The food, atmosphere and service is 5 star 💯 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. Greeted promptly with a welcoming smile. Our server Chase was attentive and knowledgeable of the menue items.
The lobster presentation was impeccable and a perfection in teamwork.
The Pittsburgh sear of my filet was the best execution I've ev
Classic upscale steak restaurant with seafood apps and decadent desserts. The steaks had a hard sear and were cooked to temp very well. We prefer far more seasoning across the board on steaks and sides to bring out flavor as very little salt was detectable in most dishes. The onion rings were intere
First time here. We watched YouTube videos about this place so we came
The food was good and the service was outstanding. Rocko, our server was very attentive and professional. Our valet Brooklyn was as well. The food was good. I like my steaks to arrive singing (sizzling) . It was just on a hot pl
The steaks were cooked properly. They just lacked a little seasoning. Our server was spectacular. Spot on with recommendations and warned us about serving sizes
I took my wife here for our 2 year anniversary and we both had a great time. The menu is a la carte and the food is delicious. You'll easily spend $50-100 per person so be prepared. The steaks are done to your liking and the sides are big enough for two people. We tried the cheesy mashed potatoes an
I don’t know what’s better, the food or the service. They bring out bread from a local bakery to start your meal. I always have to start with their chopped Italian salad. The filet mignon and the Chilean seabass can’t be beat as an entree. All of the sides are phenomenal but the cheese mashed potato
The food and service were both top notch. Barrel aged Manhattan could use some work (coming from Kentucky folk). The seafood sampler was to die for! We took our two young sons and they devoured the baked shrimp, shrimp cocktail, and decadent seafood bisque. We will definitely be back.
Very good place. Def don't need anything for your steak as it tastes amazing and juicy just as it is after being cooked. The asparagus was really good also. I also got a half dozen oysters. They was good. But a couple of them was small and whoever shucked them I give them like 4 out 5. Still had bit
This is a A1 place Chris the connoisseur was a magnificent host The Food top of the line the atmosphere very mature. Elegant. Dinner for my wife and I on our 3 year Anniversary. New York Prime made it unforgettable. Thank you Sincerely Darren Hubbard
Hands down the BEST steak house I have experienced. The food is amazing and the service is exceptional. Special shout out to Jesse, he was our server on 12/15 in the evening and exudes the definition of professional, and impeccable customer service. We plan to visit again and would only want Jesse t
WOW!! This place was amazing from entry to exit. The server we had, Trayson, was amazing and nice and got everything perfect. The food was fabulous! Cooked to perfection and the Brussel Sprouts are to die for!
This was our first dining experience and it was great! Laura was our server and she provided great recommendations. The food was top quality and prepared perfect. They offered excellent cocktail and wine choices. Valet service was great. Management came around and talked with us. It was just an over
Service and the meal were some of the best we ever had. Our waiter was excellent and very helpful. The steaks were fantastic and cooked to perfection. As other reviewers have mentioned prepare to spend $100 per person. Absolutely outstanding dinner and about 1 block off the ocean.
This is the place you want to go to as part of a bachelor party or other big dinner out. I did not expect NY Prime to really come too close to a real NYC steakhouse but they did an incredible job. I was very satisfied with my meal, as was the rest of my large group. Our table ordered drinks, apps, s
My daughter took me to NY Prime for their special Mother's Day brunch. We had the crab/shrimp filled crepes, maple bacon and hashbrowns. Everything was delicious and we were stuffed. The service was first class. You can tell they've trained the staff for fine dining service.
Phenomenal experience. We had a fantastic server Jesse, and the food was superb. I had the 12 oz filet and it originally came to the table a little under. Jesse brought it back to the kitchen for a more accurate med-rare. The steak arrived back to the table a PERFECT med-rare. The mashed potatoes we
22 oz. Bone-in ribeye deserves 6 stars. Perfectly cooked and seared.
Read this as a 4.5. Service very nice. Wine list and cocktails very good. Potatoes were incredible, spinach mediocre. Steaks very very good and perfectly cooked. Wedge was on point with the incredible blue cheese. Banana cream pie, very good. Just a really loud place. $300 for 2 to totally indulge!
The steak, bread, salad and white choc banana cream pie was amazing! We did not like the steak fries at all no flavor. Drinks were great. Atmosphere is ok but was very tight where it was seated. Waiter was amazing!!! Very professional!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes