The food here is so good I can't even discribe it! The crust on their pies is the best I've ever had! The people are great and the owner Sam is so sweet!
The best store ever. The pies are great reminds of growing in up England and buying pies from the chip store
We love the pie store. Tried six or seven different kinds and we really liked them all. The soccer pie in particular is really good and they key lime pie is excellent.
Love this shop. On a rainy day there's nothing better than a chana masala pie and carrot ginger soup 😋
I've been going here for years now. The authentic English pies do not disappoint. Also has a small but varied selection of imported UK foods, snacks and drinks. All pies are made in house and not one of them can do you wrong. The Tayto Beef and Onion chips go well with the Turkey and Stuffing pie, which has cranberries mixed into it for the full Thanksgiving experience. The Steak, Ale, & Mushroom pie is another good choice.
Omg they're amazing! Such kind, sweet people and absolutely delicious pies, savory or sweet. They were so kind to throw in a pie fresh out of the oven, and it was amazing just like they said! We tried the apple-cranberry-blackberry pie, the one with chicken coconut curry, and the Cornish pasty. All delicious. I also very much appreciate the covid precautions they are taking. Only 1 person/party in at a time and everyone wears a mask. You guys are fantastic, we sure will be back soon! Thank you!
Fantastic small pie shoppe.... specializing in English type pastries and pies...but with a nice variety. Please, please try the Thanksgiving turkey pie.... fabulous!!
I love everything about the Pie Store, except the line! I sure wish they'd sort out a prepay / pickup window option. I go half as often as I would otherwise. Key lime, chocolate mousse, and chicken pot pie are our go-tos.
If pies are your thing, or even if you crave a delish slice of pie (and the City is too much a hassle to visit one of its many bakeries), and you love a good English pasties, this is there best place in North Jersey, and hands down one of the best places for pie in the area. Also, their Strawberry Scones are to die for.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes