The crust and cheese put them above the rest in the area if you like New York style (real) pizza. Really, the crust makes it (order well-done if you get carryout - counter the steam in the box) but the cheese and other ingredients are really top notch.
This is the closest I can get to home out here in Cincinnati. Born a d raised on Long Island and I moved here 3 years ago for a job. Walking in it smells like a pizza place from home. They have pizza by the slice and it's done just right. I've read a few of the bad reviews and they all have one thing in common. They've clearly never had real NYC pizza.
This is quite simply what pizza is supposed to taste like. This is what every other pizza place in the area is trying to taste like.
This is one of the best pizzas I have ever had! Definitively not a chain-type place. So bored with the run of the mill pizza spots in Cincy. I highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta for great tasting NY style pizza!
Seriously the best lasagna I've ever tasted!! The portion was so massive I had to take half home for dinner!!
Michael C. Bannister Sr.
+5
The best place to grab a slice of pie on the go or for dining in!
I love their Baked Ziti with the garlic knots and Meatball.
Best place in town. If you love pizza & wings, you'll love theirs. �������� Staff, Service and Food, is always exceptional. Keep up the greatness & tastefulness of your business.
Brooklyn Pizza and Pasta has fantastic food! Their pizza IS.THE.BEST! There is something about a freshly made pizza that the chains just can't compete with! My family always agrees on Brooklyn's.
Don't have to say much. All I have to say is that if you know why New Yorkers love their hometown pizza, this is the joint for you. For all others, I invite you to taste what the best pizza in the world tastes like.
Best food ever! Huge portions at a low price! My boyfriend and I decided to stop in on a whim as we were driving past. Staff was super friendly! We will be going back for sure!
Eat here all the time! Great lunch specials and the pizza is the best in Cincinnati!!
Our family favorite. Large cheese, wings, and a black and white cookie. Nostalgic. If you are from upstate NY, east coast, NYC, this is as close as it comes here in Cincinnati.
Love the pizza! Nice thin foldable crust. Great Italian sauce and quality toppings. We get a large - half Mattie and half Bronx. Yum!
My go-to place for pizza. This is the place to go in Cincinnati for pizza that isn't mass-produced by transient hourly workers that were working in a grocery last week. Great quality ingredients and a perfect New York-style recipe make this our favorite by far.
As others have said, the store itself isn't a fancy place to have lunch or dinner, but if you want great pizza at a good price this is it.
Best crust in town & by the slice. I work in the area and started going to Brooklyn Pizza when it was still known as Noce's. In Cincinnati, most pizza options are chain places and one is just as good or bad as the other. Brooklyn Pizza, on the other hand, is around the same price point as those places but is much more than a step above - especially if you like the crispy and chewy crust found on the East Coast. I like blanco pizza and it's a testament to the quality of their ingredients that a simple slice of blanco hits a spot that others fail so miserably at getting to. It's the ingredients and attention to recipe.
Also, for lunch, they sell a variety of slices for less than most fast food burgers. They don't just warm them up when you order, they take that extra minute or so in the hot oven to get them back to crispy crust where the cheeses remelt to their soft stringy goodness (even good for carryout which I often get).
Ambiance? It's a pizza place in a strip mall like many pizza places so I don't place a high bar on ambiance. But, they have a ESPN on a few flat screens throughout the place which I always like and they'll change channels to your favorite game upon request.
Customer. Best place for pizza in the area bar none. Great crust and sauce plus inventive toppings. Caramelized onions are the bomb. We want to try the pasta but never get past the pizza.
It was OK for lunch. I wouldn't say the pizza is great but its fine for lunch. Would I go back...no. There are other pizza places closer that are the same or better quality. Flying Pizza comes to mind. They are also OK but better because closer. I'll try again when the change the name for a third time.
It's The Pizza. It is just great pizza we have to make the trek 1 each week for pizza. The owners know our names and our special pizza is waiting for us. The crust and all the ingredients are just outstanding. The atmosphere may not be a 5 star but the pizza is and back in the New York metro area that is usually where you find the best meals. Lived in Chicago the pizza there was not for me just so glad to have New York or East Coast style pizza again.
Great!. We have tried the pizza, pasta, the knots.. The SAUCE is awesome! Everything has been wonderful! The staff is wonderful, friendly and very helpful. I ordered a pizza lunch for the teachers at my nieces school. They were very brought them everything they needed and were prompt and friendly. I am also ordering some pasta dishes for the Holidays!
Great pizza, but even better experience. I have only been to this pizzeria a couple of times, but every time I leave thinking that the people working there were friendly and they seem to enjoy working there. I like that feeling.
I travel the country and dont get the oppprtunity to get NY as much as i like. Everytime i come to Cincinnati, I make it a point to slide by Brookyln Pizza ( was Noce's ) to get a taste of authentic NY pizza. The food is great and Rich is always great for the latest sports talk... I feel at home when I'm here. Thank you guys! Keep it up... See you in 6 weeks!
Awesome. PIZZA WAS AWESOME! Waitress were so nice.....
'nuff said... Best. Pizza. Ever. We're from NY. We've been searching Cincinnati since we moved here for equivalent pizza, not to be found. Some places had it close. This one has it.
Great Pizza. The best pizza in cincinnati, just like NY style.
Pasta. I just tried the vegatable lasagna. Let me tellyou it was amazing.
Real New York Style. The pizza was amazing! I loved it.
Very low-key, mom n pop place. Nothing fancy but the food makes up for it. Friendly staff. A 10” 5-topping is a steal of a deal. Eggplant is a tasty topping option. They were not skimpy on the toppings in the least. Crust is done just right. We usually get lasagna and it’s packed full of meat! Hope you enjoy it as much as we do.
I love NY style pizza and when I get a craving this is the place! I'll be back again and again. The crust is just like you would get in NY city. The cheese is piled high its very stringy when you pullout a slice and they put lots of pepperoni and onions on.
We eat here every month or two, we absolutely love the calzones. Tonight we tried the “fried dough” for the first time ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE! Best $4 desert you will find anywhere. Serves 3-4 people, but 2 can finish it if you are committed!
Great food at a great price! And the staff is excellent 👌. But don't stop with just pizza. They have the best lasagna and to take there lasagna to another level they have the best vegetarian lasagna too.
Outstanding business!!! The food it’s incredible! Everything homemade, every bite it’s super tasteful and fresh. The pizzas are delicious, we also tried the wings and it was the best I ever had. The meatballs was so delicious!!!! We can’t wait to go back and try the pasta, they have so many options and I have no doubt everything in their menu taste incredible! Also the server was amazing, she made us feel so welcomed. For me it’s without a doubt the best pizza/pasta place in Cincinnati
Yum! Stopped in passing through town and we were quite pleased with the pizza! In house made pizza dough, nice sauce, quality toppings! Service was great even though it was extremely busy! We checked out other peoples meals as we left and all looked great! Definitely will be back next time in town!
Good food and good service. Trying local food is always good.
I wish they stayed a little late.
Stopped in on my way home from Cincinnati. It is what it says it is. Real New York style pizza. I ordered a large cheese and it was awesome. Crust was chewy and the sauce and cheese delicious. Highly recommended
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes