Sluurpy > Restaurants in Muskogee > American Pie Wood-fired Pizza

Review American Pie Wood-fired Pizza - Muskogee

Corey Perry-Kimball
Holy cow! Just moved back to Muskogee and I’m impressed! I got the margherita pizza and Stromboli! I just moved from Austin, TX and Minneapolis, MN before that so I know good food and this is good! Honestly you should pay more money for what you get. Very fresh and filling! I did get it as a takeout due to the pandemic but you can’t even tell!
Kestrel Goodnight
Ok, I didn't know this place existed. It's now my new favorite restaurant in town! The server was amazing, the pizza was spectacular, as was the appetizer. The price turned out less than I expected and the restaurant is uniquely if a bit sparsely decorated. The pictures attached are from the secondary dining room next door. Really, I have to say the price was very equal to the quality of the food. I would go so far as to say it was actually cheaper than it could be for what you get. The pizza offered here, is nothing you can get at a regular pizza chain and the crust is all made by hand and you can tell. That crust is amazing. The appetizer included a garlic hummus and it is thus far the only hummus my boys liked! It was probably the best I've ever had. I took a picture but I was not fast enough to get the picture before they had attacked it. Extra bread is only $1.00 and included 2 different types. A flat bread and a Baggett in slices. I will be back! They offer limited dine in and carry out at this time.
Keisha Patterson
Best Pizza ever. The food is amazing. The serves is always amazing. We love their crust. There is nothing like the taste of wood fire pizza.
Truth Ismyreligion
Amanda was amazing!!!!!! so was the food and always is! The charcuterie board is ALWAYS on point, the pineapple jalapeño sauce with the cheese gets me everytine. Its one of the best places in town. In fact may be my number one spot. Its all super quality food. Best pizza in town by FAR.
Brian B
Phenomenal pizza, no alcohol served though so better prime the pump before going.
Collin Owens
Friendly waitress, fast service and amazing food! My husband and I split an appetizer, pizza and desert. We had pizza left to take home and even some of our appetizer left as well. The pizza had a great flavor! The cheesecake was better than the Cheesecake Factory! We will enjoy this place again for a date night!
Colleen Noble
Great food and service. Love the pepperoni pizza.
Nathan Wood
This place still serves my all-time favorite pizza, a muffaletta pizza. We had one this past Monday, and it was still excellent. I hope they always continue serving it. They also serve a real mufaletta sandwich, but I enjoy the pizza so much I've never tried it. The rest of the family also enjoyed they're bruschetta pizza. There are some very interesting flavored pizza's here and you can make your own as well, and it's all heated and cooked in a wood fire oven. Simply wonderful. It's made by a Master Chef, so it comes with a higher price, but it is worth it.
Beth Hannah Schesny
THE best tasting pizza with the best choices in Muskogee. Tonight was my first experience eating there and it will not be my last. The service was awesome and it’s a very neat and clean restaurant, too. Thank you for the awesome food and wait staff! Simply the best in town �
Pat Landrum Gillham
� it. Second time I’ve been. The wait staff was on point and the pizza was delivered quickly to our table. She recommended the homemade chocolate crust cheesecake and it was divine. All in all a great experience.
Darrin Reed
Just had lunch there. So glad we picked it! Whitney, our server, was great! The food was terrific. The music was really good and the decor was fun (A Christmas Story leg lamp made my day!). Great place!
Kristi Spindle
The best place to have pizza, hands down. Easy parking, handicap access, beautiful atmosphere and the best food, from appetizers to dessert. Go there now!
Sebastian Fitzgerald
I've been here with my Marine Veteran Dad, my brother, and my lovely daughter and they've always treated us like family. I'll always recommend a homely and welcoming place, especially when the food is phenomenal. Extra Garlic please!!
Nicole Stewart Swanson
Wonderful pizza, amazing sauce, friendly staff, fantastically furnished and ICE COLD beer! It was worth the drive. Love from Fort Smith, AR.
Rae Cox
Hands down best pizza Muskogee has to offer. The three meet pizza was good, but the winner of the night was the Chipotle chicken bacon ranch. Oh and try the pesto its amazing. Will definitely be back!
Kathy Hearn Wiley
We ate there today with friends and all of us love it. Everything was great, the food and the staff. We will go back! And I didn't even mention the salted caramel cheese cake, Wonderful!
Michele Boyd
Delicious food & great atmosphere 💯 highly recommend this place!!!!
Josh Standridge
Good food and it's nice to not have to drive all the way to tulsa to get great pizza. Definitely a repeat customer.
Danny-Sheila Upton
Great pizza and we loved the cheesecake! My husband and I were pleasantly surprised to find this place in Muskogee. We had great service by our waitress, too!
Bailey Smith
The atmosphere sets the mood for a GREAT dining experience. The brisket pizza is everything!! The Greek salad is so so good and fresh. Our favorite place in town!
Becca Terry
Great food and even better service! Definitely recommend!
2 Enchilada Lunch Special 2 Meat Combo 3 Meat Alfredo Alfredo Pizza All You Can Eat BBQ All You Can Eat Dinner Sliced Brisket Chopped and Hot Links Apple pie Arby's Signature Sandwiches Arby's We Have the Meats Avocado Ball Salad and Crazy Roll Avocado Salad Bacon Egg & Cheese Biscuit Bacon Egg nd Cheese Sandwich w Pancakes Bacon Ham and Cheddar Pizza Beef Beef Bean Rice Burrito with Avocado and Cream Cheese Belly buster Big a Breakfast and Chicken Fried Steak Breakfast Big Mac Biggest Baddest Cuban Sandwich Birria Taco’S Biscuits and Gravy Black Eyed Peas Blackened Catfish Brisket Sandwich with Fries Bruschetta Board Buffalo Chicken Pizza Burger Burger King Chicken Nuggets Burnt Ends Dinner Burrito Burrito California with Jalapenos Steak Burritos Jalisco Cakes Calamari Calzone Carnitas Carrot Cake Catfish Ceviche de camaron Cheese Dip cheese pizza Cheeseburger Cheesecake Chicken and Vegetable Tempura Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Chicken Courdon Blue Chicken fried steak Chicken Mcnuggets Chicken Quesadillas Chicken Sandwich chicken teriyaki Chili Chips & Margaritas Chips & Salsa Chips and Salsa Chocolate Calizone Chocolate Cream Pie Chopped Brisket - Pound Clear Soup Club Lunch Burrito Club Sándwich Crawfish Cupcake Cupcakes Curry Double Fajitas Dragon and Dynamite Roll Dumplings Enchilada Night English Muffin with Strawberry Preserves Fajita Nachos Fajitas Fajitas del Mar Fire Island Roll and Firecracker Roll Fish Fish Bites Fish Sandwich Fish Taco Flautas and Margarita French Dip and Sauce French Fries Fresh Salads Fried chicken Fried Onion Strings and Pickes Fried pickles Fried Shrimp Garlic Cheese Bread Sticks Giant Margarita Gnocchi Gorgonzola Salad Greek salad Gyoza 6 Half of My Order of Fries Half Order Onion Strings and Half Order Fried Pickles Hamburgers Hawaiian Roll Lobster Roll Firecracker Roll Homemade Mac and Cheese Homemade Pork Rinds Ice Cream Indian Tacos Italian Sausage Pepperoni Kani Salad Kids Mini Corn Dogs with Fries Lasagna Dinner Lasagne Lemon Icebox Pie Loaded Curly Fries Loaded French Fries Lomac a Cheese Lopez Quesadillas Lunch Fajitas Margherita Pizza Margueritas Medium Mcdouble Mcflurry with Oreo Cookies Mcmuffin Meatballs Meatloaf Miso Soup Mocojete Molcajete Muskogee Special and Flautas Dinner with Rice and Beans Nachos Supremos Noodle Oklahoma Roll 10 pcs Our French Toast Pad Thai Pancake Pancakes Pasta Patty Melt Pepper Tuna Pepperoni Pizza Peppers Personal Pizza Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie Pimento Dip Pineapple Fajitas Pork Katsu Prime rib Pulled Pork and Burnt Ends with Baked Beans and Coleslaw Queso Ribs Ribs and Bread Only Roast Beef Roast Beef and Chicken Ranch Sandwiches Roast Beef Sandwich Runt's Brisket Salad Salad Salad bar Salmon Skin Roll Sandwiches Sashimi Sausage Pizza Scrambled eggs Shrimp Shrimp Chimichanga Shrimp Fajitas Shrimp Tacos Side Salad Sliced Brisket w 1 Side Southern Omelet with Grits and a Biscuit Spaghetti & Meatballs Spicy Tuna and Tuna Roll Spinach and Artichoke Dip Spinach Salad Strawberry daiquiri Street Tacos Taco and Guacamole Salad Taco salad Tacos Tacos de Carne Asada Tapas Teppanyaki The Sloppy Hogg Three Meat Pizza Toasts Top Shelf Fajita Top Shelf Margarita Volcano Roll 8 pcs White Queso Wings Wood-Fired Pizzas
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review