leaving, bought two my way heroes(self created)omg... it was worth it, I only ate half, could not..."
Indira Singh
"Great food! Historical family business... Fresh food and products Has the best Italian dishes also available through catering. Kind..."
T Black
"Is this Tommy Arditos from Flushing NY? If so , I used to love the pizza from the window. Their Italian Ices were the best back in the..."
Eileen Shea
"Ardito's serves classic Italian cuisine packed with flavor at fair prices. The quality ingredients are obvious in every bite and the portion sizes..."
Cristian Castro
"Great hot lunch selection. Also terrific deli sandwich selection that they can make on the spot. Not cheap, but the quality to price makes sense..."
Joseph L
"Excellent food! Lovely people. My highest..."
Evan
"The best on Long Island. Don't come. I don't want to wait in line. I'm not kidding. A $10 hero feeds 4. A $10 lunch that player easily feed..."
David Farrell
"Great old school Italian delicatessen with excellent hot food, great sandwiches and wonderful..."
Thami Stafyleras
Piccolo's Of Mineola
92
/100 (496 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Chicken Parmesan
Artichoke Ravioli
Pollo Zingarella
Shrimp
Stuffed Veal
Prosciutto and Mozzarella
A Combo of Duck Pumpkin and Chestnut Ravioli in Their Famous Triple Sec Cream Sauce
Pasta
Duck
Pesto
Gnocchi
Garlic bread
Broccoli
Tortilla Soup
Cheese Cake
Orange Sorbet
Pumpkin Ravioli
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The best and affordable place for wedding reception…We have privacy to only for our wedding way back 2019. I just had the chance to give review and..."
HelenofTroynUSA
"Just had my work holiday party here and it was fantastic!! The food, service and restaurant atmosphere were all so wonderful. The Chicken Zingarella..."
Lauren Banzer
"Tonight was my second time at Piccolo’s and it has not disappointed. The food is absolutely delicious (especially the chicken zingarella and the..."
Meredith Brooks
"Homely Italian restaurant with Italian sound, Italian aroma and taste. We ordered a Chianti wine that accompanied the excellent dishes, the homemade..."
shai shani
"A true hidden gem that has been serving authentic Italian food for over 30 plus years in Mineola. With Robert Sr. and another son taking care of FOH..."
J
"The food is wonderful, expensive but no more than any great restaurant🍷If you are ready to treat yourself this is your place. BTW….the service..."
dot newell
"Stopped to check it out for a party. Very nice friendly & helpful staff, everything smelled great. I look forward to dining..."
TJ Jones
"The raviolis was excellent and so was the service . new to coming to the restaurant but grew up in the area. definitely will be..."
Michelle Clifford
"Went here for a surprise birthday party for my Bestie. The service was great. Atmosphere pleasant, quick and attentive. We all had a great time of..."
Therisa Hemingway
"A jewel box. A real find of amazing food, both selection, presention, and deliciousness. The staff was attentive and so very..."
Deniseplllplio8l Enright
"First time at Piccolos and I will definitely go back.. food was excellent and place was buzzing. Staff was friendly and made great suggestions off..."
Joseph Mastriano
"Homemade raviolis are a must. Loved the pollo zingarella. Split them both and it was the perfect portion. Also really enjoyed the bread served in the..."
Mandy K
"The staff is really friendly and attentive. The home made bread never stops, and the ravioli is..."
Christine McGovern, LMT
"Food was so delicious and big portions, the service was excellent. Would recommend to everyone we're definitely going back..."
Robert m Waddell
"Outstanding customer service and authentic, original, amazing food. They were so accommodating and friendly and a pleasure to dine with. We had a..."
Trent M
"They are wonderful. Great food, great service, and great people. Robert and his dad are amazing people. I recently had a dinner party for my..."
B C
"Wonderful family run restaurant. Food is always top notch, fresh and..."
alice connors
Barosa
87
/100 (146 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
"Had the best tasting generously-sized chicken parm hero ever at Barosa! Minestrone soup was excellent too. Will return to try an entree although the..."
Mona Reich
"Awesome food! Amazing service. Louis rocked and our hosts were..."
Carrie's Berrys
"Food was tasty. Pricing was moderate. Clean, local eatery in..."
John Fuentes
"We are so happy that we found this place!! It has become our new local standard for amazing Italian food. Louis and Joe are amazing and everyone here..."
Robert Horton
"The reason I'm giving a 4 and not a 5 star rating is because I've only had the pizza, but I'm sure the food is wonderful as well seeing how clean and..."
Paul Paiva
"Good, old-school, welcoming NY pizzeria. Crust is flavorful, toppings are generous yet balanced. I loved my veggie slice, whose lack of sauce..."
Mg 0
"We moved here from Queens about a year ago and it took us a few months to find “our pizza” and Barosa is it. Straight forward great sauce, cheese..."
Katie Cropper Klein
"Great Chicken & Broccoli slice! Crust and bedding are just right; not too soft and not too rough. You can eat it with one hand the way it is supposed..."
G. M.
"Ordered for work and the pizza was hot and delicious. The garlic knows are to die for and the red sauce 10 stars. The driver forgot the crushed red..."
Rachel Tinch
"I have only had the pizza so can’t speak for the other food, but the pizza is by far my favorite in the area. Also friendly, gracious service...."
Joe Murray
"This old standby has been around for many years. Pizzeria in the front of the restaurant and tables in the back. Tired dated decor. But the quality..."
W Renfield Lewis
"Very nice Italian restaurant with old school charm with modern Italian flavors. Must have calamari in Champaign sauce with homemade pasta...."
Michael Robinson
"We go there every week we love the place the food is excellent the service even..."
Billy Hine
"Interesting restaurant, because when you enter, you have the fast-food Pizzeria part where you can grab a quick bite and then, in the back, you have..."
Nicolas Vincent
"We order from here at least once a week. Everything has been fantastic and they have THE BEST Calamari! I've never once been disappointed in their..."
Ashley Genova (Ashley G)
"First time ordering from here and the food was fantastic! Prices are very fair and they give large portions. All of the food has a lot of flavor and..."
Matthew Kohl
"Great service and food. We only came here because of a Groupon cash back deal, but we’re so glad we did. It felt like we were transported to..."
Lauren Marzo
Luigi's Pizzeria Of Mineola
86
/100 (1184 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Luigi’s pizzeria has delicious food! My favorites are the Milanese wrap and the buffalo chicken..."
Kareea Mabery
"Luigis has so many great pies to chose from. The eggplant pizza is amazing and vegetable pie. The penne a la vodka is delicious and lots of great..."
Danielle Gaudio-Lalehzar
"A great place to meet up with friends and family for some wonderful food and fantastic service. Not only that, your support of them thsnks them for..."
Kathleen Walsh Rodgers
"Best service, great food and when my travel baseball team ask for food for our fund raiser, they didn't even hesitate to help. They asked how many..."
Richard A. Macchietto
"Can't get enough of the Blazing Buffalo Slice with a side of Bleu Cheese. That's why I always order two..."
Thomas Michael
"Excellent quality food. Great atmosphere. Top notch..."
Niko Catalano
"Come here almost every Friday. My one and only issue (Not really a big deal) CHAIRS ARE TO..."
Howard Fahner
"The really cute guys behind the counter are always so friendly and serve great tasting..."
Amanda Giordano
"Hey how can I apply!! Love the pizza!!! I love..."
Jess Taylor
"Yummy everything I am trying every time different things all r..."
Anju Sharma
"Best pizza around..."
Laura Pinciotto-Bury
"Ordered via Seamless. Penne all vodka was great, reheated and finished all of it in a few days. There wasn’t any meat/prosciutto in the pasta so..."
Erma Ameen
"The foods are very good, the price are reasonable, will come back..."
Mandy Li
"I came in close to closing and they were so accommodating. Insisted that they make me the rolls I asked about. To my surprise, they sent home an..."
Laura Paulson-Bromberg
"Went here last week, for a business meeting with a potential new client. The place was very upscale and had very new decor. I loved the vibe walking..."
Jiovani Rivera
"The food from the pizza to the pasta was good. Easy to park and lots of room to eat. I thought their pizza was ok. The staff was nice. a bit..."
Jacob Domosh
"Had a pepperoni slice, really good pizza! It just annoying when you cannot browse…you have one of the staff attacking you with ((can I help..."
Erick O
"I just moved to Mineola in January ( still exploring the area ). I stopped in a couple months back for a couple slices of pizza for lunch, and really..."
Jason Conboy
"One of the most delicious Pizza and wraps. Many food selection and great service. Very clean and well-spaced tables &..."
Hiyam H
"Great pizza and classic Italian entrees. Self seating dining with hightops, tables, window bar seating. Food is prepared and brought to your..."
Mark S
"Great pizza with many toppings, amazing pastas, and salads. Everything is fresh, and the dining room is clean. Excellent customer service. Ample..."
V Glln
"We’re new to the area as we have a few projects we’re building. Always great to find a local place that serves quality food. Amazing management..."
Dave Castel
"Visiting from South Carolina. We had an awesome experience here! Great food, friendly staff, and environment and decor was perfect. Best pepperoni..."
Adam Ramsey
"Big S/O to Luigi's for taking care of the crew tonight. Your service was great and the food was fantastic. Can't thank you enough. We'll be back for..."
Patrick Blum
"So I’ve been eating from this place for a long time. The food has always been consistent. Tonight I went in to pick up my take out order and made..."
David Blitz
"Easy to order take out! Got a small 10” pepperoni pizza + pineapple & 10” buffalo chicken pizza. Tasted really..."
Kelly Yang
Cugini Pizzeria & Restaurant
85
/100 (1682 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"🔔Update Sept 2023: Cuginis is open again with signs saying under new management. Had the same thing I’ve had here for the past 15 years and..."
Eric Go
"I was out with my grands and looking for a place to have lunch. Cugini is a moderate size Pizzeria with a restaurant dining room attached. I had the..."
Andre Vialet
"Delicious pizza; also, nice atmosphere friendly counter, plenty of..."
Richard Wagner
"One of my favorite pizzerias in the area since I was a kid. Sicilian slices and Margarita pizza are the definite..."
Jonathan Kaufman
"Wonderful pizzeria and restaurant! The BEST local pizza with a nice variety of special slices! Also, in the back is a wonderful restaurant area with..."
Dr. Peter Osroff
"The staff was super friendly and the pizza was delicious. It tasted fresh and it was the perfect ratio with the sauce and..."
Atiya Mohamed (Tya)
"Great pizza. The buffalo chicken is my go to. They gotta put back up the autographed picture of Ralph Maccio aka the karate kid..."
Declan Durcan
"I recently had to change pizza places from Gino's of Carl place to Cugini, Cugini being the closest pizza joint. Gino's was apparently too far away..."
Bryan Dasilva
"Dont miss this place if you can. Food was..."
Armand Grasso
"Very good chicken and bacon slice. Nice cozy space and seems to be family..."
Fuin Fuan Store
"This place is more than decent. Went on a whim and was not disappointed one bit. It is not the best, but trust me it is far from the worst or even..."
rick verga
La Bottega
83
/100 (87 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Italian
"Great selection of paninis. Fresh cut of mozzarella on the paninis, which I appreciate but it was very bland. If they can work on this I'll give 5..."
Abigail Soper
"Great stop for lunch in the middle of the day. Try the Pietra! I haven't tried the lunch special but a regular panini is more than enough..."
Joseph
"I love the food here. it's one of the best La Bottega restaurants around. The food is clean and very tasty. They prepare the food with..."
Cole T
"The breakfast options are prepared well and made fresh. Service is good. Excellent..."
katherine kelly
"Great food and priced just right for a hidden..."
Tim Timbo
"Great spot to grab a panini. Excited to check out and try their breakfast..."
Joe DiVerniero
"Really good pasta dishes. Only issue is that it's a little pricy for the portion..."
David Amatulli
"Good food but..."
Alexis Corbisiero
"Great food. Large portions. Friendly..."
Ricky B
"The lunch was delicious and fresh, highly..."
Paul Buckley
"Enjoyable staff and very good panini..."
Anthony Onorato
"Fresh, delicious, and a good price for the..."
Joe Rispoli
"Good food, good..."
Jim Brady
"Food is good. Service needs..."
Eve Seidman
"One of Mineola's best lunch..."
Christopher Caputo
"Really enjoy the breakfast..."
Shaun McDowell
"Deliciously consistent quick..."
Paul Weston
"Food is always..."
Jennifer Fermin-Solon
Cassariano
83
/100 (2272 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Polenta
Pesto
Fish
Pork
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Chose Cassariano for my wife’s 50th birthday party. They accommodated over 30 people on a Saturday night. Everyone had a great time. The food was..."
Elmer Detres
"Food was fresh and delicious! Wait staff were prompt, efficient, very friendly and accommodating. The bar is well stocked and drinks were delicious..."
Donna Freund- Anderson
"The food here is top of the charts. The service is second to none and the staff makes you feel like you are at home. I recommend this place to..."
John Marsala
"One of the most awesome restaurants you could go to!!! From Billy, the owner, Giancarlo another owner & chef to the atmosphere to the food...it..."
Maureen Farrelly Marsala
"The food was cooked to perfection and the atmosphere was sublime. Our waiter was very peasant and sweet. I highly recommend this restaurant. I can't..."
Margaret Fuiaxis Katranis
"The food was amazing, truly a gastronomic feast. The service was impeccable! Excellent wine selection. Cant say enough wonderful things about..."
Dina Grgas
"My husband and I went to have dinner last week... the food and service were indescribably delicious. Unbeknownst to my husband, I had already hired..."
Nikole DeLuca
"fantastic food !!!excellent service from waiter to the manager and the owner very friendly and accommodating. very clean atmosphere food very..."
Yolie Vicencio
"Delicious food, ample portions, attentive staff, nice atmosphere. We couldn't decide which of our 6 dinners we liked better...."
Patty Barlow
"Had a great dinner at cassariano and the service was excellent! Daniel took great care of us and the food was exceptional from the appetizers down to..."
Anthony Capotosto
"I was at Cassariano and I can say it was the best restaurant I ever been on Long Island. The menu was very different then any other place and the..."
Gappsi Giuseppe Abbrancati
"Had the lamb shank. OUTSTANDING!!! Other entrees that were ordered were the duck, branzino and papardelle. All plates were totally clean at the..."
Mike Yakiemchuk
"The inside is loud, probably great for parties and if you're looking for a high energy atmosphere. The outside area is nice but unfortunately the..."
Frank Morgano
"Awesome spot ! Ate here for the first time this evening and was seated promptly and our party of 8 were lucky enough to get seated in the glass room..."
Enzo Chiaramonte
"I had my bridal shower here in October and I have to say Danny made it amazing! Everything came together beautifully! All 4 courses came on time and..."
Marina Colletti
"So lucky to have stumbled across this hidden gem recently. My wife and I had other dinner plans that fell through and we found this place on the map..."
Kenneth Malley
"All I can say is thank you with the sincerest gratitude. We had our daughters first birthday party here today and everything was absolutely..."
Megumi Mase
"Absolutely perfect gem of Long Island. The food is consistently perfect, the service even when busy is always great. Nelson (head server) always..."
David Keelor
"Fun place, lively atmosphere on a Friday night. Excellent for large groups and celebrations. Very nice staff and service, they all do their best to..."
Ravi Gupta
"We had our office dinner. Food is..."
Keisha Williams
"I had our wedding here during the pandemic and it was more than I expected!!! 🤵♂️👰♀💍Great food, great service, and great venue..."
Tae Kim
"I have only ever gotten the family meal to go so I cannot speak for the dine-in experience. However, the family meal is FANTASTIC! It can easily feed..."
Emily Schiller
Spaghettini Pizza Trattoria
82
/100 (1336 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This place is a hidden gem!! Though the food was outstanding the service was excellent!! I have to say I had the best chicken parm ever!!!! I can't..."
Ron Wilson
"I ordered takeout from here before, I loved the pizza! It was really delicious and the sauce to cheese ratio was perfection. Me and my boyfriend..."
Atiya Mohamed (Tya)
"Cute outdoor tented seating area. Very good service and attentive staff. Excellent calamari. Meat selection was mediocre- ordered the Osso Bucco and..."
Michelle Mascioli
"I went into Spaghettini the other night for dinner, I had the Tomato Mozzarella and then the Chicken Marsala. The food was delicious and the staff..."
Bruce Grant
"Had the best dinner outside under the tent. We started with pizzettas, burrata salad, calamari, and rice ball all were excellent! For dinner we had..."
Robert Janecek
"Great place, delicious food and waiters really kind. Life music perfect. What else can you ask? Me and my husband spend a great time. Definitely we..."
Adriana Argudo
"I order a salad. I was surprised at how fresh and seasoned the chicken was. And how large the portion was. Would definitely..."
Cole T
"Very convenient pizzeria with a great Caesar salad..."
Max Cohn
"Excellent place. Had my wife's birthday party here. Very welcoming. My wife said it's probably the best penne a la vodka she's ever had. Excellent..."
Joe Gebke
"Place was amazing and food was amazing and service was amazing. Good eats all..."
Jaime Santiago
"Great food! The staff was wonderful, fast, friendly service. We'll be going back for..."
Joe M
"It's very clean, and it was nice and quiet that..."
Lynn Wegner
"Since it opened, Spaghettini has become a regular restaurant that I visit – either in person or to get takeout. I have always been impressed, not..."
Jonathan Baker
"Delicious Italian American food. Penne alla vodka was exceptionally tasty. Grilled lamb chops were cooked perfectly. Highly..."
SK Song
"I love this place ! Everyone is so kind and food is amazing! I absolutely love to dine here once a week. Chicken rolls are delicious. Thank you for..."
Amanda Acevedo
"What a great experience! Excellent attention Our waitress very nice girl Delicious sangria Perfect to feel happy this special..."
Vickicita
"Excellent food and reasonable prices. ..."
Handz Productionz
Eric's Italian Bistro
79
/100 (1024 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Martini
Sangria
Mesclun Salad Mussels Bianco
Pinot Noir
Pumpkin soup
Double Espresso
Sole meuniere
Veal Parmigiana
Red wine
Chick
Tiramisú
Lasagne
Meatballs
Hot Bread
Baked Clams Oreganata
Caprese Chicken Paillard
Grandma's Lasagna
Grandma Sausage
Pasta
Veal Monachina
Salad
Wine from Chile
Lasagne
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great food. Lamb shank special was excellent. And so was our waiter, Nicholas. Very friendly staff and a menu that allows you to go "old school"..."
James M. Sherry
"I've been to probably 300 Italian restaurants on Long Island and I can truthfully say I haven't had this much fun in a while with my family drinking..."
John Wood
"Cozy restaurant with an attentive staff and absolutely delicious food...from appetizers of flat bread with tomato and mozzarella and fried calamari,..."
Cenza D'Avella Dziorny
"We love. Eric’s and staff is great and amazing the food is amazing taste great George is amazing and so..."
Barbara Ann Mallon
"Excellent service. Friendly staff. Good food. Fair prices. Nice atmosphere. Great for a romantic dinner or a family..."
Patrick Morales
"Best monk fish and capalini cakes I had in my life...."
Gary Jacobs
"Had my first Ladies Luncheon here and the owner George was very accommodating, helpful and professional. The food was great, the atmosphere..."
Karen Carter
"Marvelous restaurant. Amazing environment. Great service. Well recommended by many. The owner is very welcoming, definitely a place to visit for any..."
Luis Payano
"Love this place! Love bringing me girlfriends or family here!..."
Ivette Echeverria
"Great Food, Great Staff ... Best Eating Experience One Could Have..."
Toots Parver
"Superbly wonderful food and the service Olson. My reconocimientos... K viva Eric's Italian..."
Luis Gomez
"The best Italian restaurant of Long..."
Guillermo Cortés
"The food was delicious and the service was good. But, for a fine dinning restaurant I felt we were rushed through dinner. We had a three course meal..."
donna dee
"Holy moly! I always wondered why the place was always packed! Now I understand. The food was amazing and the place is actually really spacious, from..."
Jiovani Rivera
"Tonight was my first time at this restaurant. The host, Frank was friendly and personable. This was the best service I have ever experienced. Our..."
Allyson Vanderclock
"Purchased a Groupon deal and this family owned bistro didn’t disappoint. The owner and staff are extremely pleasant and gave us the true sense of..."
Jesse Yuan
"Had a wonderful dinner at Eric's Bistro. Haven't been there in a while and they have not lost their touch..We were warmly greeted by Frank , the..."
Howard Rothenberg
"Absolutely PERFECT meal. From beginning to end. We started with the baked classic which were so tasty then she had shrimp scampi and I had a steak...."
sethrock1
"Food is excellent and staff is A+. On the pricey side. But you do get what you pay for. Excellent..."
michael laird
"Wonderful place, can't wait to go back. Don't get fooled by outside, plenty if quiet, peaceful space to enjoy your..."
Joseph Malandruccolo
"The food was SO FRESH! The environment was so relaxing and a perfect date spot. The servers were also incredibly welcoming and attentive. Great..."
Ben F
"Great restaurant! Food and service was so awesome when I went in for lunch, that I had to come back the next night and do the full dinner experience...."
DnD_Beyond_Is_Bad
"Food was great, staff friendly, enjoyed our time there. We go as often as we..."
Helen Hartmann
"AMAZING SERVICE both times, from start to finish it was amazing. The attentiveness to detail was perfect. They are extremely nice and cater to kids...."
Patricia Annie Castellano
"We have been driving past this spot almost daily for a year. It's always decorated very festively on the outside, and always seems very inviting. The..."
Zack McCabe
"The first time I visited, the food was delicious, and the presentation was family style due to a large business meeting in a separate room great for..."
Laurie Bahna
"8/10/2020 We visited Eric's twice in the past three weeks. Happy to report the food is up to their usual high standard. We had lunch at first, then..."
Ed Franmel
Piccola Bussola Restaurant
79
/100 (1388 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Clams
Calamari
Risotto
Calamares
Meatballs
Pesto
Shrimp
Fish
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Private Dining
Valet Parking
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Our second time dinning there and just as excellent as the first. The food from the appetizers , salad too the main entree was superb. Service was..."
Doug Griffin
"Mineola is filled with a lot of good restaurants. This Italian restaurant is pretty good. We tried their octopus app and shrimp entree. Both were..."
Sadh Nafee M Khan
"Had there my son first communion great food old school Italian style,would definitely go back..."
Ivica Gruban
"My family and I celebrated my uncles 80th Birthday! Great food and..."
Corinne Fiamma
"Food is amazing and staff is very attentive. Just a great experience evey..."
Roy DiMarco
"Not only is the service excellent, the food is..."
Myrna Katz Morris
"Really enjoyed "Comedy Night". The food was really good❗️The service, as always, was professional and the comedy was LOL funny. Tony you and..."
Amy Brothman Thompson
"Hands down the best Italian food; the owner and his staff are a phenomenal bunch. Never once was I..."
Eric Schueler
"We had our annual Christmas luncheon at Piccola Bussola on 12/4/16 and had delicious food served by an attentive wait staff. Everyone enjoyed..."
Carl Marchese
"This Spanish restaurant is pretty good. We tried their octopus app and shrimp entree. Both were delicious and the staff is very cordial and..."
nafSadh
"We were there for a wedding rehearsal dinner. Food was very good, dessert was an assortment of many items, see photo. Wait staff was excellent and..."
Steven E
"Nice restaurant that is prefect for a big gathering with their family style..."
Joe DiVerniero
"Went here for the office Christmas party. We went here last year also. The food as usual was EXCELLENT. Every meal served was exceptional. ..."
Joanne
"I was there for a meeting last night. We often have meetings at dinner venues but this location was better than most. The room was quiet and..."
Keith Niesenbaum
"Food was good, service good. Drinks were very good. We went on Valentine's day, they gave us chocolate covered strawberries and gave my wife a rose..."
Rich Terrana
"Great tasting food, group style plating, so family and the like, will enjoy themselves. Dining room has warmth and appeal. Servers are more on the..."
Martha Nelson
"Outstanding Italian restaurant. Upscale drawing a trendy crowd. Ultra attentive wait staff with great selection of Italian cuisine and assorted..."
Bruce John
"This is a wonderful neighborhood Italian restaurant with generous portions served family style, a warm ambiance, and excellent service. I highly..."
Sophie Wang
"Where do I start! I had my daughters Bridal Shower of 72 woman. First and foremost Tony, the owner is truly a gentleman and made my daughter's Bridal..."
Mary Lynn Giocastro
Nicks Tuscan Grill
77
/100 (282 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Shrimp
Pasta
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Had a great experience at Nick’s. The saffron risotto underneath my osso bucco was perfect. The shank itself was cooked just right. The menu was..."
Chris Miller
"Great local lunch spot. Good is excellent. Service is solid. A little pricey but worth..."
Rafe Lieber
"I visited this cute spot on a Tuesday night. A few tables were there, but not too busy. Waitstaff consisted of only two people but still the..."
Megan Dunphy
"I am giving this place a two thumbs up and a five star review. The Seafood Arrabbiata is amazing. The Chicken Franchise is excellent. The place is..."
Honey Fame
"NICK'S served delicious food. Drinks as well. Went recently during week and sadly empty. This place is worth spending a little extra. Waiter was..."
Jeannie Noriega
"Excellent food, drinks and service..."
Esz Serrata
"Food was cooked and seasoned very well. Plate presentation was normal. Ambiance was warm and comfy. Prices were mid range and what you would expect...."
Archer Tbk9
"Excellent. I don't remember the name of what I ordered, but it was boneless chicken breast with mushrooms and sausage all sliced so perfectly thin..."
Diane Lulley
"Delightful ambiance, good Italian food, and hospitality await you here. The menu has many sumptuous options, and we enjoyed Calamari and nicely..."
Jacqueline Vita
"Great Italian food. Good friendly service. Staff always willing to please. Good for a special occasion dinner. Good pricing for portions. Very..."
MARIA AMICO
"Loni had not only a great attitude, but went above and beyond to make our experience an unforgettable one. The food was spectacular and seasoned to..."
Chano Don
"Great little place in the heart of Mineola. We ended up there unexpectedly on New Year's Eve and didn't have reservations. The place was very busy..."
Joe Caraccia
"Great place to eat have a drink!! Very clean!! Nice soft music great hospitality!! Awesome place I’ll definitely recommend to anybody great food..."
Joel Estevez
"Excellent Food, Outstanding service and have been there many times and have always had great food and not over priced. Highly..."
Toby Horowitz TMH
"Was exactly as website shown, as far as atmosphere, very nice. Choice of food items very good. Food it self was great and good portions. Service was..."
Gordon Aberbach
Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant
77
/100 (155 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast Food
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
"First time at Plum Tomatoes and consider myself a pizza aficionado. This place is definitely one of the best places I have been too! The sauce on the..."
Larry Kaye
"From the clams oreganata to the veal piccata we had a great experience at Plum Tomatoes. The fresh cannolis were really good. Our waitress Stephanie..."
Argelia Guzman
"Come to Plum Tomatoes regularly and the food and service is excellent! Love their grilled salmon and shrimp parm entrees. Highly recommend this..."
Tara B
"Been here 3x. I am sorry but it's really hard to find a place where the Italian sauce is good! Their food is good minus the red sauce. I've had their..."
Bkfucci
"Absolutely the best Italian food I've had in a long time. Everything is homemade, dish's are made to order. Service was phenomenal, couldn't ask for..."
AJ Jordan
"This is one of my favorite restaurants. Bob the owner is exceptionally thoughtful and always greets the customers with a smile. The food is excellent..."
Ronans220
"The best pizza around and there are a lot of good pizza places in the area. Really great variety of slices, the staff is always friendly and helpful..."
Vaccarodonna98
"Wonderful gluten free pasta dish! Really enjoyed our meal. Great portion size not to..."
Jillian Smolen
"MUST TRY!!. The Owners are new as of 2013 and the have turned this place into an amazing family restaurant. I usually get pizza slices like all their..."
Brandon Lang
"Owners Bob and Bryan bring excellent service and great food back to Plum Tomatoes! Definitely a must have..."
Brett
"First off the staff was very friendly, pizza is displayed and everything to me looks very appetizing. I had the buffalo slice and a beef patty( yes a..."
Derek Draiz
"I have tried a wide variety of dishes and pizza from Plum Tomatoes and I can tell you that this is absolutely fresh, homemade food. You can taste the..."
Miss Conduct
"I love this place. I work locally and eat here at least 3 times week. Great salads. The best buffalo pizza around. They are always creating..."
eltorretta
"First time at Plum Tomatoes and consider myself a pizza aficionado. This place is definitely one of the best places I have been too! The sauce on the..."
Larry Kaye
"Great pizza place, but it loses a star for being inconsistent. Sometimes the quality if a plain pie is great from here, other times it suffers from..."
Zaeem Nazir
"A fairly ordinary pizzeria. I liked that they seemed to anticipate what I might want. I ordered an unsweet iced tea and they offered to put some..."
R. Drew Davis
"Simply the Best Pizza in all of Long Island. Ordered their famous Buffalo Chicken pizza and no other place I have gone too compares! By far one of..."
Tara Berman
"Went to Plum Tomatoes for the first time today to celebrate my birthday with the family. Our first impression when we walked in was how comfortable..."
Deborah Cerreta
"I am a resident of Nebraska. I've never been to Plum, but through a mutual friend it has come to my attention. They raved about the cleanliness and..."
D Pick
"Came in because I love Italian food and I heard alot of good feedback about Plum Tomatoes. Had the chicken parm entree & a large cannoli. The..."
AJ Jordan
"Came in with my girlfriend and the food was outstanding. Waiter demonstrated marvelous customer service and was definitely the dining experience I..."
Deshaun McClelland
"I frequently eat at Plum Tomatoes and both the food and service are as good as it gets. That says a lot since I'm from Brooklyn! 5 stars and 2..."
Damon Parthesius
"DELICIOUS food. Reasonable prices. FAST delivery and a wonderful caring staff. A+++ Try the Shrimp parm hero and fried calamari! Eating there 3+..."
Fred Luhn
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes